Used electric vehicles defy depreciation fears as fuel prices surge

Australian auction sees bidding frenzy for repairable BYD EVs, with salvage prices far exceeding petrol equivalents amid cost-of-living pressures

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time2 min
Sources2 outlets
Used electric vehicles are holding their value far better than expected in Australia, with a recent auction of repairable EVs sparking a bidding frenzy as soaring petrol prices from the Iran conflict and cost-of-living pressures drive buyers toward cheaper-to-run alternatives.

The shift was starkly illustrated at a late-March auction run by asset sales company Pickles, where insurers sent 40 BYD vehicles that had been splattered with concrete but were repairable. With fuel prices rising sharply in response to the US and Israel war on Iran, the auction drew intense demand.

"We had thousands of buyers trying to bid on about 40 cars, so just the prices we generated were incredible," said Brendon Green, Pickles' general manager of automotive solutions. "The amount of views that we got on those cars, the bidders that registered and the amount of bids that we took were extraordinary compared to what we would typically see."

Salvage EVs with pre-accident values of up to $40,000 fetched substantially higher prices than comparable combustion models, according to the auction house. Written-off EVs sold for spare parts and second-life batteries achieved 16% higher sale results than petrol equivalents, while repairable write-offs generated a 71% price premium.

The trend is being driven by financial considerations as much as environmental ones. More EVs than petrol-only cars were sold in September, according to Federal Chamber of Automotive Industries data, supported by an influx of low-priced Chinese brands. The Iran conflict and associated enduring oil price rise accelerated demand from March and it has continued.

Rob Chan, managing director of car rental marketplace Turo Australia, said customer demand for EVs and hybrids has rocketed, with bookings growing at 28 times the pace of petrol and diesel over the past year. In response, Turo "hosts" are buying secondhand EVs to meet that demand.

The strong resale performance overturns earlier warnings from sceptics that used EVs would rapidly depreciate and become worthless.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • For Australian car buyers, the improved resale value of EVs reduces total cost of ownership, making them a more viable option even without government subsidies.
  • The data challenges a common anti-EV argument about depreciation, potentially accelerating the transition away from petrol vehicles.
  • Geopolitical instability and fuel price volatility are directly reshaping consumer behaviour in the car market.

Background

For years, sceptics have warned that used electric vehicles would depreciate rapidly due to battery degradation and technological obsolescence, creating a financial risk for buyers. High upfront costs of new EVs also fuelled that concern. But a combination of factors—rising petrol prices driven by the conflict in the Middle East, cost-of-living pressures, and an influx of affordable Chinese EV brands—has flipped that narrative in Australia. The result is a surge in demand for secondhand EVs, which is now reflected in auction prices and rental marketplace bookings.

Key Perspectives

[EV buyers and owners]: They benefit from higher resale values, which lower the effective cost of ownership and strengthen the financial case for switching from petrol. [Insurers and salvage operators]: Higher auction prices for damaged EVs mean insurers can recoup more from written-off vehicles, potentially influencing premiums and repair-or-write-off decisions. [Petrol car owners and sellers]: They face the prospect that petrol vehicles—once seen as safer bets—may now carry greater depreciation risk as fuel costs remain elevated and buyer preferences shift.

What to Watch

  • Whether the resale premium for EVs holds if oil prices fall or the Iran conflict de-escalates.
  • Battery health and second-life battery markets: sustained value depends on confidence in battery longevity.
  • Any changes to government incentives or import tariffs on Chinese EVs that could affect new and used prices.

Sources

Zotpaper

Written by software from the reporting listed above, scored by an automated standards desk, and published without a person reading it first. If something here is wrong, tell the editor and it will be put right.

How we workSubscribe