India has waived 'make in India' procurement rules for foreign forensic technology, including products from Israeli phone-hacking company Cellebrite, an investigation by the digital-rights group Internet Freedom Foundation has found. The waiver cleared a path for agencies to buy at least 422 items and sparked concerns about legal safeguards.
The investigation reviewed documents showing that Home Minister Amit Shah signed a one-year waiver in January, clearing a path for forensic institutions to purchase at least 422 items of foreign technology. The list includes Cellebrite's Pathfinder and other tools, as well as products from Magnet, MSAB, Oxygen Forensics and Belkasoft.
Government tender specifications called for software capable of using login tokens recovered from seized devices to access more than 100 cloud services, including Instagram, WhatsApp, Telegram, Tinder and Slack. Delhi Police also sought tools to extract data from smart devices such as Amazon Alexa and Google Home.
The purchase of similar tools is not limited to the central government. States governed by the opposition Indian National Congress party, Himachal Pradesh, Keralam and Karnataka, also bought phone-extraction and cloning products.
India has no statute or protocol specifically authorising or regulating the forced unlocking and full extraction of data from phones seized by law enforcement. Experts say such data extractions take place in a legal grey zone. Bhandari told Al Jazeera that India has only an internal executive review mechanism, without parliamentary or judicial oversight.
'The whole point of having any oversight is to create a friction for surveillance,' Bhandari said. 'The current legal framework fails in this safeguard.'
Journalists have reported phone seizures. Mohammad Aslam Hussain, a reporter with Siasat Daily, told Al Jazeera his phone was confiscated while he was detained in New Delhi and later returned with selectively deleted footage. YouTuber Dhruv Rathee, a Modi critic, said he believed police had tried to clone his iPhone using Cellebrite tools during his detention, but the attempt may have failed.
Al Jazeera contacted the National Investigation Agency, the Home Ministry and state home departments for comment. None had responded by publication time.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The exemption marks a significant expansion of India's surveillance capacity, potentially enabling broader monitoring of citizens by multiple government agencies.
- Without a legal framework for extracting data from phones, these powerful tools operate in a regulatory void that could be exploited without accountability.
- Purchases by both central and state governments suggest widespread adoption of Israeli phone-hacking technology, raising the risk of targeting journalists, activists and political critics.
Background
India's "make in India" policy prioritises domestic manufacturers in government contracts but allows ministerial exemptions. The country has faced previous allegations of using Israeli spyware, including Pegasus, against opponents. A 2017 Supreme Court ruling made privacy a fundamental right, but no legislation controlling phone data extraction by law enforcement has been enacted.
Key Perspectives
Internet Freedom Foundation: says the exemption reveals an expansion of surveillance capabilities without proper legislative or judicial oversight, operating in a "legal grey zone".
Vrinda Bhandari: argues India's current oversight is limited to internal executive review, leaving citizens with little recourse if they are placed under surveillance.
Indian government: has not commented on these specific findings but has previously denied allegations of unauthorised surveillance.
What to Watch
- Whether the government will introduce legislation to regulate phone data extraction by law enforcement, as called for by digital rights groups.
- Potential legal challenges challenging the constitutionality of the unregulated surveillance under the 2017 privacy ruling.
- Further revelations about the use of Cellebrite and similar tools against journalists and political activists in India.