The United States is facing resistance from the European Union over plans to expand its AI supply chain alliance, Pax Silica, into a broader economic security framework. EU countries have raised concerns, citing vague definitions, a terminology clash over superintelligence and risks to their regulatory autonomy.
Washington wants members of Pax Silica, a US-led coalition designed to secure supply chains for AI, semiconductors and critical minerals, to endorse a declaration at a ceremony in San Francisco on Sunday. The declaration states that “economic security is fundamental to national security, and that no nation can be secure without securing its critical systems and technologies from those that would do it harm.”
The EU joined the initiative in June despite reservations from France, after several member states had already signed up individually. But the latest proposals have revived divisions within the bloc.
The declaration calls for a “common understanding” on protecting sensitive technologies and critical infrastructure by diversifying supply chains and coordinating responses to economic coercion. It argues that “durable economic security among trusted partners rests not on professions of friendship alone, but on the vigilant protection of the foundations on which our economies depend and on the active promotion of shared innovation and technological leadership.”
EU concerns are rooted partly in Washington’s previous attempts to restrict access to advanced AI technology. The Biden administration introduced export controls under its AI Diffusion Framework in 2025 that would have limited access to the most advanced AI chips for several EU countries. The Trump administration scrapped the measures shortly before they were due to take effect, but they were seen as a signal that Washington did not consider some EU countries sufficiently aligned with its approach to China.
One sticking point in the latest declaration is its broad definition of sensitive technologies and critical infrastructure. Some EU member states are demanding objective criteria, fearing the current wording would give Washington considerable discretion to impose restrictions and pressure allies to follow suit.
Another dispute centres on terminology. Trump is pushing the concept of superintelligence, while the European Commission has proposed an explanatory note clarifying that the EU understands the term to mean artificial intelligence, as defined in key EU legislation such as the Artificial Intelligence Act. Washington has long opposed the AI Act and is now proposing a Pax Silica working group to explore innovation-friendly regulatory approaches.
On Wednesday, EU governments gave the Commission a mandate to represent the bloc and negotiate the content of the declaration with the US. However, the Commission may not receive a mandate to sign it in time for the San Francisco ceremony.
“We affirm that the safeguarding of these sensitive technologies and critical infrastructure is a shared endeavour; that the security of each signatory is strengthened by the vigilance of all; and that we engage in this common cause as trusted partners,” the text concludes.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The outcome will shape whether the US can enforce a unified technology bloc against China, directly affecting investment and trade rules for AI and semiconductors.
- The dispute over terminology (superintelligence vs AI) could create legal uncertainty for companies operating under both US-led and EU regulatory frameworks.
- EU resistance may slow US efforts to restrict technology transfers, giving China more time to develop its own AI capabilities.
Background
Pax Silica is a US-led coalition formed to secure supply chains for AI, semiconductors and critical minerals. The EU joined in June 2026 after several member states had already signed up individually. The Trump administration has sought to strengthen the alliance as part of a broader economic security strategy, following Biden-era export controls that were scrapped before taking effect. The EU’s Artificial Intelligence Act, passed earlier, sets binding rules for AI systems, creating a regulatory divergence with the US.
Key Perspectives
United States (Trump administration): Pushes for a shared commitment to protect sensitive technologies and infrastructure, arguing no nation can be secure without securing critical systems; proposes a Pax Silica working group to explore innovation-friendly regulatory approaches.
Some EU member states: Express concern that the declaration’s broad definition of sensitive technologies gives Washington too much discretion to impose restrictions and pressure allies; demand objective criteria.
European Commission: Proposes an explanatory note clarifying that the EU understands “superintelligence” to mean artificial intelligence, to align the declaration with existing EU law and avoid legal uncertainty.
France: Had reservations about joining Pax Silica in June, though the EU ultimately joined.
What to Watch
- Whether EU member states grant the Commission a mandate to sign the declaration before the San Francisco ceremony on Sunday.
- The outcome of the terminology dispute over superintelligence; could set a precedent for how the US and EU define emerging AI capabilities.
- Whether the US, in future negotiations, softens its stance on the AI Act or seeks bilateral agreements with individual EU states.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 11 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedThe US push to expand Pax Silica into a broader economic security pact faces EU resistance.Euronews: “The US wants to turn Pax Silica, its AI supply chain alliance, into a wider economic security pact, to be endorsed in San Francisco on Sunday. EU countries have raised concerns”
- SupportedWashington wants Pax Silica members to endorse the declaration at a San Francisco ceremony on Sunday.Euronews: “Washington wants members of Pax Silica, a US-led coalition designed to secure supply chains for AI, semiconductors and critical minerals, to endorse the declaration at a ceremony in San Francisco on Sunday.”
- SupportedEU countries have concerns about vague definitions, terminology over superintelligence and regulatory autonomy.Euronews: “EU countries have raised concerns, citing vague definitions, a terminology clash over superintelligence and risks to their regulatory autonomy.”
- Partly supportedThe declaration states that “economic security is fundamental to national security, and that no nation can be secure without securing its critical systems and technologies from those that would do it harm.”Euronews: “The latest draft of a US declaration, discussed by EU ambassadors on Wednesday and seen by Euronews, states that “economic security is fundamental to national security, and that no nation can be secure without securing its critical systems and technologies from those that would do it harm.””
- SupportedThe declaration says durable economic security among trusted partners rests on protecting economic foundations and promoting shared innovation and technological leadership.Euronews: ““durable economic security among trusted partners rests not on professions of friendship alone, but on the vigilant protection of the foundations on which our economies depend and on the active promotion of shared innovation and technological leadership.””
- SupportedThe EU joined Pax Silica in June despite French reservations, after several member states had signed up individually.Euronews: “The EU joined the initiative in June despite reservations from France, after several member states had already signed up individually.”
- SupportedIn 2025, the Biden administration introduced AI Diffusion Framework export controls that would have limited several EU countries’ access to the most advanced AI chips.Euronews: “In 2025, the Biden administration introduced export controls under its AI Diffusion Framework that would have limited access to the most advanced AI chips for several EU countries.”
- SupportedThe Trump administration scrapped those measures shortly before they were due to take effect.Euronews: “The Trump administration scrapped the measures shortly before they were due to take effect”
- SupportedSome EU member states want objective criteria for sensitive technologies and critical infrastructure, fearing the wording could give Washington discretion to impose restrictions and pressure allies.Euronews: “Some EU member states are demanding objective criteria, fearing that the current wording would give Washington considerable discretion to impose restrictions and pressure its allies to follow suit.”
- SupportedTrump is pushing the concept of superintelligence, while the Commission has proposed a note clarifying that the EU understands the term to mean AI.Euronews: “Trump is pushing the concept of superintelligence, while the European Commission has proposed an explanatory note clarifying that the EU understands the term to mean artificial intelligence.”
- SupportedThe text concludes that safeguarding sensitive technologies and critical infrastructure is a shared endeavour among trusted partners.Euronews: ““We affirm that the safeguarding of these sensitive technologies and critical infrastructure is a shared endeavour; that the security of each signatory is strengthened by the vigilance of all; and that we engage in this common cause as trusted partners,” the text concludes.”
- SupportedOn Wednesday, EU governments gave the Commission a mandate to represent the bloc and negotiate the declaration with the US, but it may not get authority to sign in time for the ceremony.Euronews: “On Wednesday, EU governments gave the Commission a mandate to represent the bloc and negotiate the content of the declaration with the US. But the Commission might not receive a mandate to sign it in time for the San Francisco ceremony.”