A forensic physician from the United Kingdom told the Supreme Court on Monday that some of Frances Crawford’s injuries had an “unusual pattern” but could be consistent with a lawnmower rollover accident, as the defence in her husband’s murder trial began presenting its case.
Professor Jason Payne-James, a forensic physician called by the defence, appeared at the trial of Royal Australian Air Force pilot Robert Crawford, who is accused of staging his wife’s death to look like a late-night lawnmower rollover. The prosecution closed its case on Friday.
Crawford’s barrister, Saul Holt KC, told the jury the defence would call three witnesses: Payne-James, acoustic engineer Jamie Conomos, and biomedical engineer Andrew Shaw.
The jury has heard that Frances suffered several injuries, including a 16-centimetre laceration to the top of her head, fractures to her thyroid cartilage, bruising on her jaw surrounding a red abrasion on her neck area, and bruising across her chest.
Payne-James told the court he assessed both the accident scenario and the prosecution’s case, which was that Crawford attacked his wife, either strangling her with his hands or an arm, before causing her body to be propelled off a retaining wall in the yard of their south-east Queensland property.
When asked by Holt about injuries to Frances’ head, Payne-James said they would be consistent with a scenario in which she tumbled down the wall. Holt asked whether injury patterns on Frances’ neck were commonly seen in chokeholds or armbars. Payne-James said: “Armbars and chokeholds in my experience generally don’t leave abrasions or bruises because of the diffusion of the force applied, and also it tends to be to the side of the neck … but generally because of the area where the force is applied, you tend not to see areas of abrasions and bruises.”
He described the injuries as having an “unusual pattern”. He said marks on Frances’ neck were consistent with being left by fingernails, and that it was natural for someone to try to remove whatever had caused the pressure, leaving marks. When asked if the marks revealed whether the injuries were caused by an arm or a steering wheel, Payne-James said no.
Forensic pathologist Andrzej Kedziora earlier told the court Frances’ injuries were consistent with strangulation. He said an injury to Frances’ neck could have been caused by clothing rubbing, or an arm, while her head moved around. Under cross-examination by Holt, Kedziora said he could not rule out the lawnmower scenario.
On Friday, the trial heard from Queensland police investigative computer analyst Sean Dalton, who had analysed usage on Crawford’s phone between 1.09am and 1.51am and 2.35am and 3.20am. Running a series of tests, he found that the messaging app Signal had been opened during those periods and that the device was unlocked at those times.
The trial before Justice Lincoln Crowley continues.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The trial turns on whether Frances Crawford's death was a tragic accident or a staged homicide, with expert testimony now directly challenging the prosecution's strangulation theory.
- The outcome has significant implications for how forensic evidence is weighed in cases where a spouse is accused of murder, particularly when divorce and financial motives are alleged.
- The defence has only just begun presenting its case, meaning the jury still has several more days of evidence before deliberation.
Background
Robert Crawford, a Royal Australian Air Force pilot, is accused of murdering his wife Frances at their south-east Queensland property. The prosecution alleges he killed her because he did not want to lose millions in a divorce, then staged the scene to look like a lawnmower rollover. The court has heard Frances was working on an “exit plan” to leave her marriage. The trial is being heard before Justice Lincoln Crowley.
Key Perspectives
Defence (Prof. Jason Payne-James): Frances Crawford’s head injuries were consistent with falling down a wall, and her neck injuries showed an “unusual pattern” that he said was not typical of chokeholds or armbars, but could be consistent with fingernail marks from trying to remove pressure.
Prosecution (forensic pathologist Andrzej Kedziora): Frances’ injuries were consistent with strangulation, though under cross-examination he could not rule out the lawnmower scenario.
What to Watch
- The testimony of the two remaining defence witnesses: acoustic engineer Jamie Conomos and biomedical engineer Andrew Shaw.
- Whether the prosecution’s phone-use evidence (the Signal app being opened during the early-morning hours) is challenged or corroborated.
- The jury's verdict, expected after closing arguments and the judge's summing up.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedFrances Crawford’s injuries were consistent with a lawnmower-accident scenario, according to the headline.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “Wife’s injuries consistent with mower accident scenario, UK expert tells court.”
- SupportedA forensic physician testified for the defence that some of Frances’s injuries had an “unusual pattern”.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “Some of Frances Crawford’s injuries had an “unusual pattern”, a forensic physician brought in from the United Kingdom as a defence witness has told her husband’s murder trial.”
- SupportedProfessor Jason Payne-James, a UK-based forensic physician, appeared at the trial on Monday.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “UK-based forensic physician Professor Jason Payne-James appeared on Monday at the trial of Royal Australian Air Force pilot Robert Crawford”
- SupportedRobert Crawford is accused of staging his wife’s death to look like a late-night lawnmower rollover.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “who is accused of staging his wife’s death to look like a late-night lawnmower rollover because he did not want to lose millions in a divorce.”
- SupportedThe prosecution closed its case on Friday.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “The prosecution closed its case on Friday, with Crawford’s barrister Saul Holt KC telling the jury the defence would call three witnesses”
- SupportedThe defence told the jury it would call Payne-James, acoustic engineer Jamie Conomos and biomedical engineer Andrew Shaw.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “Crawford’s barrister Saul Holt KC telling the jury the defence would call three witnesses: Payne-James, acoustic engineer Jamie Conomos, and biomedical engineer Andrew Shaw.”
- SupportedFrances had a 16-centimetre laceration to the top of her head.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “a 16-centimetre laceration to the top of her head”
- SupportedPayne-James said the head injuries would be consistent with Frances tumbling down the wall.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “When asked by Holt about injuries to Frances’ head, Payne-James said they would be consistent with a scenario in which she tumbled down the wall.”
- SupportedPayne-James said, “Armbars and chokeholds in my experience generally don’t leave abrasions or bruises because of the diffusion of the force applied”.Brisbane Times - Latest News: ““Armbars and chokeholds in my experience generally don’t leave abrasions or bruises because of the diffusion of the force applied, and also it tends to be to the side of the neck …”
- SupportedForensic pathologist Andrzej Kedziora told the court Frances’s injuries were consistent with strangulation.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “Forensic pathologist Andrzej Kedziora earlier told the court Frances’ injuries were consistent with strangulation .”
- SupportedOn Friday, analyst Sean Dalton examined phone usage in the periods 1.09am–1.51am and 2.35am–3.20am.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “who had analysed usage on Crawford’s phone between 1.09am and 1.51am and 2.35am and 3.20am.”
- SupportedDalton found Signal had been opened and the phone was unlocked during those periods.Brisbane Times - Latest News: “he found that messaging app Signal had been opened during those periods on Crawford’s phone and that the device was unlocked at those times.”