The CBO's detailed analysis, released on Friday, found the US submarine industrial base is struggling to meet existing demand, and 'increasing production further to replace SSNs [attack submarines] sold to Australia would increase the challenges that the Navy and the shipyards are facing.' The report concluded that 'the sale of SSNs to Australia would reduce the number of attack submarines available to the Navy for many years.'
The US Navy's latest shipbuilding plan does not factor in the Aukus agreement, noting only in a footnote that the transfer of any Virginia-class submarine to Australia 'has not been factored into the plan,' the report says.
Under the 'Pillar One' of Aukus, the US has agreed to sell between three and five in-service Virginia-class submarines to Australia, beginning in 2032.
The CBO questioned whether any submarines transferred to Australia could be used in the event of a US conflict with China. 'Would China be less deterred if the United States reduced the number of its attack submarines to help Australia develop its own submarine force?' the report asked. It argued that the loss of US capability might even be more than offset because Australian submarines would be based in the Western Pacific and could respond more quickly, but noted that 'Australia would control its own submarines, and their participation in any particular conflict would not be guaranteed.'
In 2023, Australian Defence Minister Richard Marles said Australia would make no promises to deploy its submarines in support of any US conflict with China, and that any future Australian submarines would be under the complete control of the Australian government of the day. Marles said earlier this month: 'Aukus is happening, our alliance is happening, and all of that continues unimpeded.'
The report also highlighted delays in US submarine construction. Virginia-class submarines are currently being built at a rate of 1.13 a year; a rate of two a year is needed for America's own needs, and 2.33 a year to also supply Australia. Building times have stretched from five to six years in the 2000s to an average of 10 to 11 years, according to current schedules, it said.
US legislation governing Aukus says the president can transfer a submarine to Australia only if losing it from US service will not degrade US undersea capabilities. The US can refuse to transfer any submarines to Australia without penalty under the Aukus agreement.
Critics have questioned whether the US will have the capacity to sell any in-service submarines to Australia. Former foreign affairs minister Bob Carr told Guardian Australia both countries were 'living a lie' in upholding the fiction that the deal would happen. 'It's now conventional wisdom in Washington as well as in Canberra that we're not going to get the subs,' he said.
The deal has bipartisan political support in both countries. US Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth affirmed his support for the agreement and the two countries' commitment 'to advance the alliance and strengthen deterrence in the Pacific' at a meeting with Marles in September.
The US Congressional Research Service has considered an alternative arrangement in which submarines earmarked for Australia would be retained under US command and sailed out of Australian bases. Its report argued that US-commanded vessels could be immediately deployed in a conflict or crisis with China over Taiwan.