An email from a Bupa-operated GP clinic has revealed the health insurance giant urged doctors to increase billing of expensive Medicare items, including chronic condition management plans, to lift revenue, according to a report by the ABC.
The email, sent in June, told doctors to ensure "revenue is increasing" by increasing bookings for costly Medicare checks known as "chronic condition management plans" (CCMPs). It encouraged doctors to re-book patients eligible for further checks but prevented by Medicare rules from claiming on the same day. The Medicare schedule fee for a GP to prepare a CCMP is $160.60, compared to $87.10 for a standard GP appointment lasting at least 20 minutes.
The email also said the "ops team" had tasked practice managers with "ensuring revenue is increasing by ensuring there is an uptick in billings of HA [health assessments]". It listed Medicare item numbers for these assessments and reminded GPs that practice managers needed to "ensure" an increase in patients being charged for these more expensive Medicare items, otherwise they "need to explain why these are not being billed".
Bupa operates 33 medical centres. In a statement, Bupa said the email was sent at one clinic and was an attempt to remind doctors to consider preventative care. "Patient needs, clinical judgement and compliance with Medicare requirements always come first," it said, adding that decisions about a patient's care and eligibility remain with the treating doctor.
The federal government now spends nearly $1.3 billion a year on chronic care plans out of the $35 billion Medicare budget. CCMPs are personalised plans designed to create structure for patients with complex health conditions, ranging from eczema to heart disease.
Health economist Terry Barnes, a former senior adviser to two Howard government health ministers, told the ABC he was not surprised by the email. "If corporates are putting pressure on their doctors to order health assessments or any other type of extra service, and the optional extras become mandatory, then there is a real problem there," he said. He said the GP sector was becoming increasingly corporatised and more guardrails were needed.
Royal Australian College of General Practitioners president Michael Wright said to comply with Medicare, GPs could only bill items like CCMPs when "medically necessary". "It's important that GPs know that they're available, but certainly they shouldn't be forced into any particular billing model," he said.
A Cubiko spokesperson said its tools helped practices meet Medicare eligibility rules "therefore reducing, not increasing, the risk of incorrect billing".
Bill Coote, who headed the Medicare regulator the Professional Services Review (PSR) between 2011 and 2016, said the potential abuse of chronic care plans was a "bugbear" during his tenure, and he saw cases of practitioners submitting many plans with little information written into them. The PSR has handed down just one penalty to a corporate entity, a $1.16 million fine in 2023 for "inappropriate practice".
The author of an independent 2023 review of Medicare Integrity and Compliance noted that medical centres do not need to be registered as Medicare providers, even though they collect revenue from the scheme. The Department of Health confirmed that despite recent law changes, there is still no requirement for medical centres to be registered.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The email raises concerns about corporate pressure on GPs to prioritise revenue over patient need, potentially leading to over-servicing and higher taxpayer costs.
- Medicare spending on chronic care plans is rising rapidly, now nearly $1.3 billion annually, and any systematic upcoding could significantly inflate the federal health budget.
- GPs' clinical autonomy is core to Medicare's integrity; if corporates can influence billing decisions, it may undermine trust in the system and prompt regulatory reform.
Background
Bupa, a health insurance and healthcare company, operates 33 medical centres in Australia. Chronic condition management plans are Medicare-subsidised care plans written by GPs for patients with ongoing health conditions, allowing more structured care. The federal government spends about $35 billion on Medicare annually. A 2023 independent review of Medicare integrity flagged that medical centres are not required to be registered as Medicare providers, leaving a regulatory gap. The Professional Services Review is the main Medicare watchdog, but has levied only one corporate penalty.
Key Perspectives
Bupa: said the email was an attempt to remind doctors to consider preventative care, and that patient needs, clinical judgement and Medicare compliance always come first; decisions remain with the treating doctor.
