WorldDeveloping

Met detective says force's handling of rape case 'like being raped all over again'; calls for Sir Mark Rowley to resign

Det Con Linda Williams, raped by PC David Carrick in 2004, says she was 'horrified and shocked' by Met lawyers' challenge to her PTSD and questions trust in the force

By LineZotpaper
Published
Updated
Read Time3 min
Sources4 outlets
A Metropolitan Police detective who was raped by a fellow officer has told the BBC that Scotland Yard's handling of her civil case made her feel 'like being raped all over again'. Det Con Linda Williams has settled her claim for damages after the Met failed to protect her from serial abuser PC David Carrick, but she says the force's legal team challenged the severity of her post-traumatic stress disorder by arguing she had been raped only once. In an unprecedented move for a serving officer, she is now calling for Commissioner Sir Mark Rowley to resign, saying he has not changed the culture as promised.

Det Con Linda Williams, a 27-year Met veteran, was raped in 2004 by PC David Carrick while on attachment in south London. Carrick was jailed for life in 2023 for sexual offences against her and 11 other women. Williams reported the rape only after Carrick was charged with another woman's rape. Carrick was brought to justice by Hertfordshire Police, not the Met.

In a civil case lasting four years, Williams sought damages from the Met for failing to protect her from Carrick. She said the process left her feeling suicidal. The 'worst thing', she said, was when the Met's legal team questioned the severity of her PTSD diagnosis, arguing that the 'abuse itself was isolated to a single episode' and that for 15 years after the rape her psychological harm was 'not such as to significantly impact her on a day-to-day basis'. Williams was horrified. 'I don't know how many times you have to be raped to have severe PTSD,' she said.

The Met has now paid compensation without admitting liability. In a statement, the force said it 'tried to reduce further distress and re-traumatisation to DC Williams' welfare and has aimed to deal with her claims as quickly and compassionately as possible'. It recognised 'the unique and additional impact on DC Linda Williams, whose exposure to Carrick came as a result of her being a Met officer' and called her continued commitment to public service 'commendable'.

Williams says she still does not trust the Met to handle rape cases. If attacked again, she would not report it to her own force. She believes the culture of misogyny identified in Baroness Casey's 2023 report has not changed enough. She said police had not moved on enough to give victims of domestic violence and sexual offences the support they need.

After Carrick's conviction, Sir Mark publicly apologised to the 12 victims. Williams emailed him saying that as a serving officer she thought he would come forward. He met her and said he was sorry. But now she wants him to resign, arguing he has failed to reform the Met. Her PTSD, she said, is '90% down to the Met Police, 10% to Carrick'.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • The case highlights ongoing failures in policing culture, with a serving officer saying she would not report a rape to her own force.
  • The Met's legal strategy in challenging a victim's PTSD is likely to damage public confidence in how the force handles sexual violence cases.
  • Williams' unprecedented public call for the commissioner to resign puts pressure on Sir Mark Rowley's leadership and his reform agenda.

Background

David Carrick was a Metropolitan Police officer who used his position to coerce and control women, raping and abusing 12 victims over two decades. He was jailed in 2023. The following year, a report by Baroness Casey described the Met as a 'boys' club' that was institutionally misogynistic and had failed women. Sir Mark Rowley became commissioner in 2022, promising to root out corrupt officers and change the culture. Williams' case has become a test of that promise.

Key Perspectives

[Det Con Linda Williams]: She argues the Met's legal team re-traumatised her by minimising her PTSD, and that Commissioner Rowley is personally responsible. She says the culture has not improved enough and calls for his resignation. [Metropolitan Police]: The force says it tried to handle Williams' case compassionately and recognises the impact on her. It compensated her without admitting liability. It has not commented directly on the call for Rowley to resign. [Sir Mark Rowley]: He has previously apologised for the Met's failures, saying Carrick should not have been a police officer. He met Williams after she emailed him. His leadership reform is now under scrutiny.

What to Watch

  • Any response from Sir Mark Rowley to the call for his resignation.
  • Further fallout for the Met's handling of civil cases involving officers' victims.
  • Potential impact on the Met's reform programme and public trust figures.

Sources

Checked

12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 10 supported.

Show each claim
  1. SupportedWilliams said the Met's handling of her case felt “like being raped all over again”.BBC News: “A Metropolitan Police detective, who was raped by a fellow officer, has told the BBC that Scotland Yard's handling of her case was "like being raped all over again".”
  2. SupportedWilliams is calling for Sir Mark Rowley to resign.BBC News: “In an unprecedented move for a serving officer, she is now calling publicly for Commissioner Sir Mark Rowley to resign.”
  3. SupportedWilliams was raped by PC David Carrick in 2004.BBC News: “Carrick raped her while she was on a three-month attachment with him in south London”
  4. SupportedWilliams said she was “horrified and shocked” when Met lawyers challenged the severity of her PTSD.BBC News: “"I was horrified and shocked," she says, adding she was reduced to tears and felt she was being called a liar.”
  5. SupportedWilliams says she does not trust the Met to handle rape cases and would not report an attack to it.BBC News: “She says if a similar attack happened to her tomorrow, she would not report it to the Met, because she has "no faith" that the force would deal with it correctly.”
  6. Partly supportedThe Met failed to protect Williams from Carrick.BBC News: “Linda brought a civil case against the Met seeking damages on the basis the force failed to protect her from him”
  7. SupportedThe Met's legal team argued the abuse was “isolated to a single episode”.BBC News: “The BBC has seen a document from the Met, sent to Linda, showing it stated that a key factor in assessing damages was that the "abuse itself was isolated to a single episode".”
  8. Partly supportedThe Met document said that for 15 years after the rape, Williams's psychological harm was not significantly affecting her day to day.BBC News: “The Met document, sent to Linda, shows it argued that - for at least 15 years after she had been raped - the psychological harm she experienced was "not such as to significantly impact her on a day-to-day basis".”
  9. SupportedWilliams reported Carrick's rape after he was charged with raping another woman.BBC News: “She reported it to the force after seeing media coverage of the news that Carrick had been charged with raping another woman.”
  10. SupportedCarrick was jailed for life in 2023 for sexual offences against Williams and 11 other women.BBC News: “Det Con Linda Williams was attacked in 2004 by PC David Carrick - a serial abuser jailed for life in 2023 for sexual offences against her and 11 other women.”
  11. SupportedHertfordshire Police, not the Met, brought Carrick to justice.BBC News: “Carrick was brought to justice by Hertfordshire Police, which investigated the rape of Linda.”
  12. SupportedWilliams says her PTSD is “90% down to the Met Police, 10% to Carrick”.BBC News: “Her PTSD after the attack is "90% down to the Met Police, 10% to Carrick", she says.”

Correction

An earlier version of this story omitted 'all over' from Williams's headline quotation and described the legal challenge as 'horrifying' in quotation marks. She said she was 'horrified and shocked'. A body quotation about support for victims was also inaccurately shortened and has been replaced with reported speech. The story also mistakenly said Williams was brought to justice by Hertfordshire Police. It was Carrick.

Zotpaper

Written by Rex Doyle on the World desk. Claims checked by Ines Fairley, verification. Read for legal risk by Marcus Hale, legal. Edited by Angus Burke, chief sub.

3 sources10 of 12 claims matched to a sourcefirst published updated once
Meet the newsroomHow we workSubscribe