Victoria’s planning minister has approved 264 development proposals submitted through Labor’s fast-track planning scheme since its expansion three years ago and refused only one, a proposed sand quarry extension near the minister’s own electorate, sparking criticism that the program has become a virtual free pass for developers while shutting out the community.
Planning Minister Sonya Kilkenny refused the sand quarry expansion in Langwarrin, south-east Melbourne, on October 7, four weeks before the Carroll government entered caretaker mode. It was her first refusal of a proposal submitted via the Development Facilitation Program (DFP) since the program was expanded in September 2023.
The DFP was ramped up as a key part of the state government’s policy to deliver 800,000 new homes in a decade. It enables eligible proposals to apply directly to the planning minister, bypassing local councils, and removes third-party objection and appeal rights.
An analysis of decisions made by Kilkenny since the expansion, provided by the Western Port Green Wedge Protection Group, shows she has approved 264 proposals and refused one. The refused quarry project would have extended to the boundary of Kilkenny’s electorate of Carrum, which she has held since 2014.
Kilkenny refused the quarry proposal on seven grounds, including unacceptable impacts on biodiversity and habitat connectivity, inconsistency with the Frankston green wedge, loss of native vegetation, and encroachment on nearby homes. The quarry owner, Heidelberg Materials, had been granted a work plan approval by Resources Victoria in 2022 but was refused a permit by Frankston City Council in 2023. The company then applied directly to the minister late last year.
Heidelberg Materials has been given 60 days to appeal the minister’s decision through the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT), a right explicitly denied to councils or community members. The company told The Age it “does not intend to challenge the permit refusal”.
Langwarrin resident Elizabeth Cester, who fought the expansion, said her relief at the refusal turned to uncertainty when campaigners learnt the company could appeal for a review. The planning department’s online guidance states “decisions made by the minister for planning under the provisions cannot be appealed” to VCAT. “We believe the public deserves a clear explanation of how these provisions operate, whether communities have equivalent review rights, and how residents can participate if a review proceeds,” she said.
David Cole of the Western Port Green Wedge Protection Group said the fact the company still has an avenue of appeal illustrates how heavily the fast-track program is biased in favour of development. “I don’t think that’s particularly well known, and I don’t think it’s a very reasonable thing either,” he said.
The DFP has faced heavy criticism from local governments. Whittlesea council in Melbourne’s outer north called an unscheduled meeting this month at which most councillors voted to call for the program’s abolition in its current form. Boroondara in the inner east voted in August to call for an immediate pause. Whittlesea Mayor Lawrie Cox said: “We’re not always perfect, but we do have a process that people can object, can take appeal rights, and go through the processes. Simply just taking it off the table and putting it on the minister’s office for a signature is wrong; it should never be supported that way.”
Crystal Legacy, an associate professor of urban planning at the University of Melbourne, argued the expansion was framed as a response to the housing crisis but was in fact “a regulatory instrument for the government to consolidate its power”. She said there is no evidence the state government does a better job of making sound planning decisions than the constituents it has disempowered through its planning changes.
A Labor spokesperson said the DFP was helping young people find a home and every fast-track proposal went through an extensive pre-application process. “Every DFP proposal is considered rigorously on its merits, including any impacts to traffic, overshadowing and amenity. For many applications, this process has resulted in increased setbacks, reduced heights and more landscaping,” the spokesperson said.
A Coalition spokesperson said it opposed “Labor’s centralisation of planning powers under the development facilitation program in its current form” but did not say how it would change the scheme.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The 264-1 approval ratio raises questions about the program’s effectiveness and accountability.
- Community members and councils lose planning input and appeal rights, affecting local development outcomes.
- The scheme’s future may be a key issue in the upcoming state election.
Background
The Development Facilitation Program was expanded in September 2023 to fast-track housing projects as part of the Victorian government’s target of 800,000 new homes in a decade. The program allows developers to bypass local councils and community objection processes, with decisions made directly by the planning minister. It also applies to non-housing developments such as data centres and quarries. Critics say it centralises power and reduces transparency.
Key Perspectives
- Labor government (spokesperson): “Every DFP proposal is considered rigorously on its merits, including any impacts to traffic, overshadowing and amenity. For many applications, this process has resulted in increased setbacks, reduced heights and more landscaping.”
- Western Port Green Wedge Protection Group (David Cole): The fast-track program is biased in favour of development, and the fact companies can appeal while councils cannot is unreasonable.
