The States of Guernsey has approved a move to keep tax relief on mortgage interest, halting the phased withdrawal agreed in 2015. Deputy Aidan Matthews, who brought the amendment to the Budget, said it was currently the "worst possible time" to consider phasing out the relief.
The relief lets homeowners apply for tax relief on interest paid on the mortgage of their principal residence of up to £3,500 a year. The States agreed to phase the relief out in 2015, but it was frozen between 2024 and 2026.
Speaking against the move, Deputy Neil Inder said the idea was right in isolation, but that if all amendments were approved it would add "£20m to the budget".
Alderney representative Alex Snowdon said the timing of the amendment was “important”. He said many people in Guernsey and Alderney would be working two to three jobs and really struggling to support their mortgage and their families, and that he thought the move sent a strong message that there was an effort to do a little to help people going through a very difficult time.
Deputy Jayne Ozanne said she was “very split” on the amendment because it was an “unfair advantage” to homeowners over renters. She said it would not solve the crisis of people leaving the island, since they cannot afford to save for a deposit while paying high rents. She recognised that families were feeling squeezed, but added: “Two wrongs don't make a right.”
Analysis
Why This Matters
- Homeowners in Guernsey keep up to £3,500 a year in tax relief, easing mortgage costs at a time of higher interest rates.
- The decision favours homeowners over renters, and renters' advocates warn it does nothing to help people save for a deposit or stop people leaving the island.
- The amendment adds to Budget spending, with opponents warning of a £20m impact if all amendments pass.
Background
Guernsey's States agreed in 2015 to phase out mortgage interest tax relief, but the relief was frozen between 2024 and 2026. The approved amendment stops the phased withdrawal and keeps the relief at its current level for principal residences.
Key Perspectives
Deputy Aidan Matthews: said now is the "worst possible time" to consider phasing out the relief.
Deputy Neil Inder: said the idea is right in isolation but would add "£20m to the budget" if all amendments were approved.
Alderney representative Alex Snowdon: said the timing is "important" because people working two or three jobs are struggling to support mortgages and their families.
Deputy Jayne Ozanne: said she was "very split", calling the relief an "unfair advantage" to homeowners over renters that will not solve the crisis of people leaving the island.
What to Watch
- Whether the full Budget passes and how the added cost of the amendment is funded.
- Whether any measures are brought forward to help renters save for deposits.
- How mortgage interest rates move in the coming year while the relief remains in place.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedGuernsey deputies approved keeping mortgage interest tax relief.BBC News: “A move to keep tax relief on interest paid on mortgage payments has been approved.”
- SupportedThe phased withdrawal agreed in 2015 was halted.BBC News: “It also meant that the phased withdrawal of the relief, which was agreed in 2015, would also stop, it was confirmed.”
- SupportedAidan Matthews brought the amendment to the Budget, and the move was approved.BBC News: “A move to keep tax relief on interest paid on mortgage payments has been approved. Deputy Aidan Matthews, who brought the amendment to the Budget in Guernsey”
- SupportedMatthews said it was currently the “worst possible time” to consider phasing out the relief.BBC News: “Deputy Aidan Matthews, who brought the amendment to the Budget in Guernsey, said it was currently the "worst possible time" to consider phasing out the tax relief.”
- SupportedHomeowners can apply for relief on interest paid on the mortgage of their principal residence, up to £3,500 a year.BBC News: “The relief allows homeowners to apply for tax relief on any interest paid on the mortgage of their principle residence of up to £3,500 a year.”
- SupportedThe relief was frozen between 2024 and 2026.BBC News: “The States agreed to phase the tax relief out in 2015, but it was frozen between 2024 - 2026”
- SupportedInder said the idea was right in isolation but that approval of all amendments would add £20m to the budget.BBC News: “Deputy Neil Inder said that, while the idea was right in isolation, if all amendments were approved, it would add "£20m to the budget".”
- SupportedSnowdon said many people in Guernsey and Alderney would be working two to three jobs and struggling to support their mortgage and families.BBC News: “There is a lot of Guernsey and Alderney people will be working two to three jobs that are really struggling to try and support the mortgage and their families.”
- SupportedSnowdon said the amendment sent a strong message that there was an effort to help people going through a very difficult time.BBC News: “I think this sends a strong message that we are trying to do a little bit to try and help people who are going through a very difficult time.”
- SupportedOzanne said she was “very split” because the amendment was an “unfair advantage” to homeowners over renters.BBC News: “Deputy Jayne Ozanne said in the debate that she was "very split" on the amendment because it was an "unfair advantage" to homeowners over renters.”
- SupportedOzanne said the amendment would not solve the crisis of people leaving the island because high rents meant they could not afford to save for a deposit.BBC News: “"This will not solve the crisis of people leaving the island," she said. "They can not afford to save for a deposit for a mortgage because they are paying such high rents," she said.”
- SupportedOzanne said, “Two wrongs don't make a right.”BBC News: “But two wrongs don't make a right.”