Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood has ordered a review of how illegal-working fines are issued and collected after a BBC investigation found that at least £150m remained unpaid, according to Home Office figures obtained by the broadcaster.
Opposition politicians called for action against Yousaf, whom the BBC secretly recorded during an undercover investigation. Shadow home secretary Chris Philp called for him to be struck off, while shadow justice minister Nick Timothy wrote to the Solicitors Regulation Authority seeking urgent intervention to stop him practising.
The BBC’s reporting formed part of an 18-month investigation into illegal working and criminality linked to some high-street businesses, including mini-marts and barbershops. A reporter posed as a mini-mart owner facing a £45,000 penalty for employing someone without permission to work.
According to the BBC, Yousaf offered to transfer the penalty into another person’s name for a £4,500 fee. The broadcaster reported that he explained the owner could avoid payment by finding someone overseas willing to declare themselves the business’s owner.
Yousaf said he had never advised anyone to put a penalty into the name of someone who was not responsible for a business, or to give false information to the Home Office, and never would.
“My work is to challenge penalties lawfully, through the routes Parliament has provided, usually on the basis that the person found was not an employee at all,” he told the BBC.
He also said that, when the reporter proposed putting the business into someone else’s name, he explained in writing that he could not advance an untruthful or dishonest case. He said he did not act for the reporter.
The Home Office has launched an investigation into whether the allegations involve a breach of immigration rules. The solicitors regulator said it would consider the information to determine whether further inquiries were needed.
An anonymous law enforcement whistleblower told the BBC that identifying the real owners of businesses employing illegal workers was difficult. She described seeing penalty notices left in a box on a mini-mart counter and said owners sometimes dismissed them as someone else’s responsibility.
Philp said enforcement was turning into a laughing stock. Mahmood said illegal working undermined honest employers, undercut local wages and fuelled organised immigration crime. The government said arrests and raids were at their highest ever levels and removals of illegal workers were up 50%.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The unpaid penalties raise questions about whether issuing fines translates into effective enforcement against employers who break immigration rules.
- The Home Office inquiry and the regulator’s assessment concern separate questions: possible immigration-rule breaches and potential professional misconduct.
Background
Employers are responsible for checking that staff have permission to work. Financial penalties are one enforcement tool, but businesses can challenge them through legal procedures. A lawful challenge is distinct from supplying false information about who bears responsibility for a business.
Key Perspectives
Mohammad Alias Yousaf: Says his work involves lawful challenges to penalties and that he refused to advance a dishonest case for the undercover reporter.
Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood: Says illegal working harms employers and wages and supports organised immigration crime.
Chris Philp and Nick Timothy: Want professional action against Yousaf, with Philp also criticising the government’s enforcement record.
Government: Points to record levels of arrests and raids and an increase in removals of illegal workers.
What to Watch
- Whether the Solicitors Regulation Authority decides that the BBC’s material warrants further investigation.
- The findings of the Home Office inquiry into possible immigration-rule breaches.
- Whether the review of fines leads to changes in how penalties are issued or recovered.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 11 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedThe Solicitors Regulation Authority will examine the BBC’s findings.BBC News: “The Solicitors Regulation Authority has said it will also examine the BBC's findings to see whether there has been misconduct by solicitors or law firms.”
- Partly supportedYousaf denies advising anyone to put a penalty in someone else’s name.BBC News: “Yousaf has denied ever advising anyone to put a penalty into the name of someone who was not responsible for a business”
- SupportedShabana Mahmood ordered a review of how illegal-working fines are issued and collected.BBC News: “In response, Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood ordered a review of the way such fines are issued and collected.”
- SupportedAt least £150m in illegal-working fines remained unpaid, according to Home Office figures obtained by the BBC.BBC News: “at least £150m is currently owed to the government in uncollected illegal-working fines, according to Home Office figures exclusively obtained by the BBC.”
- SupportedChris Philp called for Yousaf to be struck off.BBC News: “Shadow home secretary Chris Philp has called for Yousaf to be "struck off as a solicitor"”
- SupportedNick Timothy wrote to the solicitors regulator seeking urgent intervention to stop Yousaf practising.BBC News: “shadow justice minister Nick Timothy has written to the head of the regulator for solicitors to take "urgent action, and stop Mr Yousaf practising as a solicitor".”
- SupportedYousaf offered to transfer a £45,000 penalty into someone else’s name for £4,500.BBC News: “secretly recorded Yousaf saying he could transfer the penalty into someone else's name for a fee of £4,500.”
- SupportedYousaf told the undercover reporter the owner could avoid paying by finding someone overseas willing to declare themselves the mini-mart’s owner.BBC News: “The Bradford-based solicitor told his potential client he could avoid paying the fine if he was able to find someone overseas prepared to declare themselves the owner of the mini-mart.”
- SupportedYousaf said, “My work is to challenge penalties lawfully, through the routes Parliament has provided, usually on the basis that the person found was not an employee at all.”BBC News: “"My work is to challenge penalties lawfully, through the routes Parliament has provided, usually on the basis that the person found was not an employee at all," Yousaf told the BBC.”
- SupportedThe Home Office launched an investigation into whether the allegations involved a breach of immigration rules.BBC News: “The Home Office said it would be investigating the allegations to see whether there had been a breach of immigration rules.”
- SupportedThe solicitors regulator said it would consider the information to decide whether further inquiries were needed.BBC News: “A spokesman for the Solicitors Regulation Authority said: "We will be considering this information to see if there are any issues arising which we need to look into further."”
- SupportedThe government said arrests and raids were at their highest ever levels and removals of illegal workers were up 50%.BBC News: “The government said "arrests and raids are at their highest ever levels and removals of illegal workers up 50%".”