Lewis-Ranwell killed Anthony Payne, 80, and twin brothers Roger and Dick Carter, 84, bludgeoning Payne with a hammer and killing the twins with a spade. A trial at Exeter Crown Court in December 2019 found him not guilty by reason of insanity; he received a hospital restriction order.
The investigation found that officers ignored warnings from a national database and a mental health assessor. The medical professional sent to examine Lewis-Ranwell lacked expertise in mental health and dismissed his unpredictable behaviour. Police did not know they had the legal power to detain him under the Mental Health Act without a medical assessment. Warnings from Lewis-Ranwell's mother, that he was having a psychotic episode and should be kept in custody, were also ignored.
Two days before the killings, Lewis-Ranwell was arrested for breaking into a farm. After release, he was arrested a second time for attacking a farmer with a 1.2-metre logging saw. Police bodycam footage showed him semi-naked, hissing, spitting and punching at the hatch window to his cell, ranting about paedophiles and seeing animals. He was released again. Following a rampage lasting hours, he killed the three men.
Amanda Taylor, the Carters' niece, told the Sunday Times the family still seeks justice. "All I want is for just one of the agencies involved to stand up and say: 'We are so sorry. Serious mistakes were made. We recognise the devastating consequences of those failures and we will do everything in our power to make sure this never happens again,'" she said. The families have called on the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) to open an investigation into Devon and Cornwall police. The watchdog said the force should investigate itself; the families have heard nothing for two years. The IOPC said the family has a right to ask for a review and it has not yet received a request.
A police spokesperson said the force was addressing "areas of learning" and would reflect on the inquest jury's recommendations, adding: "Our thoughts, as always, remain with the loved ones of Anthony Payne and Dick and Roger Carter."
An estimated 100 to 120 mental health-related killings occur in the UK each year. Julian Hendy, of victims' charity Hundred Families, said: "In my view, had the lessons in the Lewis-Ranwell case been learnt earlier, and effective action taken, there is a real chance that the Nottingham attacks could well have been prevented. Services aren't learning and totally innocent people are losing their lives as a result."
Lewis-Ranwell's case is one of several where police and mental health service failures have led to tragedy. A Care Quality Commission review of Valdo Calocane, who has paranoid schizophrenia and killed three in Nottingham in 2023, concluded a "series of errors and misjudgments" led to his discharge despite repeatedly not taking medication. The report found "systemic issues with community mental health care which, without immediate action, will continue to pose an inherent risk to patient and public safety". NHS England has since strengthened guidance on community mental health support for people with severe mental illnesses who face high risk or struggle to engage with services.