The NSW Coroner's Court has heard that doula Amy Lou Smith repeatedly reassured first-time parents that their newborn was OK despite appearing purple and having difficulty breathing. The parents said Smith left to set up a jumping castle for her son's birthday, while Smith told the court it was already set up and she went home to rest. Baby DH died eight hours after birth.
The inquest, held at Lismore Local Court, is examining the deaths of four newborns. Earlier this week, Deputy State Coroner Joan Baptie heard of two other deaths following a free birth outside the medical system, babies R and D.
Smith, who is not medically trained, was hired by DH's parents for $2000 to "keep mum and baby safe". The baby was born with a complex heart abnormality that was not detected because the mother had no ultrasounds.
The court heard that the parents saw signs that something was seriously wrong from the first minutes of life. DH was born with floppy limbs and let out only a small cry, which was not typical for a newborn; his parents later raised concerns about his purple colour. Smith reassured them that “some babies take time to land” and said DH needed to be warmed up. She told them his breathing noises were “cute little noises”. Smith denied making these comments.
The father said the couple trusted Smith. "Time and time again we looked to her for advice and guidance. We trusted her because of her long-time experience with birthing," the court heard. The mother said "at no time did Amy say that she was unsure, or offer to call someone to check".
Five hours after the birth, Smith left to set up a jumping castle for her son's birthday, according to the parents. Smith told the court the castle was already set up and she went home to rest after nine-and-a-half hours with the family. Before leaving, she had not given them a doctor's number; she later texted them a number for a practice where the doctor no longer worked, and sent a photo of the fully inflated castle.
When the parents sent a live photo in which the baby looked like he was struggling to breathe, Smith replied that his colour seemed to be improving despite his blue or purple appearance. A GP eventually told the couple to call Triple Zero. Paramedics spent 32 minutes trying to revive DH, but resuscitation was stopped on arrival at Byron hospital, 10 minutes from home.
The next day, Smith set up an online fundraiser for the family without their knowledge or consent. The mother said this caused further grief as they had not yet told loved ones overseas.
Smith told the court she had attended only six births without a midwife before DH, and that a doula's role was emotional support. She denied that her comments amounted to clinical advice. She said she twice recommended the parents transfer DH to hospital if concerned, but there was no record of these suggestions in the parents' police statement.
A 2022 video of Smith was played in which she criticised unnecessary medical intervention to start babies breathing, saying "if they were just left … and given skin to skin [contact] they would likely just start breathing in their own time".
The inquest continues.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- Raises questions about the role and regulation of doulas in Australia, who are not medically trained but may offer advice during births.
- Highlights risks of unmonitored free births, where complications can go undetected.
- Could lead to policy changes regarding birth support outside the medical system.
Background
The inquest is examining the deaths of four newborns following free births in the Byron Bay area. Free births are births without medical attendance, sometimes with a doula providing emotional support. The case has focused attention on potential harm when unaccredited practitioners offer clinical advice.
Key Perspectives
Parents of Baby DH: say Smith repeatedly assured them nothing was wrong and did not recommend hospital transfer despite the baby's purple colour and breathing difficulties. They say they would have called an ambulance if she had not been present.
Amy Lou Smith: denies giving clinical advice and says she twice recommended hospital transfer. She says a doula's role is emotional support and that she had only attended six births without a midwife before DH. She claims the baby's condition seemed to improve.
Inquest experts: gave split opinions on whether earlier intervention could have saved DH, but the court heard the extended time at home meant the only possible outcome was death.
What to Watch
- The inquest's findings, due after submissions.
- Potential recommendations for regulation of doulas or greater medical oversight of home births.
- Any criminal referral or disciplinary action against Smith.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedThe headline says a Byron Bay doula left a dying newborn to set up a jumping castle, as told to the court.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Byron doula left dying newborn to set up a jumping castle, court told.”
- SupportedThe NSW Coroner's Court is examining Baby DH's death in a case involving a doula.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Baby DH is one of four newborn deaths being examined at an inquest being held at Lismore Local Court.”
- SupportedThe court heard that Smith repeatedly reassured first-time parents their newborn was OK despite his purple appearance and difficulty breathing.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “A Byron doula repeatedly reassured two first-time parents that their baby was OK before returning home to a jumping castle, despite the newborn appearing purple and having difficulty breathing, a coronial inquest has heard.”
- SupportedBaby DH died eight hours after birth.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Experts were split over whether his death eight hours after birth could have been prevented by earlier intervention.”
- SupportedThe parents said Smith left to set up a jumping castle for her son's birthday five hours after the birth.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Five hours after DH was born, Smith left to set up a jumping castle for her son’s birthday, according to the newborn’s parents.”
- SupportedSmith told the court the castle was already set up and she went home to rest after being with the family for nine-and-a-half hours.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Smith told the court the jumping castle was already set up and that she had gone home to rest and shower before returning to the new parents, as she had been with them for nine-and-a-half hours.”
- SupportedSmith was hired for $2000 to “keep mum and baby safe”.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Smith, who is not medically trained, was hired by the parents of DH for $2000 to “keep mum and baby safe” and look out for warning signs.”
- SupportedThe baby was born with a complex heart abnormality that was not detected during pregnancy because his mother had no ultrasounds.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Baby DH was born with a complex heart abnormality, which was not detected during pregnancy as the mother did not have any ultrasounds.”
- SupportedSmith reassured the parents that “some babies take time to land”.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Smith reassured the parents that “some babies take time to land”.”
- SupportedSmith described the newborn's breathing noises as “cute little noises”.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “When the parents raised concerns about DH’s breathing, Smith told them they were “cute little noises” and that newborns can have irregular breathing for some time, the court heard.”
- SupportedThe father said, “Time and time again we looked to her for advice and guidance. We trusted her because of her long-time experience with birthing.”Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “‘Time and time again we looked to her for advice and guidance. We trusted her because of her long-time experience with birthing.’ The father of Baby DH”
- SupportedThe mother said, “at no time did Amy say that she was unsure, or offer to call someone to check”.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “DH’s mother said “at no time did Amy say that she was unsure, or offer to call someone to check”, the court was told.”