The usual logic holds that rising bond yields increase the cost of credit and produce attractive near risk-free returns, reducing the appeal of stocks. That dynamic, however, is not being reflected in the US sharemarket indices. Bartholomeusz describes the market's performance as "not a broad-based bull run" in the caption accompanying his analysis, which appears in Nine newspapers including the Sydney Morning Herald, Brisbane Times and WA Today. While the record-setting rally continues, the factors that typically temper equity markets appear to have been set aside for now.
Wall Street Hits Record High as Bond Yields Surge to 2002 Levels, Defying Usual Market Logic
Columnist Stephen Bartholomeusz notes unusual divergence, while Iran war and oil crunch loom
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The breakdown of the typical stock-bond correlation could suggest the stock rally is narrow or fragile.
- Sustained high bond yields may eventually pressure equity valuations, particularly if interest rate costs rise.
- The rally is occurring amid active military conflict involving Iran and elevated oil prices, raising questions about risk pricing.
Background
Share prices and bond yields usually move in opposite directions: when bond yields rise, stocks become less attractive as the cost of credit increases and safer income streams become available. The current environment in the US, where the S&P 500 has hit a record while bond yields are at their highest since 2002, is an anomaly.
Key Perspectives
Stephen Bartholomeusz, senior business columnist: The market's behaviour is unusual and the headline indices do not reflect a broad-based rally. Market participants: Some investors may be concentrated in a handful of large-cap stocks, particularly in sectors like technology or energy, that are driving the index higher while the average stock struggles. Critics: Without a clear catalyst, the divergence could indicate a mispricing of risk, particularly given the parallel rise in bond yields and the geopolitical uncertainty from the Iran war.
What to Watch
- Direction of US bond yields: continued increases could eventually drag stocks lower.
- Market breadth: whether the rally widens beyond a few sectors or becomes more inclusive.
- Oil price movements and any escalation in the Iran conflict that might shift investor sentiment.
Sources
- Shrugging off war, the bond rout and oil crunch: Why Wall Street keeps rallying — WA Today - Latest News
- Shrugging off war, the bond rout and oil crunch: Why Wall Street keeps rallying — Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News
- Shrugging off war, the bond rout and oil crunch: Why Wall Street keeps rallying — The Age - Latest News
- Shrugging off war, the bond rout and oil crunch: Why Wall Street keeps rallying — Brisbane Times - Latest News