A 51-year-old Werribee man accused of sending violent death threats to Melbourne Cup-winning jockey Michelle Payne has been denied bail, with a magistrate deeming him an unacceptable risk to the community.
Craig Langford is accused of bombarding Payne with death threats and sexualised slurs through Instagram messages over three days last week.
Payne, the first woman to win the Melbourne Cup, described the level of violence in the alleged threats as "unimaginable".
In court, prosecutors said they held "grave concerns" for Payne's physical safety and mental health, noting she was left in a state of shock after the alleged death threats. "The victim is a well-known public figure and can easily be tracked and located," the court heard. Prosecutors said Langford had made "threats of lethal violence" that included wishing Payne and her family dead.
The court heard detectives did not know the motive behind the alleged messages and that Langford did not know Payne personally.
Police raided the Werribee home where Langford lived with his stepfather and mother, seizing his mobile phone for analysis. After his arrest, Langford denied sending the messages and claimed he did not use Instagram when interviewed by police.
Langford's defence counsel argued he would have "next to zero" access to a computer or smartphone if bailed, and that his stepfather would report him to police if he breached any orders imposed on him. The court also heard Langford cared for his unwell, elderly stepfather and his wheelchair-bound mother.
However, the magistrate ruled Langford posed an unacceptable risk to the community, saying "stalking has a significant impact on those people subjected to it." Langford, flanked by custody officers in the dock, was remanded in custody.
The alleged threats are the latest challenge for Payne, whose father Paddy Payne Sr died in September at age 90. She had previously dealt with alleged stalking: Victorian man Peter Widdowson pleaded guilty to stalking Payne and fellow jockey Nikita Beriman when he mailed them parcels of toys, books and letters in 2022.
Langford will return to court next month.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The case highlights the persistent risk of stalking and online abuse faced by public figures, even when the perpetrator has no personal connection to the victim.
- The denial of bail reflects a growing judicial recognition of the serious psychological impact stalking has on victims, beyond physical threats.
- It comes amid broader community concern about online harassment and the adequacy of legal protections for women, particularly high-profile women.
Background
Michelle Payne became the first female jockey to win the Melbourne Cup in 2015, riding Prince of Penzance. She has since retired from racing. In 2022, another man pleaded guilty to stalking Payne and a fellow jockey by mailing them packages. Her father, renowned horseman Paddy Payne Sr, died in September at age 90.
Key Perspectives
Michelle Payne: said the level of violence in the alleged threats was "unimaginable" and that people who make such comments "don't deserve their freedom".
Magistrate: deemed Langford an unacceptable risk to the community, noting that "stalking has a significant impact on those people subjected to it".
Prosecutors: said they held "grave concerns" for Payne's physical safety and mental health after the threats left her in a state of shock.
Defence counsel: argued Langford would have little access to technology if bailed and that his stepfather would report any breaches.
What to Watch
- Whether Langford's next court appearance yields further details about the alleged threats or a possible motive.
- Any impact this case may have on bail decisions in stalking and harassment cases involving high-profile victims.
- Payne's public response or potential advocacy around online safety and stalking laws.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedThe headline says a man accused of threatening to kill jockey Michelle Payne was denied bail.Just In: “A man accused of sending violent death threats to Melbourne Cup-winning jockey Michelle Payne has been denied bail.”
- SupportedThe summary says a man accused of sending violent death threats via Instagram was remanded in custody.Just In: “Craig Langford, a 51-year-old man from Werribee, allegedly hurled the violent threats at Payne in a series of Instagram messages last week.”
- SupportedA 51-year-old Werribee man accused of sending death threats to Payne was denied bail.Just In: “Werribee man Craig Langford, 51, is accused of sending violent death threats to Payne via social media over the course of three days last week.”
- SupportedThe magistrate deemed Langford an unacceptable risk to the community.Just In: “But a magistrate deemed Payne's accused stalker an unacceptable risk to the community”
- SupportedLangford was accused of sending threats and sexualised slurs over three days last week.Just In: “A court heard Mr Langford, who was on bail for other alleged offending when he allegedly sent the abusive texts over the course of three days, threatened to kill Payne and called her a slut, a pig and a dog.”
- SupportedPayne described the level of violence in the alleged threats as “unimaginable”.Just In: “Payne, the first woman to win the Melbourne Cup, told the ABC the level of violence detailed in Mr Langford's alleged threats was "unimaginable".”
- SupportedProsecutors said they held “grave concerns” for Payne’s physical safety and mental health, and that the threats left her in shock.Just In: “Mr Langford was denied bail in the Wyndham magistrates court today after prosecutors told the court they held "grave concerns" for Payne's physical safety and mental health after the alleged death threats left her in a state of shock.”
- SupportedThe court heard: “The victim is a well-known public figure and can easily be tracked and located.”Just In: “"The victim is a well-known public figure and can easily be tracked and located," the court heard.”
- SupportedProsecutors said Langford made “threats of lethal violence” that included wishing Payne and her family dead.Just In: “Prosecutors said Mr Langford had made "threats of lethal violence" that included wishing Payne and her family dead.”
- SupportedLangford’s defence counsel said he would have “next to zero” access to a computer or smartphone if bailed.Just In: “Mr Langford's defence counsel told the court he would have "next to zero" access to a computer or smartphone if he was bailed”
- SupportedThe magistrate said, “Stalking has a significant impact on those people subjected to it.”Just In: “But a magistrate deemed Payne's accused stalker an unacceptable risk to the community, saying: "Stalking has a significant impact on those people subjected to it."”
- SupportedAfter his arrest, Langford denied sending the messages and claimed he did not use Instagram when interviewed by police.Just In: “Following his arrest, Mr Langford denied sending the messages and claimed he did not use Instagram when interviewed by police.”