- Langwarrin resident Elizabeth Cester: The community was shocked to learn that after the minister refused the quarry, the company could still appeal, contradicting the department’s online guidance.
- Whittlesea Mayor Lawrie Cox: “Simply just taking it off the table and putting it on the minister’s office for a signature is wrong; it should never be supported that way.”
- University of Melbourne planning academic Crystal Legacy: The program was framed as a response to the housing crisis but is a “regulatory instrument for the government to consolidate its power.”
- Coalition spokesperson: Opposes “Labor’s centralisation of planning powers under the development facilitation program in its current form” but did not specify changes.
What to Watch
- Heidelberg Materials has 60 days to appeal the quarry refusal, although it says it does not intend to challenge.
- Whittlesea and Boroondara councils have called for the program’s abolition or pause, suggesting further council opposition may emerge.
- The Victorian government entered caretaker mode in October, meaning a state election is imminent, which could reshape planning policy.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 10 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedThe fast-track scheme approved 264 proposals and rejected one sand quarry extension.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “An analysis of decisions made by Kilkenny since the program’s expansion just over three years ago, provided to The Age by the Western Port Green Wedge Protection Group, reveals she has approved 264 proposals and refused one.”
- Partly supportedCritics say the program has become a ‘free pass’ for developers.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Critics say the development facilitation program – ramped up three years ago to approve more housing, but also used to assess data centres, quarries and big batteries – has become a virtual free pass for developers and shut the community out of the planning process.”
- Partly supportedThe approvals and refusal sparked criticism that the program is a virtual free pass and shuts out the community.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Critics say the development facilitation program – ramped up three years ago to approve more housing, but also used to assess data centres, quarries and big batteries – has become a virtual free pass for developers and shut the community out of the planning process.”
- SupportedKilkenny refused the Langwarrin quarry proposal on October 7, four weeks before the Carroll government entered caretaker mode.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “The proposed sand quarry expansion in Langwarrin, in Melbourne’s south-east, was refused a permit by Planning Minister Sonya Kilkenny on October 7, four weeks before the Carroll government entered caretaker mode.”
- SupportedThis was Kilkenny’s first refusal of a proposal submitted through the program since its September 2023 expansion.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “It was Kilkenny’s first refusal of a proposal submitted to her via the fast-track program since it was expanded in September 2023.”
- SupportedThe program bypasses local councils and removes third-party objection and appeal rights.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “The program enables eligible proposals to apply directly to the planning minister, bypassing local councils, and removes third-party avenues to object or appeal.”
- SupportedHeidelberg Materials has 60 days to appeal the minister’s decision through VCAT, a right denied to councils and community members.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Heidelberg Materials has also been given 60 days to appeal the minister’s decision through VCAT, a right that is explicitly denied to councils or community members.”
- SupportedHeidelberg Materials told The Age it “does not intend to challenge the permit refusal”.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Heidelberg Materials told The Age it “does not intend to challenge the permit refusal”.”
- SupportedCester said, “We believe the public deserves a clear explanation of how these provisions operate, whether communities have equivalent review rights, and how residents can participate if a review proceeds”.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: ““We believe the public deserves a clear explanation of how these provisions operate, whether communities have equivalent review rights, and how residents can participate if a review proceeds,” she said.”
- SupportedCole said, “I don’t think that’s particularly well known, and I don’t think it’s a very reasonable thing either”.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: ““I don’t think that’s particularly well known, and I don’t think it’s a very reasonable thing either,” Cole said.”
- SupportedWhittlesea Mayor Lawrie Cox said, “We’re not always perfect, but we do have a process that people can object, can take appeal rights, and go through the processes. Simply just taking it off the table and putting it on the minister’s office for a signature is wrong; it should never be supported that way.”Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: ““We’re not always perfect, but we do have a process that people can object, can take appeal rights, and go through the processes. Simply just taking it off the table and putting it on the minister’s office for a signature is wrong; it should never be supported that way.””
- SupportedLegacy called the expansion “a regulatory instrument for the government to consolidate its power”.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “The development facilitation program’s expansion in 2023 was framed as a response to an urgent need to tackle Victoria’s housing shortage, but was in fact “a regulatory instrument for the government to consolidate its power”, said Crystal Legacy, an associate professor of urban planning at the University of Melbourne.”