Deaths in ICE custody surge under Trump, advocates say

Family of detainee who died from untreated infection demands accountability

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time2 min
Deaths in U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement custody have risen sharply during President Donald Trump's second term, with at least 50 people dying in the first 500 days and 2025 becoming the deadliest year on record, according to an Al Jazeera investigation. Advocates and experts say the death rate has nearly tripled compared to the Biden administration, even as the Department of Homeland Security denies a spike.

Ismael Ayala-Uribe, a Mexican-born man brought to the United States as a child, died on September 22, 2025, while in ICE custody at a detention centre in Adelanto, California. He was arrested on August 17 while working at a car wash. A coroner's report found the cause of death was complications from an abscess in his pelvic region. His mother, Lucia Uribe, told Al Jazeera that her son had complained of fever and bloodshot eyes in the days before his death. 'Mom, I'm not going to make it,' she recalls him saying. She said insufficient medical treatment allowed a preventable infection to become fatal.

Ismael's case is one of many. At least 33 people died in ICE custody in 2025, according to agency statistics, and at least 26 have died so far in 2026. A joint report by Human Rights Watch and Physicians for Human Rights in June found that immigrants in ICE custody are dying at a rate roughly three times higher than under former President Joe Biden. The annualised mortality rate rose from 2.24 per 10,000 detainees under Biden to 6.38 per 10,000 during Trump's second term.

Reagan Williams, a human rights lawyer and researcher involved in the report, said that the increase in overall detentions does not explain the spike in deaths. Nicholas Cuneo, an expert in immigrant health with Physicians for Human Rights, added: 'What has often been claimed is that the overall detained population is going up. That clearly is not proportional to the detained population.'

The Department of Homeland Security, which oversees ICE, has publicly denied a spike, stating in a June social media post that the death rate has remained 'consistent with data over the last decade' and that there has been 'NO spike in deaths.' The department pointed to the percentage of deaths relative to the overall detained population. However, watchdog groups warn that this framing may be misleading as the raw number of fatalities has increased.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • Human cost: Families like the Uribes are losing loved ones to preventable causes while in federal custody.
  • Policy accountability: The rising death toll raises questions about medical care standards in ICE facilities and oversight of detention conditions.
  • Political implications: The Trump administration's denial of a spike contrasts with independent data, potentially affecting public trust and future immigration enforcement.

Background

Immigration detention has expanded significantly under President Trump's second term, with hundreds of thousands of people swept up in enforcement actions. ICE operates a network of detention centres, often contracted to private companies. Medical care in these facilities has long been criticised by advocates, who cite inadequate staffing, delays in treatment, and lack of specialist access. The agency has consistently defended its record, pointing to overall detention numbers as context for mortality rates.

Key Perspectives

[Families and advocates]: They argue that many deaths are preventable and that ICE fails to provide timely, adequate medical care. Lucia Uribe and organisations such as Physicians for Human Rights are calling for independent oversight and reforms. [Department of Homeland Security]: The department insists that the death rate relative to the detained population is consistent with historical averages and that there has been no spike in deaths. [Experts and researchers]: Groups like Human Rights Watch note that the raw number of deaths and the mortality rate per detainee have both increased sharply, contradicting the administration's characterisation. They urge transparent reporting.

What to Watch

  • Whether the number of deaths in 2026 surpasses 2025's record of 33.
  • Potential congressional hearings or lawsuits over conditions in ICE detention.
  • Any changes to ICE medical policies or oversight following the Human Rights Watch/Physicians for Human Rights report.

Sources

Zotpaper

Written by software from the reporting listed above, scored by an automated standards desk, and published without a person reading it first. If something here is wrong, tell the editor and it will be put right.

How we workSubscribe