The sinking unfolded with "extraordinary speed" when a violent downburst of hurricane-force winds knocked the 56-metre vessel onto its side in less than 15 seconds, the MAIB said. Fifteen survivors escaped to a life raft launched by a crew member.
The accident on 19 August 2024 claimed the lives of Mike Lynch, 59, and his daughter Hannah, 18; Morgan Stanley International chairman Jonathan Bloomer, 70, and his wife Judy, 71; American lawyer Chris Morvillo, 59, and his wife Neda Morvillo, 57; and crew member Rick Thomas, 59.
The MAIB found that the Bayesian "had a vulnerability to high winds that was not recognised, because the yacht had never been assessed at anchor with its sails down." Safety information provided to the crew did not identify this type of risk. Rob Loder added that the extreme winds that night were not explicitly forecast; the weather forecast had predicted gusts of up to 27 knots, but wind speeds went from 8 knots to about 70 knots within minutes.
A study commissioned by the MAIB indicated that with no sails set, the vessel was vulnerable to being knocked over. Once the yacht passed 73 degrees of heel, it could not right itself. The centreboard, which provides stability under sail, was raised and not needed when using motors; it was rarely lowered at anchor.
"It was very dynamic, very quick," said MAIB principal inspector Simon Graves. "The speed of events overtook the crew and prevented them from taking any other action." Rob Loder, chief inspector of marine accidents, said: "Our thoughts remain with the families and loved ones of the seven who lost their lives... This accident developed with extraordinary speed."
The MAIB report makes seven recommendations, calling for new regulations for single-hulled sailing vessels and improved life raft rules, and urging collaboration between the Met Office and global counterparts to improve severe weather information for mariners.
The MAIB report appeared to contrast with recent reports from Italy, where prosecution experts have reportedly blamed errors by the crew rather than problems with the yacht. Italian prosecutors are investigating captain James Cutfield, chief engineer Tim Parker Eaton and deckhand Matthew Griffith on potential charges of multiple manslaughter and culpable shipwreck. British investigators said Italian prosecutors restricted access to some witnesses and evidence, and noted that "it is possible that the circumstances depicted in this report may alter following disclosure of evidence withheld by the Italian authorities." Graves said he was satisfied with the British investigation. The report found that alcohol consumption had not contributed to the sinking.