Rinderknecht, 30, was found guilty of two counts: destruction of property by means of fire and arson affecting property used in interstate commerce. He showed little reaction, hugging his attorneys before leaving the courtroom. His father was present.
The Palisades Fire began as a brush fire on Jan. 1, 2025, known as the Lachman Fire, which firefighters initially suppressed. Embers smoldered underground and flared up again on Jan. 7, driven by powerful winds, becoming one of the most destructive wildfires in California history. Prosecutors argued Rinderknecht used a lighter to start the initial brush fire.
In the retrial, prosecutors presented a more tightly organized case than the first trial. They focused on digital forensic data, cellphone tower data pointing to Rinderknecht’s movement on the hill, fire detection camera images showing the ignition window, and expert testimony ruling out other possible causes such as fireworks. They also introduced evidence of Rinderknecht's state of mind in the hours before the fire: testimony from Uber passengers and text messages to his girlfriend. Assistant U.S. Attorney Mark Williams said he "was mad at everything, and frustrated."
Prosecutors said Rinderknecht called 911 more than a dozen times as he walked down the hill after the fire began and screen-recorded the calls on his phone. During the calls, he asked ChatGPT: "Are you at fault if a fire is lit because of your cigarettes?" Prosecutors said these were part of an alibi he was trying to create for himself.
Defense attorney Steve Haney challenged the government's case, arguing the fire scene could have been compromised because the area was accessible to the public for six days after the initial blaze. "Six days of anyone and everyone walking across the spot the government now calls a crime scene," he said. The defense called its own expert witnesses, including a retired U.S. Forest Service fire investigator who argued the origin area was different from what the government concluded. Haney pointed to a neighbor's testimony about seeing a group of teenagers running away from the direction of the trailhead and argued that missing cell data records meant the government could not conclusively say no one else was by the fire's ignition point.
He told jurors to disregard evidence about Rinderknecht's character, calling angry text messages "evidence of the man, not evidence of the act." The defense also presented an alternative explanation: fireworks. Multiple witnesses, including a local firefighter, said they heard a loud bang from the direction of the hill that night. Prosecutors dismissed the theory as "baseless," saying thousands of camera images showed no fireworks in the sky above the fire's origin.
Rinderknecht was originally charged with a third count of timber set afire, which prosecutors dropped when they filed the new indictment. Jurors in the retrial were instructed not to consider the Los Angeles Fire Department's role in suppressing the Lachman Fire. The first jury deadlocked 10 to 2 in favor of acquittal.
Sentencing is scheduled for March 17.