The European Union is pushing the British government for a firm commitment to guarantee that European students will pay the lower domestic rate on university tuition fees, with at least six member states calling for a resolution before a key summit later this month. Failure to agree could delay the implementation of a food and drink deal worth billions to the UK economy, according to EU sources.
The demand comes ahead of a Brussels summit on 20 November where Andy Burnham is expected to meet EU leaders Ursula von der Leyen and António Costa. The meeting aims to sign three agreements on food and drink, carbon markets and youth exchange, and pledge a "trusted partnership" on steel and defence. However, the longstanding dispute over whether EU students should pay costly international tuition fees, which can be four to six times higher than domestic rates for an undergraduate degree, remains unresolved and could hold up the food and energy deals.
EU Commission negotiators have proposed postponing agreement on tuition fees by six months to ensure the summit's success, but at least six member states, including from central and eastern Europe, want the issue settled by the summit, according to four EU sources.
One EU diplomat told the Guardian: "Having a youth experience scheme without an agreement on tuition fees has very little added value," noting the lower cost of university education in many EU countries. A second diplomat said there was cautious optimism about the summit but "a large majority" wanted "a more convincing British commitment" on tuition fees.
A UK government spokesperson said: "We do not comment on leaks or provide a running commentary on live negotiations. We are building an ambitious, close relationship with the EU that will strengthen our economy, protect British industry, and create more opportunities for young people across the UK."
For the EU, the creation of a youth experience scheme known as Yes, which will enable those aged 18 to 30 to live, work and study on both sides of the Channel, is a high priority. EU officials argue the bloc has leverage: the food and drink deal, a Labour manifesto pledge estimated to be worth £5.1bn a year to the British economy, would come into force only if there was a satisfactory agreement on tuition fees. Similarly, the agreement to relink emissions trading systems sundered by Brexit could also be delayed. A leaked version of the summit statement hints at a link between the trio of agreements, looking forward to "their joint and timely entry into force".
This week the Guardian reported that the UK was prepared to spend up to £450m a year to give EU students discounted university tuition fees if Brussels allowed Britain access to the Made in Europe industrial programme. The EU said there would be no deal on Made in Europe at the November summit because the bloc was still finalising its position on the key draft law, the Industrial Accelerator Act. France is pushing for a narrow definition of Made in Europe, while Germany leads a larger group of countries that do not want to exclude trade partners including the UK. France and Germany struck a compromise favourable to the UK, but it only applies to cars, not other industrial sectors.
In a win for the UK, the draft summit statement proposes a "trusted partnership" on strategic industries, starting with steel and defence. Separately, EU sources have suggested that without a deal on tuition fees, the EU could delay talks on British reintegration into the European electricity market expected to intensify next year.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The outcome will affect hundreds of thousands of EU students seeking to study in the UK and British students in the EU under the youth exchange scheme.
- The food and drink deal, worth an estimated £5.1bn annually, is central to the UK's post-Brexit economic relationship; its delay would hit businesses and consumers.
- The summit is a test of the reset between the UK and EU under Prime Minister Andy Burnham.
Background
Since Brexit, EU students have been classified as international students in the UK, paying much higher tuition fees than domestic students. The UK government has been negotiating a closer relationship with the EU, and the November summit is seen as a key moment to sign multiple agreements. The dispute over tuition fees has become a sticking point, with the EU seeking a return to pre-Brexit arrangements and the UK balancing domestic political pressures.
Key Perspectives
EU member states (at least six): want a clear commitment from the UK by the summit that EU students will pay the domestic tuition rate.
EU Commission negotiators: have proposed postponing agreement on tuition fees by six months to allow the summit to proceed.
UK government: says it does not comment on leaks but is building an ambitious relationship with the EU that strengthens the economy and creates opportunities.
France: is pushing for a narrow definition of "Made in Europe" that could exclude UK goods from strategic industrial subsidies.
Germany: leads a group of countries that do not want to exclude trade partners including the UK from the industrial programme.
What to Watch
- The outcome of the 20 November summit and whether a tuition fee agreement is reached.
- Whether the food and drink and carbon market deals are delayed if tuition fees remain unresolved.
- The progress of the Industrial Accelerator Act in the European Parliament, which will determine the scope of Made in Europe and UK access.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 11 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedThe EU is pressing the UK to guarantee discounted university tuition for European students before the summit.World news | The Guardian: “The EU is seeking a firmer pledge from the British government to guarantee European students discounted rates on university tuition fees before a much-anticipated summit this month.”
- SupportedAt least six member states want a clear commitment ahead of the 20 November meeting.World news | The Guardian: “At a meeting of senior EU diplomats on Wednesday, at least six member states called for a clear commitment from the UK by the time of the summit”
- SupportedThe failure to agree could delay the food and drink deal, which is worth billions to the UK economy, according to EU sources.World news | The Guardian: “Many believe a failure to reach an agreement should delay the highly prized food and drink deal”
- SupportedEuropean students could pay domestic tuition rates under the proposed commitment.World news | The Guardian: “EU students will pay the lower domestic rate of university tuition fees.”
- SupportedThe 20 November meeting in Brussels is expected to bring Andy Burnham together with Ursula von der Leyen and António Costa.World news | The Guardian: “Andy Burnham will meet the EU leaders Ursula von der Leyen and António Costa on 20 November in Brussels”
- Partly supportedInternational undergraduate tuition fees can be four to six times higher than domestic fees.World news | The Guardian: “international fees, which can be about four to six times higher for an undergraduate degree.”
- SupportedEuropean Commission negotiators proposed postponing an agreement on tuition fees by six months.World news | The Guardian: “European Commission negotiators have proposed postponing an agreement on tuition fees by six months”
- SupportedOne EU diplomat said a youth experience scheme without a tuition-fee agreement had “very little added value.”World news | The Guardian: ““Having a youth experience scheme without an agreement on tuition fees has very little added value,””
- SupportedA second diplomat said a “large majority” wanted “a more convincing British commitment” on tuition fees.World news | The Guardian: ““a large majority” wanted “a more convincing British commitment” on tuition fees.”
- SupportedThe UK government spokesperson said: “We do not comment on leaks or provide a running commentary on live negotiations. We are building an ambitious, close relationship with the EU that will strengthen our economy, protect British industry, and create more opportunities for young people across the UK.”World news | The Guardian: ““We do not comment on leaks or provide a running commentary on live negotiations. We are building an ambitious, close relationship with the EU that will strengthen our economy, protect British industry, and create more opportunities for young people across the UK.””
- SupportedThe food and drink deal is estimated to be worth £5.1bn a year to the UK economy and would come into force only if there were a satisfactory agreement on tuition fees.World news | The Guardian: “the food and drink deal – a Labour manifesto pledge estimated to be worth £5.1bn a year to the British economy – would come into force only if there was a satisfactory agreement on tuition fees.”
- SupportedThe Guardian reported that the UK was prepared to spend up to £450m a year on discounted tuition for EU students if Brussels allowed UK access to the Made in Europe programme.World news | The Guardian: “This week the Guardian reported that the UK was prepared to spend up to £450m a year to give EU students discounted university tuition fees if Brussels allowed Britain access to the Made in Europe industrial programme.”