An independent Israeli professor who reviewed the medical records of Hussam Abu Safiya, the director of Kamal Adwan hospital in northern Gaza, has raised serious concerns about his health after nearly 23 months in Israeli detention without charge, saying continuous food deprivation, beatings and inadequate care could cost him his life.
Hussam Abu Safiya was detained at work on 27 December 2024 and later held in solitary confinement at Rakefet, an underground prison. Israeli authorities have not brought formal charges against him. He was classified as an unlawful combatant, a designation Israel has used to justify prolonged detention without trial, along with more than 375 medical workers.
Last month, Israel's supreme court rejected a petition to release the doctor. Over the weekend, a district court rejected a separate petition to allow him an independent medical examination, despite findings in his medical records that Prof Amit Tirosh, an independent Israeli specialist who reviewed a file obtained by Physicians for Human Rights Israel (PHRI), said were not adequately investigated.
In an interview with the Guardian, Tirosh said Abu Safiya's weight had fallen from 90kg in January 2025 to 76kg this May. He identified insufficient investigation of chest pain, delays in treating scabies, and a drop in haemoglobin levels that warranted further examination. A 14kg weight loss was very alarming, Tirosh said, especially if its cause was unknown, and a prison physician wrote that it was a common trend among security prisoners associated with their diet. Tirosh said the haemoglobin drop between February and July 2026 came long after the weight loss, so detention or starvation alone could not explain it, and it coincided with reported beatings in Rakefet. Such blood loss can be life-threatening and requires urgent ER evaluation, Tirosh said, and the records showed these urgent problems were not addressed.
Medical records documented bruising around one of Abu Safiya's eyes, dizziness and rib pain in July. He told his lawyers he had been beaten by prison guards, but Tirosh said the records did not explain his injuries.
The district court ruling revealed allegations by Israeli authorities that Abu Safiya had exaggerated his medical problems, set up organisations from prison, influenced other prisoners and maintained international contacts. PHRI said the allegations did not justify denying him an independent medical examination, a right protected by law. Tirosh said refusing an independent examination is never justified, and told the Israeli prison system authorities he felt deep shame to be counted with them as a doctor or health provider in Israel, saying as a system they betray every medical and ethical principle he stands for.
The Israeli prison service did not immediately respond to a request for comment. A spokesperson for the IPS told the Guardian the allegations are part of a broader campaign aimed at discrediting the state of Israel, and that the IPS operates in accordance with the law and under constant judicial oversight.
Abu Safiya had become the face of health workers struggling to treat patients throughout the war in Gaza before his detention. He is being held indefinitely along with thousands of other Palestinian civilians in prisons Israeli rights groups have described as torture camps. At the time of his arrest he was wearing a white medical coat he had refused to wash since his son, Ibrahim, was killed by a drone strike at the hospital entrance that October. He had helped keep the hospital running through more than 80 days of siege and attacks by Israeli forces.
Naji Abbas of PHRI said 14 Palestinian doctors, including hospital directors, remain imprisoned without charge or trial at a time when Gaza's healthcare system desperately needs them. Abu Safiya's family have not been able to communicate with him directly in detention.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- Abu Safiya's deteriorating health and lack of charge raise urgent medical and legal questions about Israel's detention of medical workers without trial
- The case highlights the broader crisis in Gaza's healthcare system, where the reported detention of at least 14 doctors without charge compounds a shortage of medical personnel
- The refusal of an independent medical examination, despite a legal right, could set a precedent affecting other detainees' access to care
Background
Hussam Abu Safiya was the director of Kamal Adwan hospital in northern Gaza. He was detained by Israeli forces in December 2024 and held under an unlawful combatant designation, which allows prolonged detention without trial. Israel has used this designation for more than 375 medical workers since the war began. Israeli rights groups have described conditions in military prisons as torture camps. The case has drawn international attention due to Abu Safiya's role in keeping the hospital running during a prolonged siege.
