Job applicants in England and Wales may no longer need to declare criminal convictions received as children, under government proposals aimed at improving employment prospects for rehabilitated young people, with lifelong disclosure removed for offences including robbery and violent disorder.
The Ministry of Justice has launched a consultation on changes that would mean criminal records for people under 18 would no longer show up for life during employer background checks. The proposed rules would apply to those who have not reoffended as adults.
The changes come as the government prepares to publish a report on the number of young people not in work or education. In May, its author, former Labour minister Alan Milburn, warned the UK risked raising a "lost generation", with almost one in eight young people not working or studying. Justice minister Jake Richards pointed to that intervention, saying barriers to employment can be "particularly difficult to overcome" for people who committed crimes as children.
Currently, the length of time a criminal record must be disclosed varies by offence severity, punishment and time elapsed. A conviction leading to a custodial sentence for a child must be disclosed for life. The government wants to reduce the number of young people those rules apply to.
Five offences would be removed from the list of crimes that require lifelong disclosure if committed by a child: affray, violent disorder, supplying a controlled drug to a child, robbery, and assaults occasioning actual bodily harm. Between March 2022 and March 2026, around 8,500 under-18s were convicted of these offences, according to ministry data. The government said such crimes are often a result of peer pressure, exploitation and "adolescent impulsivity" by individuals who are still developing, rather than a broader propensity for crime and violence.
Under the proposals, these offences would cease to show up in checks after five and a half years. Lifelong disclosure would also be removed for offences leading to detention of less than two years, replaced by an 11-year disclosure period. If a child was given a sentence longer than two years, which can only happen if the crime’s severity meant they were dealt with by an adult crown court, the current rules would remain. The most serious crimes, including severe violence, terrorism-related crimes and sexual offences, would be exempted from the reforms.
Other changes include cutting or removing disclosure periods for offences that led to a fine, ending automatic disclosure of out-of-court resolutions, and reforming how multiple childhood offences appear in checks.
Richards said: "Many young people who offend do not go on to lead lives of crime. They take responsibility, turn their lives around and want to make something of themselves. When they do, we should recognise that progress and support them – not put unnecessary barriers in their way."
Campaigners welcomed the proposals, saying they would boost youth employment. Companies say criminal convictions are the second biggest barrier to hiring people from disadvantaged backgrounds.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The proposals could significantly improve employment prospects for thousands of young people who committed crimes as minors but have not reoffended as adults, reducing long-term barriers to work.
- The changes reflect a policy shift away from lifelong disclosure for certain serious childhood offences, potentially affecting how employers view criminal records in hiring.
- The reform is tied to broader government efforts to tackle the rising number of young people not in work or education, a problem the Milburn report highlighted.
Background
The UK government is consulting on changes to criminal record disclosure rules in England and Wales. Currently, convictions from childhood can require lifelong disclosure for certain offences, especially those resulting in custodial sentences. The proposals follow a review by former Labour minister Alan Milburn on youth unemployment, which warned of a "lost generation". The Ministry of Justice says young people who have not reoffended as adults struggle to find work due to past behaviour.
Key Perspectives
- Ministry of Justice/Justice Minister Jake Richards: believes the system should offer second chances, saying "the system at the moment doesn't discern for offences committed when you were a child than those that you committed as an adult," and that barriers to employment can be "particularly difficult to overcome" for people with childhood convictions.
- Campaigners: welcomed the changes, saying they will boost youth employment.
- Companies: say criminal convictions are the second biggest barrier to employing people from disadvantaged backgrounds.
What to Watch
- The outcome of the government's consultation, which will determine whether the proposals become law and in what form.
- Whether the changes affect youth custody rates or recidivism, as the government aims to reduce the number of children in custody.
- How employers adjust hiring practices in response to reduced disclosure requirements, particularly for sectors requiring standard or enhanced DBS checks.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 2 sources: 10 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedYoung offenders in England and Wales could be spared lifelong disclosure of childhood convictions under government proposals.BBC News: “Some job applicants in England and Wales would no longer need to declare criminal convictions they received as children under government proposals designed to improve the employment prospects of rehabilitated young people.”
- SupportedFive offences, including robbery and violent disorder, would no longer require lifelong disclosure if committed by a child.BBC News: “They are: affray, violent disorder, supplying a controlled drug to a child, robbery and assaults occasioning actual bodily harm.”
- SupportedThe proposals are aimed at improving rehabilitated young people’s employment prospects.BBC News: “under government proposals designed to improve the employment prospects of rehabilitated young people.”
- SupportedJake Richards said young people who offend can turn their lives around and should not face unnecessary barriers.BBC News: “Many young people who offend do not go on to lead lives of crime. They take responsibility, turn their lives around and want to make something of themselves. When they do, we should recognise that progress and support them – not put unnecessary barriers in their way.”
- SupportedRichards said employment barriers can be particularly difficult to overcome for people who committed crimes as children.BBC News: “saying barriers to employment can be "particularly difficult to overcome" for people who committed crimes as children.”
- SupportedAround 8,500 under-18s were convicted of the five listed offences between March 2022 and March 2026, according to Ministry of Justice data.BBC News: “Between March 2022 and March 2026, around 8,500 under-18s were convicted of those offences, according to Ministry of Justice data.”
- Partly supportedThe five offences would stop appearing in checks after five and a half years.UK news | The Guardian: “If they are convicted of one of those offences but do not get a custodial sentence, they will have to disclose them only for five and a half years.”
- Reports differLifelong disclosure for offences leading to detention of less than two years would be replaced by an 11-year period.UK news | The Guardian: “If they get a sentence of two years or less, they would have to disclose it for 11 years.”
- SupportedThe existing rules would remain for a child given a sentence longer than two years, which can happen if the case is dealt with by an adult Crown Court because of the crime’s severity.BBC News: “In cases where a child was given a sentence longer than two years - which can only happen if the severity of the crime meant they were dealt with by an adult crown court - the rules would stay the same.”
- SupportedThe most serious offences, including severe violence, terrorism-related crimes and sexual offences, would be exempt from the reforms.BBC News: “The most serious offences - including severe violence, terrorism-related crimes and sexual offences - would be exempted from the reforms.”
- SupportedIn May, Alan Milburn warned that the UK risked raising a “lost generation”.BBC News: “In May, he warned the UK was at risk of a raising a "lost generation"”
- SupportedAlmost one in eight young people were not working or studying.BBC News: “as almost one in eight young people are not working or studying.”