Bowen described the outcome as “very disappointing” and told reporters there were “unbridgeable red lines” in the discussions. He said the situation coming into COP was the most complicated and fraught geopolitical environment in living memory. The talks, known as COP31, were co-presided by Turkey and Australia.
The standoff centred on a cover decision, which can only be adopted by consensus of all parties, and which reiterated calls from previous talks for a transition away from fossil fuels. The Saudi-led bloc, backed by Russia, rejected the agreement. The European Union said it could not support an agreement that would take backwards steps. Delegates also raised objections to a call to increase the use of carbon capture and storage technology, championed by the Saudi-led bloc, and to the failure of developed nations to pledge more financial support for poorer countries.
Turkey's conference president Murat Kurum said at the closing plenary that he could see there was no agreement and confirmed he would not advance any new text. "There is nothing to do, we did all that we could," he said.
Speaking on behalf of the EU, Ireland’s Minister for Climate, Energy and the Environment Darragh O'Brien rejected the draft on the floor of the final plenary. “We will not endorse a cover decision, or an Antalya Pact, that does not even mention fossil fuels, which is the key driver of climate change, and we will not accept negotiating backward in time, and we will not accept a COP that greenwashes fossil fuel,” he said.
A member of the Panamanian delegation also rejected the deal, saying it repeated previously agreed commitments without closing the gap between reality and what science demands, relied too much on carbon capture technology instead of deep changes, and weakened language agreed in previous decisions. A representative of the Marshall Islands said her nation had been failed by all sides and that they had been offered “next to nothing” over the past two weeks, while the finance gap kept growing and seas were rising and ecosystems collapsing.
Bowen had sought to sidestep the impasse by including language recognising the agreement reached in Dubai, where the world pledged to “transition away from fossil fuels.” He commended delegations for all-night negotiating efforts and said things that were manageable at previous COPs became red lines this time.
A Russian delegate told the session Russia stands by the goals of the Paris Agreement but argued the conference made rapid phase-out of fossil fuels central when it should not have been. He said UN scenarios show the world will continue using about 40 per cent of 2019 oil levels and 50 per cent of 2019 gas levels. A Saudi representative said Arab League states represent less than 2 per cent of historical greenhouse gas emissions and had called for a tripling of climate finance, language that he said was removed from the text.
China noted its reservation about some content but said to demonstrate unity it had decided to accept the cover decision and called on all parties to show compromise. Fiji's Minister Lynda Tabuya said though the text was not perfect she regretted it was not adopted, and told Bowen the failure was not his to carry but was a collective responsibility resting with all parties.
Mary Robinson, former Irish president and a member of The Elders, said COP31 saw "a shameful lack of urgency and leadership" from the co-presidencies, compounded by what she called politicised attacks on the science.
