The Harare City Council has demolished homes in the St Martins Extension suburb, leaving families homeless and sparking a dispute over land allocations, with residents claiming they bought their stands through official processes and citing a court order that barred demolitions of named applicants’ homes without a valid court order.
Methro Masunga, a single mother of three, said she was jolted awake at around 5am on August 14 by the sound of bulldozers. She had saved for years to buy a residential stand and began paying for it in 2015, receiving an allocation in 2019. She said the arrangement was formalised through the city council in 2020. “I thought they were here for some other business, probably land development or road grading; alas, they had been sent to destroy our homes,” she told Al Jazeera.
The demolitions are part of a wider city council programme to address what authorities say is illegal construction and disputed land sales. Council records seen by Al Jazeera list more than 5,000 houses facing demolition under 37 outstanding High Court orders; these figures concern properties targeted under the wider programme, not homes already demolished. A council task force has inspected 22,255 sites to identify structures on prohibited or unauthorised land.
Council spokesperson Stanley Gama said the municipality was only demolishing structures built illegally whose owners had been warned many times not to proceed with construction. Mayor Jacob Mafume said residents with approved building plans should produce them during inspections. Principal housing director Edgar Dzehonye said residents had been warned against building in the area because it had not been adequately serviced.
In October 2025, Justice Happias Zhou issued a consent order barring the city from evicting named applicants in St Martins or demolishing their homes without a valid court order. The council has maintained it did not demolish properties protected by the order. However, Memory Chengeta, whose house was also demolished, said the municipal authorities “went ahead to destroy the properties” despite the order. “There was a court order for them to stop demolitions,” she said.
Precious Shumba of the Harare Residents’ Trust said the demolitions were particularly troubling because of the court order protecting residents allocated stands by the municipality. “Despite that, the town planning department and legal officers in the Chamber Secretary’s Department issued directives to the Municipal Police to demolish the houses of St Martins Extension residents,” he said. David Jenje, chairman of the St Martins Residents Association, said residents had paid deposits and received allocation letters. He said: “These demolitions were illegal.”
Harare South MP Trymore Kanopula called for a halt to further demolitions until land allocations had been audited and investigated. Minister Daniel Garwe said the government did not carry out demolitions and could not interfere with court processes, but acknowledged the existence of about 5,000 demolition orders.
The constitution prohibits eviction from or demolition of homes without a court order made after considering all relevant circumstances, and the national housing policy calls for alternative accommodation before relocations and demolitions. Residents say no alternative housing was offered. Joachim Nhete, who lost his home after using his retirement package to buy land and build a house, said: “I cannot recover the loss and pain. My hope is in the courts of law that Harare City Council must be held accountable and pay us back.”
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The demolitions have left hundreds homeless and threaten thousands more, undermining property rights for low-income families who invested life savings.
- The dispute exposes failures in land administration and the rule of law, with residents claiming court orders were ignored.
- The situation could lead to prolonged legal battles and further social instability in Harare.
Background
Zimbabwe's constitution prohibits eviction without a court order, and the National Human Settlements Policy calls for alternative accommodation before relocations. A 2019 commission of inquiry into Harare's governance found unauthorised land sales and weak administration. The current demolitions are part of the city's efforts to address illegal construction, but residents argue they are being unfairly targeted.
Key Perspectives
Residents and rights groups: They say they acquired land through official processes and that demolitions violate a court order. They call for accountability and compensation.
Harare City Council: It says it is enforcing planning laws against illegal structures and did not demolish properties protected by the court order.
Government: Minister Daniel Garwe said the government does not conduct demolitions and cannot intervene in court processes, but noted the high number of demolition orders.
What to Watch
- The fate of the more than 5,000 homes subject to demolition orders and whether further enforcement occurs.
- Any response from parliament or the president to calls for an audit of land allocations.
- Potential legal action by residents seeking damages for demolished homes.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 11 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedMasunga said, “I thought they were here for some other business, probably land development or road grading; alas, they had been sent to destroy our homes.”Al Jazeera – Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera: ““I thought they were here for some other business, probably land development or road grading; alas, they had been sent to destroy our homes. We tried to understand, but no one would hear us,” Masunga told Al Jazeera.”
- SupportedChengeta said there was a court order to stop demolitions and that the authorities “went ahead to destroy the properties.”Al Jazeera – Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera: ““There was a court order for them to stop demolitions. The municipal authorities came with no court order that overturned the previous judgement, but went ahead to destroy the properties,” she said.”
- SupportedShumba said town-planning and legal officials directed municipal police to demolish St Martins Extension residents’ houses.Al Jazeera – Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera: ““Despite that, the town planning department and legal officers in the Chamber Secretary’s Department issued directives to the Municipal Police to demolish the houses of St Martins Extension residents,” he said.”
- SupportedJenje said, “These demolitions were illegal.”Al Jazeera – Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera: ““Most of the members had paid deposits of $5,000 as far back as 2018 … Allocations were made in July 2019 after completion of payment of intrinsic land value. All the allocation letters and agreements of sale were signed in February 2020. These demolitions were illegal,” Jenje said.”
- SupportedNhete said, “I cannot recover the loss and pain. My hope is in the courts of law that Harare City Council must be held accountable and pay us back.”Al Jazeera – Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera: ““I cannot recover the loss and pain. My hope is in the courts of law that Harare City Council must be held accountable and pay us back.””
- SupportedThe headline says Harare demolitions left families homeless amid a land-allocation dispute.Al Jazeera – Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera: “Harare demolitions leave families homeless after years of building.”
- Partly supportedResidents say they bought stands through council processes.Al Jazeera – Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera: “Residents say they bought stands through council-linked processes and invested their savings in building homes.”
- SupportedThe city says it is enforcing planning regulations.Al Jazeera – Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera: “The municipality says it is enforcing planning regulations against structures built without the necessary approvals or on land not designated for housing.”
- SupportedMasunga, a single mother of three, was jolted awake at around 5am on August 14 by bulldozers.Al Jazeera – Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera: “At around 5am on Friday, August 14, Methro Masunga, 28, was jolted awake by the sound of bulldozers and shouting municipal police officers.”
- SupportedGama said the municipality was demolishing illegally built structures whose owners had been warned many times not to build.Al Jazeera – Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera: ““We are only demolishing structures built illegally whose owners were told and warned many times not to proceed with construction,” Gama said.”
- SupportedCouncil records listed more than 5,000 houses facing demolition under 37 outstanding High Court orders; these were properties targeted under the wider programme, not homes already demolished.Al Jazeera – Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera: “However, city council records seen by Al Jazeera list more than 5,000 houses facing demolition under 37 outstanding High Court orders. These figures concern properties targeted under the wider programme, not homes already demolished.”
- SupportedIn October 2025, Justice Happias Zhou issued a consent order barring the city from evicting named applicants in St Martins or demolishing their homes without a valid court order.Al Jazeera – Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera: “On October 29, 2025, Justice Happias Zhou issued a consent order in case HCH5444/25, setting aside demolition notices issued to named applicants in St Martins Extension. It barred the City of Harare from evicting those applicants or demolishing their homes without a valid court order.”