A Victorian company whose dealings with a Western Australian official were found on the balance of probabilities to involve a corrupt exchange of benefits and work, with messages describing the contracts as having inflated margins, has continued working on state Labor’s Big Build program, with Victoria’s peak infrastructure agency declining to explain why.
Vicflow, a civil works contractor, has remained a subcontractor on the Eastern Freeway upgrade in Melbourne despite damning graft findings from Western Australia’s Corruption and Crime Commission tabled in parliament on October 1. The commission concluded that Vicflow paid kickbacks to Shire of East Pilbara manager Bevan Klein to secure millions of dollars of contracts in the remote WA region. On October 26, West Australian police charged one of the firm’s two Victorian directors, Richard Carroll, with bribery offences. One suspected bribery scheme involved an inflated purchase of a ute from Klein in return for contracts worth more than $5 million.
The Victorian Infrastructure Delivery Authority (VIDA) was asked by The Age why Vicflow was still a Big Build subcontractor and whether any steps had been taken in light of the corruption findings. VIDA provided no specific response, saying only that it “continues to engage with its contractors to strengthen integrity controls and is committed to fully co-operating with the royal commission and supporting its inquiry into integrity on construction sites”. The statement came hours before the Kourakis royal commission lashed VIDA for failing to fully co-operate, accusing it of stalling the release of key documents about suspected wrongdoing on Big Build projects.
Text messages between Vicflow directors, detailed in the corruption commission’s report, revealed a 2022 scheme in which the firm paid $40,000 for Klein’s 2014 Mitsubishi Triton valued at $17,000. “We can pay overs for a shit box and he gets the cash,” Carroll said in one text. In another, the allegedly corruptly procured contracts were described as having “fat as f---” margins. The corruption commission’s report also included admissions from Vicflow managers that they had given Klein seafood, clothes vouchers, a computer, power tools and $12,500 in cash. The WA Crime and Corruption Commission said it was satisfied on the balance of probabilities that the relationship involved a corrupt exchange.
Carroll is one of Vicflow’s two directors. The company has operated on the Big Build with a CFMEU-backed enterprise bargaining agreement signed off in 2022 and re-signed in 2025. On Sunday, Carroll refused to answer questions about the corruption commission’s report, saying “I’m not getting sucked into this” before hanging up. Fogarty could not be reached for comment.
The revelations add to a growing list of companies allowed to operate on the Big Build despite serious allegations of crime or graft. The Kourakis royal commission is examining suspected improper and nepotistic dealings that allowed select CFMEU subcontractors to win work at the expense of cheaper firms. Carroll and Klein are to reappear in a WA court in February.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- Taxpayer-funded infrastructure projects continue to employ contractors found by a corruption watchdog to have engaged in corrupt conduct, raising questions about oversight and accountability.
- The case highlights the absence of adequate fit-and-proper tests for government subcontractors, a gap that the Kourakis royal commission is examining.
- If such firms can operate with impunity, public confidence in major state infrastructure programs may be further eroded.
Background
The Big Build is a multibillion-dollar Victorian state government program of road and rail projects. The Kourakis royal commission is investigating allegations of union-linked corruption, improper subcontractor tendering, and organised crime infiltration on Big Build sites. The WA Corruption and Crime Commission’s two-year probe into Vicflow was triggered by a tip-off about bribery in the Pilbara.
Key Perspectives
WA Corruption and Crime Commission: concluded on the balance of probabilities that a corrupt exchange occurred between Shire of East Pilbara manager Bevan Klein and Vicflow, Klein received gifts and Vicflow received work, and said serious misconduct had occurred, though it cautioned that this was not a finding of criminal liability.
Victorian Infrastructure Delivery Authority: declined to explain why Vicflow remains a Big Build subcontractor, stating only that it continues to engage with contractors to strengthen integrity controls and is committed to co-operating with the royal commission.
Richard Carroll, Vicflow director: refused to answer questions about the corruption commission’s report and whether he had disclosed it to any contractor or VIDA, saying “I’m not getting sucked into this” before hanging up.
What to Watch
- The WA court reappearance of Carroll and Klein in February, which may produce further charges or plea details.
- The Kourakis royal commission’s next block of public hearings, which may examine whether Vicflow’s pattern of conduct mirrors other cases on Big Build sites.
- Whether VIDA or major contractors take any action to suspend or remove Vicflow from the Eastern Freeway upgrade.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedThe headline says a Victorian firm at the centre of Pilbara bribe allegations is still working on the Big Build.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “A Victorian company that bribed a West Australian official to win government contracts and extract “fat as” margins from infrastructure projects has remained working on state Labor’s Big Build program.”
- SupportedVicflow continues to work on the Eastern Freeway upgrade.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Vicflow has continued operating on the Eastern Freeway upgrade”
- SupportedVIDA declined to explain why Vicflow was still a Big Build subcontractor.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “The authority provided no specific response to the questions”
- SupportedThe WA commission was satisfied on the balance of probabilities that the relationship between Klein and the Vicflow companies involved a corrupt exchange of benefits and work.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “the relationship between Mr Klein and the Vicflow companies involved a corrupt exchange of benefits – Mr Klein received gifts from the Vicflow companies and the Vicflow companies received work sourced from Mr Klein”
- SupportedCarroll said in a text, “We can pay overs for a shit box and he gets the cash”.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: ““We can pay overs for a shit box and he gets the cash,” Carroll told Fogarty in the 2022 text about the deal”
- SupportedA text described the allegedly corruptly procured contracts as having “fat as f---” margins.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “the allegedly corruptly procured contracts were described as having “fat as f---” margins”
- SupportedVIDA said it “continues to engage with its contractors to strengthen integrity controls and is committed to fully co-operating with the royal commission and supporting its inquiry into integrity on construction sites”.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “it “continues to engage with its contractors to strengthen integrity controls and is committed to fully co-operating with the royal commission and supporting its inquiry into integrity on construction sites””
- SupportedCarroll said, “I’m not getting sucked into this”, before hanging up.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “he said: “I’m not getting sucked into this”, before hanging up the phone.”
- SupportedPolice charged one of Vicflow’s two Victorian directors, Richard Carroll, with bribery offences on October 26.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “On October 26, West Australian police charged one of the firm’s two Victorian directors, Richard Carroll, with bribery offences.”
- SupportedThe commission concluded that Vicflow paid kickbacks to Shire of East Pilbara manager Bevan Klein to secure millions of dollars in contracts.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “the commission concluded that Vicflow had paid kickbacks to a local government official in the Pilbara to secure millions of dollars of contracts in the remote WA region.”
- SupportedA suspected scheme involved Vicflow buying Klein’s 2014 Mitsubishi Triton, valued at $17,000, for $40,000 in return for contracts worth more than $5 million.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Text messages between Carroll and his fellow Melbourne-based Vicflow owner, Damien Fogarty, also revealed a scheme in 2022 in which the pair’s firm paid an inflated price for a 2014 Mitsubishi Triton valued at $17,000 and owned by Klein.”
- SupportedThe commission report included admissions from Vicflow managers that they had given Klein seafood, clothes vouchers, a computer, power tools and $12,500 in cash.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “The evidence aired in the corruption commission’s October 1 report included admissions from Vicflow managers made in September 2025 which revealed that they had gifted to Klein seafood and clothes vouchers, a computer, power tools and $12,500 in cash.”