Google has secured approval from the Hermantown City Council for a proposed data center in Minnesota, following a unanimous vote on October 30 after at least two postponed meetings and hours of public opposition. The proposed development could cover just over 200 acres, with three buildings spanning approximately 1.66 million square feet. The project still faces three lawsuits and a separate inquiry into its electricity supply.
At a meeting that ended shortly before midnight, the council approved a development agreement, a special use permit, and provisions for decommissioning the site if construction is abandoned or the facility eventually closes.
Council member John Geisler said the decision was about local land use, not wider debates over artificial intelligence or big technology companies. “What we've done tonight is not about AI. It's not about big tech. It's not about software. It's about a project here in Hermantown, a land use application, and agreements that are associated with that,” Geisler said.
During the approval process, Google made several changes to its original plan. The company reduced the number of buildings from four to three, capped their height at 33 feet, and agreed to monitor nearby private wells. It also agreed to withdraw an earlier request for up to $80 million in property tax breaks. The revised arrangement is expected to generate about $3 million in annual property tax for the city, and a separate decommissioning agreement valued at $210 million has been put in place.
Supporters of the project point to those provisions as evidence that Google had responded to local concerns. Opponents, however, argue that the changes did not address the important question of whether a development of this scale belongs in the rural residential area.
The approval does not mean construction can start immediately. Three lawsuits filed by The Minnesota Center for Environmental Advocacy and Stop the Hermantown Data Center challenge the city’s zoning process and ownership of the land, and demand an environmental review. The project also requires about 500 megawatts of power, comparable to the combined demands of homes in Minneapolis, St. Paul, Duluth, and Rochester, according to the Citizens Utility Board of Minnesota. Google still needs approval from the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission on power consumption, despite an agreement with Minnesota Power.
Google is also pursuing a separate data center project near Pine Island, close to Rochester, which is now subject to a more extensive environmental review following a legal settlement.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The Hermantown vote reflects growing tensions between local communities and tech companies building large data centers, a recurring issue across the United States.
- The decision sets a precedent for how Minnesota and other states balance economic benefits against environmental and quality-of-life concerns.
- If the lawsuits succeed or the power approval is denied, it could delay or halt the project, affecting Google's data infrastructure plans in the Midwest.
Background
Data center developments have sparked similar disputes in other states: Alabama residents were unable to stop a 50MW Bitcoin mining facility despite local moratoriums, and a NorthPoint Development proposal in Pennsylvania faced resistance despite financial offers to nearby households. Google's Hermantown project is one of two it is pursuing in Minnesota; the other, near Pine Island, is undergoing a more extensive environmental review after a legal settlement.
Key Perspectives
- Supporters: point to the tax revenue, decommissioning agreement, and environmental monitoring as evidence that Google addressed local concerns.
- Opponents: argue the changes do not resolve the fundamental issue of whether a facility of this size is appropriate for a rural residential area.
- John Geisler, Hermantown council member: said the vote was about a local land use application, not a statement on AI or technology companies.
What to Watch
- The three lawsuits challenging the city's zoning process and demanding an environmental review.
- The Minnesota Public Utilities Commission's decision on the project's power consumption, which is required before construction can begin.
- The progress of Google's other Minnesota data center project near Pine Island, which is undergoing a more extensive environmental review.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedGoogle won Hermantown City Council approval for its Minnesota data center after protests and scaling back its plans.Latest from Tom's Hardware: “Google data center wins approval in Minnesota after protests delay council vote twice — 200-acre project moves forward despite opposition from local residents, tech giant scales down project”
- SupportedGoogle agreed to withdraw its request for up to $80 million in property tax breaks.Latest from Tom's Hardware: “Google also agreed to withdraw an earlier request for up to $80 million in property tax breaks.”
- SupportedGoogle agreed to monitor nearby private wells.Latest from Tom's Hardware: “capped their height at 33 feet, and agreed to monitor nearby private wells”
- SupportedThe proposed development could cover just over 200 acres and include three buildings spanning approximately 1.66 million square feet.Latest from Tom's Hardware: “The proposed development could cover just over 200 acres in a rural residential area outside Duluth with three data center buildings spanning approximately 1.66 million square feet.”
- SupportedThe council's unanimous vote was on October 30, after at least two postponed meetings and hours of public opposition.Latest from Tom's Hardware: “The decision, reached on Friday, October 30, clears a major hurdle for the company following at least two postponed meetings and hours of public opposition”
- SupportedCouncil member John Geisler said the decision concerned local land use, not wider debates over AI or big technology companies.Latest from Tom's Hardware: “Council member John Geisler, however, clarified the move, noting that the decision concerned local land use application rather than the wide debate over artificial intelligence or big technology companies.”
- SupportedGeisler said: “What we've done tonight is not about AI. It's not about big tech. It's not about software. It's about a project here in Hermantown, a land use application, and agreements that are associated with that,”Latest from Tom's Hardware: ““What we've done tonight is not about AI. It's not about big tech. It's not about software. It's about a project here in Hermantown, a land use application, and agreements that are associated with that,” Geissler said.”
- SupportedThe council approved a development agreement, a special use permit and decommissioning provisions for abandonment or eventual closure.Latest from Tom's Hardware: “The council approved a development agreement, a special use permit, and provisions for decommissioning the site if construction is abandoned or the facility eventually closes.”
- SupportedGoogle reduced the plan from four buildings to three and capped their height at 33 feet.Latest from Tom's Hardware: “The company changed its initial plan of putting up four buildings to three, capped their height at 33 feet”
- SupportedThe revised arrangement is expected to generate about $3 million in annual city property tax, and a separate decommissioning agreement is valued at $210 million.Latest from Tom's Hardware: “The revised arrangement is now expected to generate about $3 million in annual property tax for the city, with a separate decommissioning agreement valued at $210 million in place.”
- SupportedThree lawsuits filed by The Minnesota Center for Environmental Advocacy and Stop the Hermantown Data Center challenge the city's zoning process and land ownership and demand an environmental review.Latest from Tom's Hardware: “Three lawsuits filed by The Minnesota Center for Environmental Advocacy and Stop the Hermantown Data Center challenge the city’s zoning process and ownership of the land, and are also demanding the project’s environmental review.”
- SupportedThe project requires about 500 megawatts of power, comparable to the combined demand of homes in Minneapolis, St. Paul, Duluth and Rochester, and still needs Minnesota Public Utilities Commission approval for power consumption.Latest from Tom's Hardware: “The project’s environmental needs are also another pain point, given it requires about 500 megawatts, comparable to the combined demands of homes in Minneapolis, St. Paul, Duluth, and Rochester, as per the Citizens Utility Board of Minnesota. Google still needs approval from the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission on power consumption”