UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham said Europe had “a clear and consistent and united negotiating position,” while German Chancellor Friedrich Merz stressed that Moscow’s “maximalist demands are not realistic.” The leaders were speaking at Berlin’s summit of Ukraine’s allies, known as the Coalition of the Willing.
The summit followed historic trilateral talks in Shenzhen, China, between US President Donald Trump, Putin and Chinese President Xi Jinping. Trump later dialled into the Berlin summit from Air Force One. Jared Kushner, one of two US envoys in Berlin, said Trump wanted to make a deal with Moscow “with Europe by his side.”
In a lengthy press conference after his Shenzhen talks, Putin said the Americans were “insistently” asking Russia to allow European participation in peace talks. He claimed Russia was not against the idea but wanted to clarify “what Europe will bring to these talks.” He said Russia had invited Europeans to Moscow to determine their positions, after which a format for dialogue with Ukraine would be decided. Putin also said that “discussing issues linked to security in Europe is pointless without the Europeans,” though Russia has so far rejected any European role in US-led peace talks.
Kushner told reporters the US president believed “peace is achievable” after Shenzhen. He said Russia was willing to trust the instinct of US envoys “on our behalf” that Europe should be at the table, and that Moscow was now “comfortable” with Ukraine having security guarantees based on the collective defence principle enshrined in NATO’s Article Five. Zelensky has long sought such a guarantee, but Putin has shown little sign of accepting it; Russia rejects outright Ukrainian membership of NATO.
Zelensky and the three European leaders, Merz, Burnham and French President Emmanuel Macron, were less optimistic. “Putin has always said no,” Zelensky said. Merz acknowledged that with US involvement the chance of peace was increasing, but said Europe was willing to enter “serious discussions on European security” with Russia only “as long as it’s matched with a serious discussion and only first a peace agreement with Ukraine.” He rejected any division of Europe into spheres of influence run by major powers, calling the Shenzhen summit “a photo opportunity” and saying “a ‘Yalta format’ will not bring peace.”
Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk took exception to Trump describing Putin as a “friend,” saying “Mr Putin is not our friend and will never be.” Macron urged allies to do the “maximum” to deliver air defence systems to Kyiv and to “reopen the question” of Ukraine’s NATO membership.
There have been mixed signals from Moscow on European participation. Last week, US envoys appeared certain Europe would soon have a seat at the table, but Putin’s aide Yury Ushakov said a “great deal” would have to be done before the format could be expanded, suggesting further rounds of discussions were needed.
While Russia has engaged in several rounds of talks over the last year, Moscow continues to pound Ukrainian energy infrastructure as winter takes hold, and has not budged from its demands for Ukrainian sovereign territory. On Thursday, several buildings in Kyiv’s historic centre were damaged in a drone attack, killing one person. Putin also vowed that Russia’s response to a Ukrainian strike on the Crimean Bridge would be “considerably more painful” than what Kyiv had achieved, and said he had discussed a “possible ceasefire in a number of areas” but decided against it after the bridge attack. He claimed to be “interested” in ending the war and ready to make compromises, but said Ukraine and Europe were not.
Kyiv and its European allies say the Kremlin leader is seeking to break Ukrainian resistance by leaving millions of civilians without electricity and water, in the absence of major front-line success.