Terry Barnes (health economist, former Howard government adviser): said if corporates pressure doctors to order extra services and optional extras become mandatory, there is a real problem; more guardrails are needed to regulate corporate owners of GP clinics.
Michael Wright (RACGP president): said GPs should not face undue pressure from corporate owners to over-service, and that financial autonomy of GPs is core to Medicare's success.
Cubiko (software provider): said its tools help practices meet Medicare eligibility rules, reducing the risk of incorrect billing, and that chronic disease is significantly under-managed.
Bill Coote (former PSR head): said the potential abuse of chronic care plans was a "bugbear" of the regulator, and the Bupa email gave the impression it was written by someone focused on the bottom line.
What to Watch
- Whether the Department of Health or the PSR launches an investigation into Bupa's practices following this report.
- Whether the federal government moves to require medical centres to be registered as Medicare providers, a recommendation from the 2023 review.
- Whether other corporate GP chains adopt similar revenue-focused billing instructions, and if any whistleblowers come forward.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedA Bupa GP clinic urged doctors to increase billing of costly Medicare items to lift revenue.Just In: “A GP clinic operated by health insurance giant Bupa encouraged doctors to lift their billing of more costly Medicare items.”
- SupportedThe ABC obtained an email telling doctors to increase bookings for chronic condition management plans, which have a $160.60 schedule fee.Just In: “The ABC has obtained an email from a Bupa clinic to its GPs in June, which told doctors to ensure "revenue is increasing". The email asked doctors to do this by increasing the bookings of patients for costly Medicare checks known as "chronic condition management plans" (CCMPs).”
- SupportedThe email told doctors to ensure “revenue is increasing”.Just In: “which told doctors to ensure "revenue is increasing".”
- SupportedThe email encouraged doctors to re-book patients eligible for further checks when Medicare rules prevented those checks from being claimed on the same day.Just In: “It further encouraged doctors to re-book patients, if they were eligible for further checks but Medicare rules prevented them from being claimed on the same day.”
- SupportedThe CCMP schedule fee is $160.60, compared with $87.10 for a standard GP appointment lasting at least 20 minutes.Just In: “The Medicare schedule fee for a GP to prepare a CCMP is $160.60, compared to $87.10 for a standard GP appointment lasting at least 20 minutes.”
- SupportedThe email said the ops team tasked practice managers with ensuring increased revenue through an uptick in health-assessment billings.Just In: “the "ops team" had tasked the practice managers with "ensuring revenue is increasing by ensuring there is an uptick in billings of HA [health assessments]".”
- SupportedThe email said practice managers needed to ensure more patients were charged for the items, or explain why they were not being billed.Just In: “GPs were reminded that practice managers need to "ensure" an increase in patients being charged for these more expensive Medicare items, otherwise practice managers "need to explain why these are not being billed".”
- SupportedBupa said the email was sent at one clinic and was intended to remind doctors to consider preventative care.Just In: “In a statement, Bupa said the email was sent at one clinic and was an attempt to remind doctors to consider preventative care.”
- SupportedBupa said patient needs, clinical judgement and Medicare compliance come first.Just In: “"Patient needs, clinical judgement and compliance with Medicare requirements always come first," it said.”
- SupportedThe government spends nearly $1.3 billion a year on chronic care plans out of a $35 billion Medicare budget.Just In: “it is now spending nearly $1.3 billion a year on these chronic care plans out of the $35 billion Medicare budget.”
- SupportedTerry Barnes said that if corporates pressure doctors to order extra services and optional extras become mandatory, there is a real problem.Just In: “"If corporates are putting pressure on their doctors to order health assessments or any other type of extra service, and the optional extras become mandatory, then there is a real problem there," he said.”
- SupportedThe PSR handed down one penalty to a corporate entity: a $1.16 million fine in 2023 for “inappropriate practice”.Just In: “it has handed down just one penalty to such an entity — only referred to in public documents as "a company", which was handed a $1.16 million fine in 2023 for "inappropriate practice".”