Sunday 11 October 2026
Night EditionRSS
ZOTPAPER

News without the noise

ZOTPAPER
Business

NYC EMS workers warn newcomers away as pay parity fight tests Mayor Mamdani

Long-serving emergency workers say wages have not kept pace, leaving them among the city's lowest-paid first responders

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time2 min
After 31 years in New York City's emergency medical services, Oren Barzilay retired at a salary of $59,000 and now warns young New Yorkers away from the job: "Don't come here. You are only going to hurt yourself." His warning comes as the city's more than 4,500 EMS workers remain locked in a years-long fight over wages and pay parity that has become an early test of Mayor Mamdani's young administration.

For Oren Barzilay, the recently retired president of FDNY EMS Local 2507, the change of heart is not about the work or the value of service, but what he calls the city's failure to pay people who risk their lives to save others. "After 31 years, I am stuck at $59,000," he said.

More than 4,500 EMS workers respond to over 1.9 million medical and fire emergencies each year across the five boroughs, making life-or-death decisions for a city of more than 8.58 million people. Yet an FDNY EMT starts at $39,386 a year, barely above New York City's minimum wage, and after five years can earn roughly $59,534.

Natasha Villaruel, a 36-year-old paramedic who was born in Jamaica and moved to Brooklyn at four, described the pressure of the job. "Within 20 seconds, you have to make a life decision," she said, explaining how she assesses a patient's breathing, skin colour and ability to speak from the doorway.

The wage dispute has become an early test of a contradiction facing Mayor Mamdani. As a candidate he built his political identity around organized labour, affordability and demands that employers pay workers more. As mayor he sits on the other side of the bargaining table, responsible for a vast municipal workforce and a finite city budget. His administration has already filed a lawsuit to stop $10,000 payments to public-school paraprofessionals, and EMS workers' campaign for higher wages and pay parity is forcing the tension into the open.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • EMS workers handle roughly 1.9 million emergency calls a year; if experienced staff follow their own veteran's advice and leave, the city's emergency response capacity could suffer.
  • The dispute tests whether Mayor Mamdani's campaign commitments to organized labour survive his new responsibility for a finite municipal budget.
  • The outcome will signal how the administration handles the rest of the city's unionised workforce, including the separate fight over paraprofessional bonuses.

Background

New York's EMS workers have argued for years that their pay does not match the risks and demands of the job, which involves making life-or-death decisions under extreme time pressure. Their campaign for parity with firefighters predates the current administration and reflects a broader pattern across the United States, where emergency medical workers in many cities have seen pay and funding lag behind police and fire services. For many EMS staff the work is a passionate calling, but veteran workers say the financial reality is driving newcomers away.

Key Perspectives

EMS workers and Local 2507: The union argues the work is a calling that is not reflected in pay. Barzilay's advice to newcomers and his own 31-year salary illustrate the retention problem facing the service.

The Mamdani administration: As mayor, Mamdani must balance the city budget while bargaining with a large municipal workforce. His administration's lawsuit to block $10,000 paraprofessional bonuses shows the fiscal pressure it is already under, even though his political identity rests on supporting organized labour.

Critics and skeptics: The concern is twofold: conceding pay parity across the municipal workforce would add significant budget pressure, while refusing it risks accelerating departures of experienced EMS staff and slowing response times in a system that already answers nearly two million calls a year.

What to Watch

  • The administration's lawsuit over paraprofessional bonuses, which will signal its broader willingness to resist or grant union pay demands.
  • Progress in the EMS contract negotiations, and whether the union escalates its campaign if pay parity is not on the table.
  • Staffing and retention data, which will show whether the workforce exodus continues regardless of how the dispute is resolved.

Sources

Zotpaper

Written by software from the reporting listed above, scored by an automated standards desk, and published without a person reading it first. If something here is wrong, tell the editor and it will be put right.

How we workSubscribe