The review, conducted by Chris Hawker of C3 Consulting, said the problems exposed by the storm were not isolated shortcomings but reflected wider systemic issues around communication, governance, staffing and emergency preparedness. Future resilience would depend on integrated systems, clearer decision-making, stronger resourcing, greater transparency, and better organisational preparedness.
The storm, which brought gusts of up to 180km/h on 23 October, toppled trees, damaged properties and left thousands without power, some for more than two weeks. Within a day, 86 cell towers were offline, and by 25 October, 40 farms could not milk. Four days later, 180 farms were still without power.
The review found that the need for generators was identified early but allocation was constrained by incomplete outage information, limited supply, technical compatibility, transport, approval and tracking requirements. The New Zealand Defence Force flew portable generators to the region on two flights, but emergency management staff declined a third flight after the generator management team said it had sufficient resources and the proposed flight would have taken about a day and cost up to $300,000.
Particular difficulty arose over whether businesses should receive generators. The review found that emergency management generally should not compensate for inadequate business continuity planning but supplying generators could be justified where a business provided critical services such as food, fuel or healthcare, or where animal welfare was involved. "This distinction matters because scarce emergency resources must be directed first to life safety, essential services, isolated communities, and critical community needs, while also encouraging businesses that provide important local services to invest in their own resilience before the next emergency," the review said.
The review found that people in governance roles during the emergency were not getting the right information at the right time or in the right format. Mayors were outside the core communication circle, and governance figures sometimes had to phone people to get updates; they did not have direct access to situation reports, dashboards or incident management information. Councillors were also gathering useful local intelligence from communities, but that information was not consistently feeding into decision-making.
Hawker said the issues identified were not specific to the October 2025 storm, were well understood, and that Emergency Management Southland now had an experienced group manager who, if supported, should be able to make necessary changes.
The review made six recommendations, including increasing the pool of trained, competent staff available to work in the Emergency Coordination Centre, updating plans and policies to reflect the Emergency Management Act 2026, and introducing an operational system providing real-time information, coordination and record-keeping that approved councils and agencies could access.