A coalition of parents, educators, and civil rights advocates, represented by the ACLU of Washington, Legal Voice and Pacifica Law Group, sued Monday night seeking to stop Initiative 638 from going into effect. The measure, set to pass with 56% of the vote after last week's midterm election, would bar transgender girls from participating in girls’ K-12 sports in Washington state.
The plaintiffs include five families with daughters who play school sports, including two trans girls, as well as the Washington Education Association and TransFamilies, a nonprofit supporting families with transgender children.
The suit alleges that the initiative, particularly its sex-verification process, violates the Washington state Constitution and students' right to privacy. Washington state's anti-discrimination law includes gender identity and expression.
Adrien Leavitt, staff attorney at the ACLU of Washington, told KUOW’s “Soundside” that the initiative would require amending the state's anti-discrimination law. “The initiative needs to be transparent that it is amending the Washington Law Against Discrimination and permitting discrimination against transgender girls, and that was not a part of the text,” Leavitt said.
Darren Littell, executive director of Let’s Go Washington, which backed I-638, argued that the sex-verification claims were based on “false assumptions.” He said doctors already know if a child is transgender and can communicate that to schools without violating privacy. “What we've seen work in other states is just saying, ‘Is this individual eligible for girls' sports, yes or no,’” Littell said. “That has nothing to do with releasing any kind of private information. All it does is say whether or not that person is eligible for girls' sports.”
The measure is set to take effect on December 3rd. The legal team is asking for an emergency injunction to prevent it from being enforced while the case proceeds. The Washington Attorney General’s Office will be tasked with defending the initiative.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The lawsuit could determine whether Washington state's anti-discrimination law protects transgender students in school sports
- A ruling could set a precedent for how sex-verification policies are implemented and challenged in other states
- The case tests the balance between voter-approved initiatives and constitutional privacy protections
Background
Initiative 638 was passed by 56% of Washington voters in the November 2026 midterm election. It would bar transgender girls from playing on girls’ K-12 sports teams. Washington state includes gender identity and expression in its anti-discrimination law. The Washington Attorney General's Office is responsible for defending the initiative in court.
Key Perspectives
- ACLU of Washington (Adrien Leavitt, staff attorney): argues the initiative would amend the Washington Law Against Discrimination and permit discrimination against transgender girls without being transparent about that change
- Let's Go Washington (Darren Littell, executive director): contends privacy concerns are based on false assumptions, and that sex-verification can be handled by doctors without releasing private information
What to Watch
- Whether the court grants an emergency injunction before the December 3rd effective date
- The Washington Attorney General's defense strategy and how the state argues the initiative does not violate the constitution
- The timeline of litigation, particularly any appeals if an injunction is granted or denied
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedWashington state’s I-638, which would bar transgender girls from girls’ K-12 sports, faces a legal challenge.KUOW: “A group of parents, educators, civil rights attorneys, and LGBTQ+ advocates are challenging Initiative 638 in court. I-638 bars trangender girls from playing girls’ K-12 sports in Washington state.”
- SupportedThe ACLU and others sued to block I-638, alleging privacy and constitutional violations.KUOW: “The suit alleges the initiative, specifically the sex verification process, violates the Washington state Constitution and students’ right to privacy.”
- SupportedI-638 is set to take effect early next month.KUOW: “The law is set to go into effect on Dec. 3.”
- SupportedThe opponents sued Monday night, represented by the ACLU of Washington, Legal Voice and Pacifica Law Group.KUOW: “On Monday night, opponents represented by the ACLU of Washington, Legal Voice, and Pacifica Law Group, sued the state to stop the measure from going into effect.”
- SupportedI-638 is set to pass with 56% of the vote after last week’s midterm election.KUOW: “It’s set to pass with 56% of the vote, after last week’s midterm election.”
- SupportedThe plaintiffs include five families with daughters who play school sports, including two transgender girls.KUOW: “The plaintiffs in the case are five families with daughters who play school sports, including two trans girls.”
- SupportedThe Washington Education Association and TransFamilies are also plaintiffs.KUOW: “The state's largest teachers union, the Washington Education Association, and a non-profit that supports families with transgender children, called TransFamilies, are also plaintiffs in the case.”
- SupportedWashington state’s anti-discrimination law includes gender identity and expression.KUOW: “Washington state also includes gender identity and expression in its anti-discrimination law.”
- SupportedAdrien Leavitt said the initiative would require amending the state’s anti-discrimination law.KUOW: “Adrien Leavitt, staff attorney at the ACLU of Washington, told KUOW’s “Soundside” the initiative would require amending that law.”
- SupportedLeavitt said: “The initiative needs to be transparent that it is amending the Washington Law Against Discrimination and permitting discrimination against transgender girls, and that was not a part of the text.”KUOW: ““The initiative needs to be transparent that it is amending the Washington Law Against Discrimination and permitting discrimination against transgender girls, and that was not a part of the text,” Leavitt said.”
- SupportedDarren Littell called the sex-verification claims “false assumptions” and said doctors know if a child is transgender and can communicate that to schools without violating privacy.KUOW: “Littell argued the sex verification claims were based on “false assumptions.” Littell said doctors are already aware if a kid is trans, and that info can be communicated to schools without violating a student’s privacy.”
- SupportedLittell said: “What we've seen work in other states is just saying, ‘Is this individual eligible for girls' sports, yes or no,’” and said that does not release private information.KUOW: ““ What we've seen work in other states is just saying, ‘Is this individual eligible for girls' sports, yes or no,’” Littell said. “That has nothing to do with releasing any kind of private information. All it does is say whether or not that person is eligible for girls' sports.””