Two skulls taken from Brazil in the 19th century, one of which was used in racist eugenics studies at Harvard University, have been repatriated after a four-year campaign to recover them. The remains arrived on Wednesday in Salvador and Rio de Janeiro, carried by Brazilian diplomats in reinforced suitcases containing padded boxes.
The skulls are believed to have belonged to Africans or Afro-Brazilians. One is thought to be from a man who took part in the 1835 urban slave revolt in Salvador, the most significant such uprising in Brazilian history, in which about 600 African Muslims attempted to seize control of the city. Police killed 70 rebels. The man died at a hospital, and a US diplomat, Gideon T Snow, is believed to have sent the skull to Boston. The Bahia Islamic Cultural Centre, which campaigned for its return, named the man Arakunrin, meaning brother in Yoruba.
The other skull was taken from Rio de Janeiro about 160 years ago. It may have belonged to a woman, according to information Harvard researchers shared with Brazilian officials, noting the skull was smaller than that of an adult man but larger than that of a child. Bruno Veras, a historian who followed the repatriation, said the skull may have been taken from a cemetery for newly arrived Africans who died during the Atlantic crossing or soon after disembarking. The person believed to have taken it was Walter Hunnewell, a student from a wealthy Boston family, part of an expedition led by Harvard professor Louis Agassiz, who was in Brazil trying to document physical types to support racist theories.
The remains had been held at Harvard's Peabody Museum of Archaeology and Ethnology. Their existence was revealed in 2022, and Brazilian researchers sought their return but said the process only moved forward after the Brazilian government became involved in late 2024. Concerns grew that Donald Trump's sometimes hostile behaviour toward Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva could derail the repatriation, but it proceeded.
“It’s very important to restore the dignity of these people, which was taken from them in life and in death,” said Carolina Dias dos Reis, a government official who travelled to Boston to sign the agreement with Harvard. “We need to recover our past as a country, however difficult and violent it was, so that we can understand what we are living through in the present: the consequences and scars of structural racism.”
The skulls will not be displayed in museums or have their images released, and the Brazilian government has pledged they will be buried with funeral rites once identification is complete. Researchers in forensic anthropology will try to confirm sex and other information through measurements and microscopic analysis. If necessary, they will seek authorisation for genetic or dating tests.
During a repatriation ceremony in Rio de Janeiro, Ivanir dos Santos, a history professor and cleric of the Afro-Brazilian religion Candomblé, poured a glass of water on the ground. “It was a ritual act because you cannot deal with the remains of our ancestors without paying reverence to them. This is not a research object … for us, that person is still alive in memory and as our ancestor,” he said.
“This history of slavery cannot be undone,” said Irina Feisthauer Silveira, a diplomat who carried one of the skulls. “But acknowledging the mistakes of the past with transparency is a first step towards building a more equal, just and less violent future.”
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The repatriation confronts a painful legacy of scientific racism, in which institutions like Harvard used the remains of enslaved people to support eugenic theories, and acknowledges the ongoing harm of that research.
- For Brazil, where Afro-Brazilians make up the majority of the population but occupy the bottom of socioeconomic indicators, the return of ancestral remains is part of a broader reckoning with the country's history of slavery and structural racism.
- The case sets a precedent for repatriation of human remains held in foreign museums, particularly those taken for unethical research, and may encourage other institutions to review their collections.
Background
The skulls were taken between the 1830s and 1860s, during the transatlantic slave trade, in which Brazil received more enslaved Africans than any other country. Slavery was abolished there in 1888. Harvard's Peabody Museum held the remains for over a century, using them in racist eugenics studies. Brazilian researchers discovered their existence in 2022 and launched a campaign for return, which gained government backing in late 2024. The repatriation was completed this week despite political tensions between the US and Brazilian leaders.
Key Perspectives
Carolina Dias dos Reis (Brazilian government official): called the return a restoration of dignity and said recovering the past is needed to understand present-day consequences and scars of structural racism.
Ivanir dos Santos (history professor and Candomblé cleric): said the remains are not research objects but ancestors still alive in memory, and that reverence must be paid.
Bruno Veras (historian): described the taking of the skulls as violent even in the context of racist research.
Irina Feisthauer Silveira (diplomat): said acknowledging past mistakes is a first step toward a more just future.
What to Watch
- The forensic identification process: whether researchers can confirm sex, age, and origin through measurements and possible genetic testing, and how long burial rites will be delayed.
- Whether Harvard or other institutions review their own collections for similarly acquired human remains in the wake of this case.
- The Brazilian government's handling of the identification and burial process, as it has committed to not displaying the remains.
Checked
10 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 10 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedHarvard returned two skulls likely belonging to enslaved people to Brazil after they were used in eugenics studies.World news | The Guardian: “Two skulls likely belonging to enslaved people returned to Brazil after Harvard used them in eugenics studies.”
- SupportedThe repatriated remains are thought to include a man who took part in the 1835 slave revolt, and their return followed a four-year campaign.World news | The Guardian: “Two skulls, including that of a man believed to have taken part in Brazil’s greatest slave revolt”
- SupportedCarolina Dias dos Reis said, “It’s very important to restore the dignity of these people, which was taken from them in life and in death.”World news | The Guardian: ““It’s very important to restore the dignity of these people, which was taken from them in life and in death,” said Carolina Dias dos Reis”
- SupportedAbout 600 African Muslims attempted to seize control of the city during the 1835 revolt.World news | The Guardian: “in 1835, when about 600 African Muslims attempted to seize control of what was then the country’s second most important city.”
- SupportedPolice killed 70 rebels during the revolt.World news | The Guardian: “They were ultimately defeated by police, who killed 70 rebels.”
- SupportedA US diplomat, Gideon T Snow, is believed to have sent the skull to Boston.World news | The Guardian: “The man died at a hospital, and a US diplomat, Gideon T Snow, is believed to have sent the skull to Boston.”
- SupportedHarvard researchers told Brazilian officials that features of the Rio skull suggested it may have belonged to a woman.World news | The Guardian: “Brazilian government officials, however, said on Wednesday that Harvard researchers had told them that some features – including that the skull was smaller than that of an adult man but larger than that of a child – suggested it may have belonged to a woman.”
- SupportedIvanir dos Santos said the water-pouring was a ritual act and that the person remained alive in memory and as an ancestor.World news | The Guardian: ““It was a ritual act because you cannot deal with the remains of our ancestors without paying reverence to them. This is not a research object … for us, that person is still alive in memory and as our ancestor,” he said.”
- SupportedIrina Feisthauer Silveira said, “This history of slavery cannot be undone,” and described acknowledging past mistakes as a first step toward a more equal, just and less violent future.World news | The Guardian: ““This history of slavery cannot be undone,” said Irina Feisthauer Silveira, a diplomat who carried one of the skulls. “But acknowledging the mistakes of the past with transparency is a first step towards building a more equal, just and less violent future.””
- SupportedThe skulls will not be displayed in museums or have their images released, and the government pledged to bury them with funeral rites once identification is complete.World news | The Guardian: “The skulls will not be displayed in museums or have their images released, and the Brazilian government has pledged that they will be buried with funeral rites as soon as the identification process is complete.”