The lawyer for a woman raped by former Scotland international footballer David Goodwillie has told the Court of Criminal Appeal that prosecutors made a mistake in deciding not to put him on trial for the attack, as she seeks permission for a rare private prosecution.
Thomas Ross KC, representing Denise Clair, argued that the Crown Office “got it wrong” when it dropped rape charges against Goodwillie due to insufficient evidence. Clair has brought an action to the appeal court in Edinburgh to grant permission for a private prosecution against Goodwillie.
Goodwillie was ruled a rapist in a civil court in 2017, the first such case of its kind in Scotland, after Clair brought a civil action. Lord Armstrong ordered him and his then-Dundee United teammate David Robertson to pay Clair £100,000 in damages.
Ross told judges Lord Pentland, Lord Matthews and Lady Carmichael that a “substantial body of evidence” had been provided in Clair’s case before judges threw out the claim in July 2011. He described the decision not to prosecute as “irrational”, adding: “There was a sufficient body of evidence available which would have allowed a prosecution to proceed and there was a reasonable chance of conviction. Our position is that in the circumstances the Crown have got it wrong.”
Alan Cameron KC, for the Crown, told the court that prosecutors had acted correctly when they decided not to prosecute Goodwillie. He said that when all the evidence available in the case was considered, the Crown were entitled not to bring Goodwillie to court, and that “there are no exceptional circumstances which would permit the issuing of criminal letters.”
Goodwillie’s lawyer, Lord Stewart of Dirleton KC, argued the legal tests needed to bring a private prosecution were not passed. He also said the use of evidence given by Goodwillie during the civil case in the new case was unfair, noting that “had it been clear that a prosecution was going to follow, then the Lord Advocate should have issued a warning.”
The court heard that, for the action to succeed, Clair’s lawyers must prove that prosecutors had made a decision that “no reasonable” prosecutors could have made, a legal test described as a “high standard”.
Lord Pentland, Scotland’s most senior judge, said the appeal court would take time to consider all submissions and would issue a judgement “as soon as practicable.”
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The case tests the scope for private prosecutions in Scotland, a rare legal route rarely granted.
- A successful bid could lead to a criminal trial more than a decade after the alleged rape, offering a potential avenue for victims when the Crown declines to prosecute.
- The outcome may influence public confidence in prosecutorial decisions and the handling of sexual offence allegations.
Background
David Goodwillie, a former Scotland international footballer, was found to have raped Denise Clair in a civil court in 2017, the first civil rape case of its kind in Scotland. Clair had alleged the footballers raped her after a night out in January 2011 when she was intoxicated. The Crown dropped criminal charges in 2011 citing insufficient evidence. Clair now seeks permission to bring a private criminal prosecution against Goodwillie, arguing the Crown’s decision was wrong.
Key Perspectives
Thomas Ross KC (for Denise Clair): argued the Crown “got it wrong” by not prosecuting, describing the decision as “irrational” and stating there was a sufficient body of evidence for a reasonable chance of conviction.
Alan Cameron KC (for the Crown): said prosecutors acted correctly and were entitled not to bring Goodwillie to court based on the evidence, and that no exceptional circumstances exist to permit criminal letters.
Lord Stewart of Dirleton KC (for David Goodwillie): contended the legal tests for a private prosecution were not met and that using Goodwillie’s civil evidence in a criminal case was unfair without a warning.
What to Watch
- The court’s judgement, expected to be issued “as soon as practicable”, on whether to grant permission for a private prosecution.
- Potential further legal challenges or a full criminal trial if permission is granted.
- Broader fallout for the Crown Office’s handling of rape cases and possible reform calls.
Checked
11 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 11 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedThe headline says prosecutors “got it wrong” in a court hearing about a private prosecution bid.BBC Scotland: “Our position is that in the circumstances the Crown have got it wrong.”
- SupportedDenise Clair’s lawyer argues the Crown made a mistake by not putting David Goodwillie on trial for rape as the appeal hearing begins.BBC Scotland: “The lawyer for a woman raped by former Scotland international footballer David Goodwillie said prosecutors made a "mistake" in not putting him on trial for the attack.”
- SupportedClair is seeking permission from the Court of Criminal Appeal in Edinburgh to bring a private prosecution against Goodwillie.BBC Scotland: “Clair has brought an action to the Court of Criminal Appeal in Edinburgh to grant permission for a rare private prosecution against Goodwillie.”
- SupportedThe Crown Office dropped rape charges against Goodwillie because of insufficient evidence, according to Clair’s lawyer.BBC Scotland: “Her lawyer, Thomas Ross KC, has argued the Crown Office "got it wrong" in deciding to drop rape charges against him due to "insufficient evidence".”
- SupportedA civil court ruled Goodwillie a rapist in 2017, in Scotland’s first civil rape case of its kind.BBC Scotland: “The judge who heard that case at the Court of Session, Lord Armstrong, ruled both of the men to be rapists and ordered them to pay Clair £100,000 in damages. It was the first civil rape case of its kind in Scotland.”
- SupportedRoss said a substantial body of evidence had been provided before judges threw out the claim in July 2011.BBC Scotland: “He said a "substantial body of evidence" had been provided in Clair's case before judges threw out the claim in July 2011.”
- SupportedRoss argued there was enough evidence to prosecute and a reasonable chance of conviction, and said the Crown had got it wrong.BBC Scotland: “There was a sufficient body of evidence available which would have allowed a prosecution to proceed and there was a reasonable chance of conviction. "Our position is that in the circumstances the Crown have got it wrong."”
- SupportedAlan Cameron KC told the court the Crown had acted correctly and was entitled not to bring Goodwillie to court.BBC Scotland: “Alan Cameron KC, for the Crown, told the court that prosecutors had acted correctly when it decided not to prosecute Goodwillie. He said that when all the evidence available in the case was considered, the Crown were entitled not to bring Goodwillie to court.”
- SupportedGoodwillie’s lawyer argued the legal tests for a private prosecution were not met and that using his civil-case evidence in the new case was unfair.BBC Scotland: “His lawyer, Lord Stewart of Dirleton KC, said the legal tests needed to bring a private prosecution were not passed. Lord Stewart also argued the use of evidence given by Goodwillie during the civil case in this new case was unfair.”
- SupportedClair’s lawyers must show that no reasonable prosecutor could have made the decision, a test described as high.BBC Scotland: “The court heard that, for the action to be successful, Clair's lawyers must prove that prosecutors had made a decision that "no reasonable" prosecutors could have made. The legal test was described as being of a "high standard".”
- SupportedLord Pentland said the appeal court would consider the submissions and issue a judgment as soon as practicable.BBC Scotland: “Lord Pentland, Scotland's most senior judge, said the appeal court would take time to consider all submissions. He said a judgement would be issued "as soon as practicable".”