Vanuatu's government says it has initiated separate international legal proceedings against France over the sovereignty of Matthew and Hunter islands, including an arbitration under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS); France has not yet accepted the jurisdiction of the International Court of Justice, effectively blocking the case from proceeding.
The Vanuatu Daily Post reports the legal actions follow two rounds of failed negotiations with Paris over the two uninhabited islands.
In August, Vanuatu filed an application before the International Court of Justice seeking to determine the sovereignty of Matthew and Hunter, as well as the establishment of a single maritime boundary between Vanuatu and New Caledonia. Deputy Prime Minister Johnny Koanapo said France had not accepted the jurisdiction of the ICJ, effectively blocking the case from proceeding.
Koanapo told Parliament that the government commenced a separate arbitration proceeding against France under UNCLOS in October. Unlike the ICJ application, the UNCLOS referral does not depend on France's agreement to participate for the arbitration to commence. The arbitration would seek to determine what maritime entitlements can lawfully be generated by France's maritime claims in the waters between Vanuatu and New Caledonia.
Koanapo said the government's legal actions over Matthew and Hunter are not acts of hostility against France, and that Vanuatu seeks dialogue and remains open to a peaceful resolution.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The dispute tests the limits of UNCLOS arbitration when a state party refuses to participate, potentially setting a precedent for other Pacific sovereignty claims.
- The outcome could affect maritime boundaries and resource rights in a region where tuna fisheries and seabed minerals are economically vital.
- The case adds diplomatic pressure on France amid ongoing tensions in New Caledonia, where independence movements remain active.
Background
Matthew and Hunter are small, uninhabited islands about 300 kilometres east of New Caledonia. Both Vanuatu and France claim sovereignty over them, a dispute that has simmered for decades. Vanuatu has pursued diplomatic talks and now legal avenues, while France has so far declined to accept the ICJ's jurisdiction.
What to Watch
- Whether the UNCLOS arbitration tribunal proceeds to a ruling despite France's likely non-participation.
- France's official response, both to the arbitration and to any renewed diplomatic overtures from Vanuatu.
- Any developments in New Caledonia's political status, which could affect the maritime boundary question.
Checked
11 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 10 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedVanuatu has launched a second legal front against France in the sovereignty dispute.RNZ New Zealand Headlines: “Vanuatu initiates legal action on second front in territorial dispute with France”
- SupportedVanuatu initiated an UNCLOS arbitration against France.RNZ New Zealand Headlines: “Koanapo told Parliament that the government commenced a separate arbitration proceeding against France under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) in October.”
- Partly supportedFrance has not yet accepted ICJ jurisdiction, effectively blocking the case from proceeding.RNZ New Zealand Headlines: “Vanuatu's Deputy Prime Minister, Johnny Koanapo, said France had not yet accepted the jurisdiction of the ICJ, effectively blocking the case from proceeding.”
- SupportedVanuatu's government says it initiated two separate international legal proceedings against France over Matthew and Hunter's sovereignty.RNZ New Zealand Headlines: “Vanuatu's government says it has initiated two separate international legal proceedings against France over the sovereignty of Matthew and Hunter islands.”
- SupportedThe legal actions followed two rounds of failed negotiations with Paris over the islands.RNZ New Zealand Headlines: “The Vanuatu Daily Post reports this comes after two rounds of negotiations failed to reach a solution to Vanuatu's dispute with Paris over the two uninhabited islands.”
- SupportedIn August, Vanuatu filed an ICJ application seeking a decision on sovereignty over Matthew and Hunter.RNZ New Zealand Headlines: “In August, Vanuatu filed an application against France before the International Court of Justice (ICJ) seeking to determine the sovereignty of Matthew and Hunter.”
- SupportedThe ICJ case also seeks to establish a single maritime boundary between Vanuatu and New Caledonia.RNZ New Zealand Headlines: “The ICJ case also seeks to determine the establishment of a single maritime boundary between Vanuatu and New Caledonia.”
- SupportedDeputy Prime Minister Johnny Koanapo told Parliament that the government commenced the UNCLOS arbitration in October.RNZ New Zealand Headlines: “Koanapo told Parliament that the government commenced a separate arbitration proceeding against France under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) in October.”
- SupportedThe UNCLOS referral does not depend on France agreeing to participate for arbitration to commence.RNZ New Zealand Headlines: “Unlike the ICJ application, the UNCLOS referral does not depend on France's agreement to participate in order for the arbitration to commence.”
- SupportedThe arbitration would seek to determine what maritime entitlements France's maritime claims can lawfully generate in the waters between Vanuatu and New Caledonia.RNZ New Zealand Headlines: “UNCLOS arbitration would seek to determine what maritime entitlements can lawfully be generated by France's maritime claims in the waters between Vanuatu and New Caledonia.”
- SupportedKoanapo said the legal actions are not hostile acts against France and that Vanuatu seeks dialogue and remains open to a peaceful resolution.RNZ New Zealand Headlines: “Koanapo said the government's legal actions over Matthew and Hunter are not acts of hostility against France, and that Vanuatu seeks dialogue and remains open to a peaceful resolution.”