Opposition Leader Jess Wilson has won the vote of undecided voters at the only leaders' debate of the Victorian election campaign, taking 39 per cent support to Premier Ben Carroll's 7 per cent, as the four contenders clashed over costings, trust and crime in a fiery forum.
The News24 and Herald Sun “People's Forum” at Melbourne's Sofitel Hotel on Tuesday night was the campaign's only debate featuring all four leaders. Early voting begins Wednesday ahead of the November 28 poll.
The audience comprised 100 undecided voters. A poll of the audience as they left put Wilson well ahead, with Greens leader Ellen Sandell on 25 per cent, One Nation's Warren Pickering on 16 per cent and Carroll on 7 per cent.
Wilson goaded Carroll over his reluctance to name his Labor predecessors, Daniel Andrews and Jacinta Allan. “You can say his name, it's OK,” Wilson said. “It's not Voldemort.” Carroll shot back that Wilson could not name Jeff Kennett. “Jeff Kennett,” Wilson immediately retorted to audience laughter.
The pair clashed over financial management. Wilson told Carroll: “I won't be lectured by you or your government on costings when you have racked up $200 billion worth of debt in this state.” Wilson also left the door open to scrapping the Suburban Rail Loop, telling moderator Kieran Gilbert a Coalition government would conduct a review. “That's exactly what the review is for,” she said.
Pickering described the state as “Gotham City” due to rising crime and said he would send offenders to a New South Wales supermax if prisons were full. Sandell, who placed second in the room vote, criticised the other parties over their funding. “If you're wondering why you can't afford your groceries or your rent or to buy a home, just look at who is funding these three other parties,” she said.
The mood of voters who feel politicians have forgotten about the people they serve was captured by Billy, one of the 100 undecided voters, who told the panel: “Nobody believes a word you're saying any more, and it's fundamental. No fun, and mostly mental.” While Wilson won the room, The Age's online poll, with more than 5500 votes cast, found 48 per cent thought Carroll had won, followed by Wilson and Sandell on 23 per cent.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The debate was the campaign's sole head-to-head comparison, offering a sharply defined choice for the significant number of voters still undecided.
- Wilson's strong room result reinforces the Coalition's lead in the polls as she tries to end 12 years of Labor rule.
- Carroll's poor showing among the undecided confirms Labor's struggle to rebuild trust, while Sandell's 25 per cent signals the Greens can shape the post-election landscape in inner Melbourne.
Background
The Victorian state election is scheduled for November 28. Labor has governed since 2014 under three different leaders. The Coalition, led by Jess Wilson, entered the campaign ahead in opinion polls but with a primary vote sitting at about 30 per cent, making the final result uncertain. One Nation is contesting lower house seats in Victoria for the first time, and the Greens are seeking to expand their inner-city base. The debate was the only opportunity for all four leaders to appear together after negotiations for other television forums failed.
Key Perspectives
- Jess Wilson (Liberal): argued Victoria needs a "fresh start" after 12 years of Labor and emphasised plans to reduce debt, cut taxes and recruit 3000 police officers. She left the door open to scrapping the Suburban Rail Loop.
- Ben Carroll (Labor): leant into Labor's record on health and education, listing 121 new schools and nurse-to-patient ratios, while acknowledging the government "got some things wrong".
- Ellen Sandell (Greens): attacked corporate donations and wealth inequality, calling the major parties beholden to "vampire" data centres, property developers and the gambling industry.
- Warren Pickering (One Nation): pitched himself as a political outsider, promising to abolish the Voice and scrap net zero targets, and vowed to lock up more offenders even if it meant using interstate jails.
What to Watch
- Early voting opens Wednesday. The debate's impact on the final 11 days will test whether Wilson can translate her strong polling into a majority government.
- Carroll's ability to recover from a weak debate showing will determine whether Labor can hold its base in the face of a confident Coalition and a surging Greens party.
- Sandell's performance could drive a late swing against Labor in inner-city seats, potentially leading to a hung parliament where the Greens hold the balance of power.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 2 sources: 11 supported.
Show each claim
- Reports differWilson led the audience poll with 39 per cent, while Carroll received 7 per cent; the story presents it as a vote of undecided voters.World news | The Guardian: “The audience members were polled as they left the Sofitel, with 39% saying Wilson had won the debate, followed by Sandell on 25% and Pickering on 16%. ... only 7% picked Carroll.”
- SupportedThe four leaders debated on Tuesday at Melbourne’s Sofitel Hotel, in the campaign’s only agreed debate, before an audience of 100 undecided voters.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “On Tuesday night, the leaders of Victoria’s four most popular political parties gathered at Melbourne’s Sofitel Hotel to debate each other before next Saturday’s election. It is the only debate they have agreed to in this campaign.”
- SupportedEarly voting begins Wednesday ahead of the November 28 election.World news | The Guardian: “with early voting opening on Wednesday”
- SupportedWilson told Carroll, “You can say his name, it's OK,” and, “It's not Voldemort.”Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: ““You can say his name, it’s OK,” Wilson teased. ... Wilson: “It’s not Voldemort.””
- SupportedCarroll shot back that Wilson could not name Jeff Kennett.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: ““Just like you can’t say Jeff Kennett’s name,” Carroll shot back. “Jeff Kennett,” Wilson replied to laughter from the audience.”
- SupportedWilson told Carroll, “I won't be lectured by you or your government on costings when you have racked up $200 billion worth of debt in this state.”World news | The Guardian: ““But Ben, I won’t be lectured by you or your government on costings when you have racked up $200bn worth of debt in this state.””
- SupportedWilson said of a review of the Suburban Rail Loop, “That's exactly what the review is for.”World news | The Guardian: “Asked by moderator Kieran Gilbert if the Coalition would be willing to scrap the project and move on, Wilson said: “That’s exactly what the review is for.””
- SupportedPickering described the state as “Gotham City” because of rising crime.World news | The Guardian: “Then there was One Nation’s Victorian leader, Warren Pickering, who said the state resembled “Gotham City” because of rising crime”
- SupportedPickering said he would send offenders to a New South Wales supermax if prisons were full.World news | The Guardian: ““I don’t give a damn if our prisons are full. You’ve broken the law. You’re going to jail. They’re bringing in a supermax in New South Wales. That’s where you’re bloody going,” he said.”
- SupportedSandell said, “If you're wondering why you can't afford your groceries or your rent or to buy a home, just look at who is funding these three other parties.”World news | The Guardian: ““If you’re wondering why you can’t afford your groceries or your rent or to buy a home, just look at who is funding these three other parties,” Sandell said.”
- SupportedBilly told the panel, “Nobody believes a word you're saying any more, and it's fundamental. No fun, and mostly mental.”Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: ““Nobody believes a word you’re saying any more, and it’s fundamental. No fun, and mostly mental.””
- SupportedThe Age's online poll had 48 per cent saying Carroll won, with Wilson and Sandell on 23 per cent each.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “In our own poll of The Age’s readers, with more than 5500 votes cast in the half an hour after the debate, 48 per cent think Carroll won the debate, with Wilson and Sandell tied on 23 per cent”