Phil, a tenant at Castleview House in Runcorn, Cheshire, described the block where he lives as “hell on Earth”, pointing to black mould and rats. But to Britské Reality, a Czech estate agency, the flat Phil rents through his benefits was an exciting business opportunity, advertised as a government-funded income stream with the property in excellent condition. A Czech investor bought it last year for £163,150, more than double the £75,000 cost of similar apartments in the block.
The BBC identified more than 40 companies marketing supported accommodation, housing for people with mental health problems, drug abuse issues or fleeing domestic violence, to investors. About a dozen work with developer Lee Jones, whose company sold Phil’s flat. Providers of “supported exempt accommodation” can charge the taxpayer more than the usual housing benefit cap because of higher running costs, but the BBC has previously reported how some exploit the system by taking the higher payments while failing to provide support.
Marketing materials made misleading promises about quality and support. One Czech advert said Nurture Housing Association, which manages many flats in developments converted by Jones, provides housing for people with mental health issues who receive aftercare under section 117 of the Mental Health Act, meaning they have been sectioned and discharged from hospital with a care plan. Phil said he has never been sectioned, receives no care and has never met anyone from Nurture. “Whoever marketed this property, the way they’ve worded it is total dishonesty,” he said.
The web of companies and cross-border ownership can make it difficult for vulnerable tenants to get help when there are problems with properties. Labour MP Abena Oppong-Asare, chair of the Housing Select Committee, called the findings “alarming” and said the system was “open to abuse”. “The way that the current system works is there’s different levels of involvement by different organisations and companies and no-one is directly accountable,” she said.
In Bradford, residents at City Exchange and Colonnade House, former office blocks converted by Jones into housing where Nurture manages many flats, showed cockroach infestations, faulty fire alarms, broken lifts, leaks and black mould. Nurture said it was responsible only for the individual homes it manages, not communal areas. The freeholder for Castleview House and City Exchange blamed “defects” by Jones and said it was taking legal action. Jones told the BBC his companies provide “good quality accommodation” and denied a conflict of interest with Nurture’s Chris Smith, but did not answer questions about his role in marketing.
Mo, a tenant in a supported flat in Cricklewood, north London, said his ceiling collapsed after a leak went unrepaired for more than a year. Mo said his provider, Windrush Alliance, receives nearly £2,000 a month from Barnet Council for the flat. Windrush said it was working with the building owner. The Regulator of Social Housing had criticised Windrush for failing to meet standards; Windrush said its “priority is residents, not investors”.
The Supported Housing Act, passed three years ago to introduce a licensing regime and give councils powers to shut down failing providers, has not yet been implemented. “It’s taken too long,” said Jasmine Basran, head of policy at housing charity Crisis. “In the meantime, this is an area where we’ve seen the worst kind of exploitation.”