Key Perspectives
Prof Amit Tirosh: says continuous food deprivation, beatings and inadequate medical care could cost Abu Safiya his life; the medical records show a 14kg weight loss, untreated injuries and a dangerous drop in haemoglobin that required urgent evaluation but was not addressed
Israeli prison service: says the allegations are part of a broader campaign aimed at discrediting the state of Israel, and that the IPS operates in accordance with the law and under constant judicial oversight
Physicians for Human Rights Israel: says the Israeli authorities' allegations did not justify denying an independent medical examination, a right protected by law
What to Watch
- Whether the Israeli supreme court will hear any further appeal on the medical examination request
- The outcome of ongoing PHRI efforts to gain access to Abu Safiya for a third-party medical assessment
- Any changes in Abu Safiya's medical condition or reports from prison visits
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedProf Amit Tirosh said food deprivation, weight loss, beatings and inadequate medical care could cost Abu Safiya his life.World news | The Guardian: ““Continuous food deprivation and weight loss, repeated beatings and injuries, with inadequate medical care, can definitely cost Dr Abu Safiya his life,” Tirosh said.”
- SupportedTirosh is an Israeli doctor who warned that Abu Safiya’s health was at risk.World news | The Guardian: “Prof Amit Tirosh, an independent Israeli specialist”
- SupportedAbu Safiya was detained at work on 27 December 2024 and had been held for nearly 23 months without charge.World news | The Guardian: “Hussam Abu Safiya was detained at work on 27 December 2024”
- SupportedIsraeli authorities had not brought formal charges against Abu Safiya.World news | The Guardian: “Israeli authorities have yet to bring any formal charges against Abu Safiya”
- SupportedAbu Safiya’s weight fell from 90kg in January 2025 to 76kg in May 2026.World news | The Guardian: “Tirosh said Abu Safiya’s weight had fallen from 90kg (14st 2lb) in January 2025 to 76kg this May.”
- SupportedTirosh identified insufficient investigation of chest pain, delays treating scabies and a haemoglobin drop that warranted further examination.World news | The Guardian: “Tirosh identified insufficient investigation of chest pain, delays in treating scabies and a drop in haemoglobin levels that warranted further examination.”
- SupportedTirosh said the haemoglobin drop between February and July 2026 coincided with reported beatings and could not be explained by detention or starvation alone.World news | The Guardian: ““Haemoglobin dropped between February and July 2026, long after the weight loss, so detention or starvation alone cannot explain it; it coincided with the reported beatings in Rakefet.””
- SupportedMedical records documented bruising around one of Abu Safiya’s eyes, dizziness and rib pain in July; he told his lawyers guards had beaten him.World news | The Guardian: “Medical records documented bruising around one of Abu Safiya’s eyes, dizziness and rib pain in July. He told his lawyers he had been beaten by prison guards”
- SupportedThe supreme court rejected a release petition last month, and a district court rejected a separate petition for an independent medical examination over the weekend.World news | The Guardian: “Last month, Israel’s supreme court rejected a petition to release the doctor. Over the weekend, a district court rejected a separate petition to allow Abu Safiya an independent medical examination”
- SupportedIsraeli authorities alleged Abu Safiya exaggerated medical problems, set up organisations from prison, influenced other prisoners and maintained international contacts.World news | The Guardian: “The district court ruling also revealed allegations made by Israeli authorities that Abu Safiya had exaggerated his medical problems, set up organisations from prison, influenced other prisoners and maintained international contacts.”
- SupportedAbu Safiya was being held indefinitely with thousands of other Palestinian civilians in prisons Israeli rights groups said had become torture camps.World news | The Guardian: “He is being held indefinitely, along with thousands of other Palestinian civilians, in prisons that Israeli rights groups say have become torture camps.”
- SupportedThe Israeli prison service did not immediately respond to a request for comment; its spokesperson said the allegations were part of a campaign to discredit Israel and that the service operated under judicial oversight.World news | The Guardian: “The Israeli prison service did not immediately respond to a request for comment. ... the allegations are “part of a broader campaign aimed at discrediting the state of Israel” and that the IPS “operates in accordance with the law and under constant judicial oversight”.”