An inquiry into UK special forces operations in Afghanistan has released photographs described as 'essential evidence' showing soldiers could have executed unarmed people lying asleep.
The public inquiry, examining allegations that the SAS murdered unarmed civilians and detainees on night raids between 2010 and 2013 and planted weapons to cover up the killings, has for the first time made public photos taken of the deceased across two SAS operations. The images show multiple individuals lying in bed with shots to the head.
The inquiry's lead barrister, Oliver Glasgow KC, said the photos may be evidence of possible war crimes and worthy of expert interrogation. Seventeen people were killed across the two operations in Helmand province in 2011. The youngest of those killed in each operation were 15 and 14 years old respectively.
Glasgow described how many "look like they sustained head shots" and in a number of cases "there appears to be a dead body with his head on a pillow". He said further analysis may be able to confirm if the people in the photographs were "shot when asleep".
The graphic photographs show multiple unarmed people lying in bed. One person was tucked under a floral blanket, others with their heads on pillows, blood pooling around their heads. Blood spatter is visible low on the wall in one of the images, consistent with someone being shot while lying down.
Glasgow said the photos appeared to contradict the accounts given by the SAS and would have raised serious questions for the military police officers investigating the operations as potential murders. Lt Col John Harvey, who led the military police's murder probe, agreed they "didn't look right". He told the inquiry his team were clear the photos could be vital evidence. Despite repeated requests by police investigators to submit the photographs for further testing, this never took place.
One of the investigators, speaking on condition of anonymity, told the BBC: "you can see why we were concerned", adding "bullet marks on the walls so low to the ground appeared to undermine the special forces' version of events."
The inquiry is subjecting the photographs to expert forensic analysis.
The public inquiry was established in 2022 in the wake of revelations by BBC Panorama, which has been investigating allegations the SAS executed unarmed civilians and children for more than eight years. Official special forces accounts of the incidents claim Taliban insurgents opened fire on troops as they entered the compounds, forcing the SAS to return fire and kill those inside. However, weaponry experts told the BBC evidence collected by Panorama indicated multiple rounds appeared to have been fired from above, suggesting those killed were either lying down or sitting against the wall and not in a firefight. Family members also told Panorama those killed had been shot cleanly in the head or chest - a common characteristic of a deliberate SAS shooting at close range.
The inquiry also heard evidence that calls into question whether alleged war crimes were thoroughly investigated. It heard how investigators were still in Afghanistan in July 2019 gathering evidence as senior officers prepared to close their murder investigation and inform ministers. One member of the Afghan partner unit that served on operations alongside the SAS told military police he had personally witnessed a British soldier planting a rifle on an unarmed person after they had been killed.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The photographs provide potential forensic evidence that may corroborate longstanding allegations of unlawful killings by British special forces during night raids in Afghanistan, a matter of profound legal and moral consequence.
- The inquiry's findings could affect UK military accountability, the treatment of Afghan families seeking justice, and international perceptions of coalition forces' conduct during the war.
- The case tests whether a public inquiry can overcome decades of secrecy around special forces operations and deliver transparency.
Background
The public inquiry was established in 2022 after an eight-year BBC Panorama investigation alleged that SAS units executed unarmed civilians and children during night raids in Helmand province between 2010 and 2013, and sometimes planted weapons at the scenes. The military police investigated the deaths but closed their murder investigation in 2019. The inquiry is now examining both the alleged killings and the adequacy of the original investigations.
Key Perspectives
Oliver Glasgow KC (inquiry lead barrister): said the photos may be evidence of possible war crimes, appearing to contradict SAS accounts, and that expert analysis may confirm victims were shot while asleep.
Investigative source (anonymous): told the BBC the low bullet marks on walls undermined the special forces' version of events.
SAS (official accounts, as reported by BBC): claim Taliban insurgents opened fire on troops as they entered compounds, forcing return fire that killed those inside.
What to Watch
- The outcome of the expert forensic analysis of the photographs, which may determine whether victims were asleep when shot.
- Whether the inquiry's final report leads to any criminal prosecutions or changes in how the UK investigates special forces operations.
- Potential further testimony from Afghan witnesses or partner unit members about weapons planting.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedInquiry photos show the SAS could have executed people lying asleep.BBC News: “An inquiry into UK special forces operations in Afghanistan has released photos described as "essential evidence", showing soldiers could have executed unarmed people laying asleep.”
- SupportedThe images are described as “essential evidence” in an inquiry into allegations of war crimes during night raids in Helmand province.BBC News: “New photos are 'essential evidence' of possible SAS war crimes, inquiry told.”
- SupportedThe inquiry released photos of deceased people across two SAS operations, showing multiple individuals lying in bed with shots to the head.BBC News: “For the first time, the inquiry has made public photos taken of the deceased, across two SAS operations, that show multiple individuals lying in bed with shots to the head.”
- SupportedGlasgow said many of the people “look like they sustained head shots”.BBC News: “Glasgow described how many "look like they sustained head shots"”
- SupportedGlasgow said that in some cases “there appears to be a dead body with his head on a pillow”.BBC News: “in a number of cases "there appears to be a dead body with his head on a pillow".”
- SupportedGlasgow said further analysis may confirm whether the people in the photos were “shot when asleep”.BBC News: “He said further analysis may be able to confirm if the people in the photographs were "shot when asleep".”
- SupportedHarvey agreed that the photographs “didn't look right”.BBC News: “Lt Col John Harvey, who led the military police's murder probe, agreed they "didn't look right".”
- SupportedAn anonymous investigator told the BBC, “you can see why we were concerned”, and said low bullet marks appeared to undermine the special forces’ account.BBC News: “One of the investigators, speaking on the condition of anonymity, told the BBC "you can see why we were concerned", adding: "Bullet marks on the walls so low to the ground appeared to undermine the special forces' version of events."”
- SupportedSeventeen people were killed across the two Helmand operations in 2011.BBC News: “Seventeen people were killed across the two operations which took place in Helmand province in 2011.”
- SupportedThe youngest people killed in the two operations were 15 and 14, respectively.BBC News: “The youngest of those killed in each of the operations were 15 and 14 years old respectively.”
- SupportedInvestigators were still in Afghanistan in July 2019 gathering evidence as senior officers prepared to close the murder investigation and inform ministers.BBC News: “It heard how investigators were still in Afghanistan in July 2019 gathering evidence as senior officers prepared to close their murder investigation and inform ministers.”
- SupportedA member of the Afghan partner unit told military police he had witnessed a British soldier plant a rifle on an unarmed person after they had been killed.BBC News: “One member of the Afghan partner unit that served on operations alongside the SAS told military police he had personally witnessed a British soldier planting a rifle on an unarmed person after they had been killed.”