Estonia is developing a strategy to run its government's digital services entirely from the cloud if its territory is occupied by a foreign enemy, officials have said, as the Baltic nation prepares for the possibility of a Russian invasion.
The plan, known as hukukindlus (Estonian for 'doomsday resilience'), would allow the country's digital services to operate from abroad in the event that data centres are destroyed or an enemy occupies the country, according to Tõnu Grünberg, an architect of the new strategy and former deputy secretary general for digital infrastructure and cybersecurity at Estonia's Ministry of Justice and Digital Affairs.
"Now we want to really be online, whatever happens," Grünberg said. "All critical services stay online … Everything needs to stay operational."
Estonia already maintains a data backup in a 'digital embassy' in Luxembourg that includes citizen registries, land registries and its legal code. The new plan goes further, aiming to keep the government functioning during a crisis.
"Ideally, we would like to build systems that can withstand every possible crisis, but in reality no country can predict or eliminate every risk," said Allan Allmere, an adviser for IT architecture and infrastructure at the Ministry of Justice and Digital Affairs. "In the most severe scenarios, we also need to preserve a trusted foundation from which Estonia's digital state can be rebuilt."
The Estonian government is building secure applications on cloud providers including Microsoft Azure and Amazon Web Services, as well as its own state cloud platform. The system is being shipped to its data embassy and other locations in Europe, Grünberg said.
The Baltic country of 1.3 million shares a 294-kilometre border with Russia. Security services have warned that Russia is waging a hybrid war on Europe, and Estonia has blamed Moscow for cyberattacks, arson plots and cuts to undersea data cables.
The danger to digital services was apparent in 2007, when Estonia faced a wave of cyberattacks lasting 22 days that brought down large swathes of commercial and government services. The country's authorities later attributed the attacks to Russia. The incident prompted a complete overhaul of Estonia's digital infrastructure, making it what some consider the world's most digitised state.
"They have taken a remarkably forward-leaning approach in terms of digitizing government services," said Joseph Jarnecki, senior research fellow at the Royal United Services Institute (RUSI) think tank in London.
Recent attacks on data centres in Russia have underlined how critical digital services have become for countries at war. Ukraine struck three data centres belonging to Russian provider Yandex last month, showing how targeting compute power had become akin to striking a power plant.
The Estonian plan is part of a broader shift in thinking about digital security. Until recently, the debate focused on keeping control close to home by storing data locally. Now states facing heightened risks of conflict are spreading the risks to digital infrastructure. On Thursday, the United Kingdom and Norway announced they are looking at ways to host each other's secure data by setting up their own data embassies.
Jarnecki said Estonia is investing in partnerships with safe third countries for security and resilience, rather than saying everything should be physically under its own control.
Allmere said the country is also preparing for the next challenge: ensuring that the same data remains understandable and usable decades from now.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- Estonia's plan represents a new model for government continuity in the digital age, where a nation's critical functions can be operated remotely
- The strategy reflects how smaller nations bordering hostile powers are adapting to hybrid warfare that targets digital and physical infrastructure
- The approach may influence other countries' resilience planning, particularly as cloud computing and data embassy concepts gain traction
Background
Estonia became one of the world's most digitised states after a wave of cyberattacks in 2007 that the government attributed to Russia. The country has since built a comprehensive digital infrastructure, with citizens accessing government services online for everything from voting to healthcare. The new doomsday plan extends this digital state by ensuring it can function even if Estonia's physical territory is occupied.
Key Perspectives
Tõnu Grünberg: The former deputy secretary general and architect of the strategy said Estonia wants to move its public services to the cloud "either when data centers are destroyed or there's boots on the ground and we cannot operate," and that "now we want to really be online, whatever happens."
Allan Allmere: The Estonian official managing the doomsday resilience plan said the country is working to preserve a trusted foundation from which the digital state can be rebuilt, and that "we should never have to start again from zero."
Joseph Jarnecki: The RUSI senior research fellow said Estonia has "taken a remarkably forward-leaning approach" to digitising government services and is investing in partnerships with safe third countries rather than insisting on physical control within its own territory.
What to Watch
- Whether Estonia's cloud infrastructure providers (Microsoft, Amazon) guarantee continued service during a crisis scenario
- The response from Russia and any accusations that the plan is escalatory or provocative
- Adoption of similar 'data embassy' and cloud continuity models by other nations, particularly those bordering Russia
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedEstonia is preparing a cloud plan for its government to operate if the country is occupied.Politico Europe: “Officials in Estonia are preparing for exactly such a scenario with a new strategy to boost doomsday resilience — hukukindlus in Estonian — that would allow the government’s digital services to be run entirely from abroad if its territory is occupied by a foreign enemy.”
- SupportedThe plan would allow Estonia’s digital services to operate from abroad as part of its doomsday-resilience strategy.Politico Europe: “a new strategy to boost doomsday resilience — hukukindlus in Estonian — that would allow the government’s digital services to be run entirely from abroad if its territory is occupied by a foreign enemy.”
- SupportedOfficials are developing the strategy as Estonia prepares for the possibility of a Russian invasion.Politico Europe: “The Baltic country of 1.3 million, which shares a 294-kilometer border with Russia, fears it is a prime target if Moscow were to invade a European Union country.”
- SupportedGrünberg said, “Now we want to really be online, whatever happens.”Politico Europe: ““Now we want to really be online, whatever happens,” Grünberg said.”
- SupportedGrünberg said, “All critical services stay online … Everything needs to stay operational.”Politico Europe: ““All critical services stay online … Everything needs to stay operational.””
- SupportedAllmere said, “In the most severe scenarios, we also need to preserve a trusted foundation from which Estonia's digital state can be rebuilt.”Politico Europe: ““In the most severe scenarios, we also need to preserve a trusted foundation from which Estonia’s digital state can be rebuilt.””
- SupportedJarnecki said Estonia has taken “a remarkably forward-leaning approach in terms of digitizing government services.”Politico Europe: ““They have taken a remarkably forward-leaning approach in terms of digitizing government services,” said Joseph Jarnecki, senior research fellow at the Royal United Services Institute (RUSI) think tank in London.”
- SupportedEstonia’s existing digital embassy in Luxembourg holds a backup that includes citizen registries, land registries and the country’s legal code.Politico Europe: “Estonia already has a data backup in its “digital embassy” in Luxembourg, effectively a copy of the country’s blueprint that includes everything from citizen registries to land registries and its legal code.”
- SupportedEstonia has 1.3 million people and shares a 294-kilometre border with Russia.Politico Europe: “The Baltic country of 1.3 million, which shares a 294-kilometer border with Russia”
- SupportedEstonia’s 2007 cyberattack wave lasted 22 days and brought down large swathes of commercial and government services.Politico Europe: “in 2007 when the country faced a wave of cyberattacks lasting 22 days that brought down large swathes of commercial and government services.”
- SupportedEstonian authorities later attributed the 2007 attacks to Russia.Politico Europe: “The country’s authorities later attributed the attacks to Russia.”
- SupportedAllmere said the same data must remain understandable and usable decades from now.Politico Europe: ““We also need to ensure that the same data remains understandable and usable decades from now,” Allmere said.”