'Don't let violence win': Cathy McGowan's plea as Helen Haines fights for life

Former Indi MP tells Wodonga vigil the attack on her successor is an attack on democracy, as the accused appears in court without seeking bail

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time3 min
Sources2 outlets
Former independent MP Cathy McGowan has warned that the attack on Helen Haines has struck at the heart of Australian democracy, telling a community vigil in Wodonga that violence must not win. Haines, 65, remains in a critical condition in hospital after having both legs amputated, while the accused, Brendan Nugent, 43, made no application for bail when he fronted Wangaratta Magistrates Court on Wednesday morning.

Hundreds of residents gathered at Wodonga's Holy Trinity Cathedral on Wednesday night for the vigil, held two days after Haines was struck by a car outside her electorate office on Monday afternoon. McGowan, whose historic 2013 election victory helped launch the modern community independents movement, described the assault as an attack on the political system itself.

"That this happened in our town, by one of our community members, to one of us: in the attack on Helen, it is an attack on all of us," McGowan said. "It's so very hard to get our minds around."

The former MP said northeast Victoria was grappling with grief, shame and the confronting reality that one of its own had been attacked in the community she represented. She revealed that Governor-General Sam Mostyn and Prime Minister Anthony Albanese had both been in contact and asked her to convey their condolences to the community. Flowers lined the front of Haines's High Street electoral office, with handwritten well-wishes from residents.

In a show of cross-party solidarity, state MPs Tim McCurdy, Bill Tilley, Cindy McLeish and Annabelle Cleeland joined nine local mayors from across northeast Victoria in a joint statement warning that threats and violence "have absolutely no place in our democracy or in our communities". Civic leaders from Alpine, Benalla, Indigo, Mansfield, Murrindindi, Strathbogie, Towong, Wangaratta and Wodonga said that while robust disagreement was essential to democracy, targeted harassment abandoned basic humanity.

"We should challenge our elected representatives, we should question their decisions, we should demand better of them. But there is a line," they said, pledging that "decency still outweighs division".

McGowan said conversations across Indi since Monday had exposed deeper scars, particularly among women already living with the threat of violence. Many women were scared for their own safety and the safety of women in public positions, and questioned whether they could enter public life without facing violence, she said.

She urged residents not to allow their grief to harden into fear or retreat from political participation, and challenged the community to make next month's Victorian election a demonstration of the democratic values that had been threatened.

"Let's make it the best ever, not only here in [the electoral district of] Benambra but across Victoria," she said. "My ask, in closing, is that we don't let violence win, that we ensure the legacy of this attack on Helen will be a stronger, more vibrant and effective democracy. And from a personal perspective, all candidates and especially women, know they can run for office and be safe."

Nugent made no application for bail at his court appearance on Wednesday morning. Police are weighing up further charges against the accused.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • The attack on a serving federal MP has raised fears for the safety of elected representatives, and of women in particular, in an electorate built on grassroots political participation.
  • McGowan argues the assault is being felt as an attack on the political system and democracy itself, not just on one person.
  • The community's response, including at next month's Victorian election, will test whether the intimidation succeeds in deterring people from public life.

Background

Helen Haines is the independent MP for Indi, the northeast Victorian seat won by Cathy McGowan in 2013 in a result that helped launch the modern community independents movement. On Monday afternoon, Haines, 65, was struck by a car outside her electorate office in Wodonga. She remains in critical condition in hospital after having both legs amputated. Brendan Nugent, 43, was charged and made no application for bail when he appeared at Wangaratta Magistrates Court. The attack has shaken the political culture that has defined Indi for more than a decade, and comes ahead of the Victorian state election next month.

Key Perspectives

Cathy McGowan and the community independents movement: The attack is an attack on all of us and on democracy. The response must be to strengthen civic participation, not retreat from it, and to ensure candidates, especially women, can run for office safely.

Regional political and civic leaders: Threats and violence have no place in democracy. Robust disagreement is essential, but targeted harassment crosses a line. In their joint statement they pledged that decency still outweighs division.

Women considering public life: McGowan says many women in Indi now fear for their own safety and the safety of women in public positions, and question whether they can enter public life without facing violence. This concern could undermine the grassroots political culture the region has built.

What to Watch

  • Haines's condition in hospital, where she remains in a critical state.
  • The court process for Nugent, who made no bail application, and whether further charges are laid.
  • The Victorian election next month, which McGowan has framed as a test of whether violence wins or democracy is strengthened.

Sources

Checked

12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.

Show each claim
  1. SupportedThe headline quotes McGowan’s plea: “Don’t let violence win.”Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “‘Don’t let violence win’: McGowan’s plea as Haines fights for life.”
  2. SupportedThe summary attributes to McGowan the view that the attack on Haines was an attack on democracy.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: ““It’s about Helen in her role as our elected representative – in attacking her, we intuit that this is an attack on our political system, on our democracy.””
  3. SupportedNugent made no application for bail at Wangaratta Magistrates Court on Wednesday morning.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Brendan Nugent, 43, made no application for bail when he fronted Wangaratta Magistrates Court on Wednesday morning.”
  4. SupportedHaines, 65, remained in critical condition in hospital after having both legs amputated.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Haines, 65, remains in a critical condition in hospital , having had both legs amputated”
  5. SupportedMcGowan said, “That this happened in our town, by one of our community members, to one of us: in the attack on Helen, it is an attack on all of us.”Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: ““That this happened in our town, by one of our community members, to one of us: in the attack on Helen, it is an attack on all of us,” McGowan said.”
  6. SupportedMcGowan said, “It's so very hard to get our minds around.”Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: ““It’s so very hard to get our minds around.””
  7. SupportedHundreds attended a vigil at Wodonga’s Holy Trinity Cathedral on Wednesday night.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “In an emotional address to hundreds of residents gathered at a community vigil in Wodonga on Wednesday night”
  8. SupportedHaines was struck outside her electorate office on Monday afternoon, two days before the Wednesday-night vigil.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “having had both legs amputated after a Tarrawingee man drove into her outside her electorate office on Monday afternoon.”
  9. SupportedGovernor-General Sam Mostyn and Prime Minister Anthony Albanese contacted McGowan and asked her to convey their condolences to the community.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “The former MP revealed Governor-General Sam Mostyn and Prime Minister Anthony Albanese had both been in contact and asked her to convey their condolences to the community.”
  10. SupportedState MPs Tim McCurdy, Bill Tilley, Cindy McLeish and Annabelle Cleeland joined nine local mayors in a joint statement.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “state MPs Tim McCurdy, Bill Tilley, Cindy McLeish and Annabelle Cleeland joined nine local mayors from across northeast Victoria”
  11. SupportedThe regional leaders said threats and violence “have absolutely no place in our democracy or in our communities”.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “In a joint statement, the regional leaders warned that threats and violence “have absolutely no place in our democracy or in our communities”.”
  12. SupportedPolice are weighing up further charges against Nugent.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Court appearance: Police weigh up further charges against accused attacker Brendan Nugent”

Zotpaper

Written by Rex Doyle on the Australia & local desk. Claims checked by Ines Fairley, verification. Read for legal risk by Marcus Hale, legal. Edited by Angus Burke, chief sub.

1 source12 of 12 claims matched to a sourcefirst published
Meet the newsroomHow we workSubscribe