The National Bank of Poland (NBP) has frozen outgoing transfers from the bank accounts of the Constitutional Tribunal (TK), citing conflicting claims over who has the authority to manage the court following a disputed takeover last month by judges backed by the government.
The dispute began when eight judges elected to the TK this year by the government's parliamentary majority took control of the court, suspending Chief Justice Bogdan Święczkowski and his deputy Bartłomiej Sochański and launching disciplinary proceedings against them. Święczkowski denounced the move as an illegal “coup d'état” and has been backed by the court's six other judges appointed under the former government.
Święczkowski submitted a statement to the NBP identifying himself as the sole person authorised to manage the accounts, but the NBP later said it had received documents indicating, in principle, other authorised persons. The NBP said it had received “a set of documents, which mutually cancel each other out”, and suspended all payment orders regardless of who initiates them. “The National Bank of Poland has no authority to decide who is legally entitled to control the Constitutional Tribunal,” it said in a statement.
The freeze drew criticism from the government. Finance Minister Andrzej Domański said the NBP “should safeguard its independence, including its political independence”, and said the government would “explore all available options” to secure funding. Justice Minister Waldemar Żurek condemned the bank's “invocation of a non-existent document [the disputed Supreme Court ruling] to block funding for a constitutional body is…an attempt to protect an entrenched system”.
According to news website Onet, Święczkowski expressed satisfaction that the NBP had denied access to the “usurpers” but argued he should be given control over the accounts as the legitimate chief justice.
The dispute is the latest episode in a decade-long crisis around the Constitutional Tribunal. The current government led by Prime Minister Donald Tusk has refused to recognise the court because three of its judges were unlawfully appointed under the former Law and Justice (PiS) government. While the ruling coalition began filling vacancies this year, President Karol Nawrocki has refused to swear in most of the new judges.
A ruling from the Supreme Court revoking Święczkowski's suspension has been issued but its validity is disputed. Judge Anna Korwin-Piotrowska, who claims leadership of the TK, said only the tribunal itself can decide the issue. Disciplinary hearings for Święczkowski and Sochański are due to begin later this week.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The freeze could paralyse Poland's constitutional court, deepening a legal dualism where judicial authority depends on political allegiance.
- The standoff between the government and the central bank may escalate tensions over judicial reform.
- The dispute undermines the rule of law and may affect Poland's standing in the EU.
Background
Poland's Constitutional Tribunal has been at the centre of a political crisis since the former PiS government altered the appointment process, leading to accusations that it brought the court under political control. The current Tusk-led coalition refuses to recognise the court because three judges were unlawfully appointed under PiS. The government began filling vacancies this year, but President Nawrocki has refused to swear in most of the new judges, leading to the current standoff. The NBP governor, Adam Glapiński, was appointed under PiS and is a longtime associate of PiS leader Jarosław Kaczyński.
Key Perspectives
- Chief Justice Bogdan Święczkowski: Denounced the takeover as an illegal “coup d'état” and argued he should be given control over the accounts as the legitimate chief justice. He expressed satisfaction that the NBP denied access to the “usurpers”.
- Finance Minister Andrzej Domański: Criticised the NBP's decision, saying it should safeguard its political independence. The government will explore all options to secure funding for the court.
- Justice Minister Waldemar Żurek: Condemned the NBP's move, calling its invocation of a non-existent document an attempt to protect an entrenched system.
- Judge Anna Korwin-Piotrowska (claiming leadership of the TK): Said only the tribunal itself can decide on the issue.
What to Watch
- Disciplinary hearings for Święczkowski and Sochański are due to begin this week.
- Potential legal action by the government to unfreeze the accounts.
- Any further ruling from the Supreme Court or the European courts on the dispute.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedPoland’s central bank froze outgoing transfers from the Constitutional Tribunal’s accounts amid a dispute over who could manage the court.Notes from Poland: “Poland’s central bank has frozen outgoing transfers from the bank accounts of the Constitutional Tribunal (TK), citing conflicting claims over who has the authority to manage the court”
- SupportedThe NBP cited conflicting claims over who was authorised to manage the Constitutional Tribunal’s accounts.Notes from Poland: “citing “a set of documents, which mutually cancel each other out”. “This means that payment orders are not executed, regardless of who initiates them,” the NBP said in a statement.”
- SupportedFinance Minister Andrzej Domański said the NBP should safeguard its independence, including political independence.Notes from Poland: ““The National Bank of Poland should safeguard its independence, including its political independence,” Domański said.”
- SupportedThe government said it would explore all available options to secure funding for the Tribunal.Notes from Poland: “He added that the government would “explore all available options” to secure funding for the TK and ensure that it can continue functioning.”
- SupportedEight judges elected to the Tribunal this year by the government’s parliamentary majority took control of it last month.Notes from Poland: “Last month, eight judges elected to the TK this year by the government’s parliamentary majority – but five of whom the opposition-aligned president, Karol Nawrocki, has refused to swear in – took control of the court.”
- SupportedThe eight judges suspended Chief Justice Bogdan Święczkowski and his deputy Bartłomiej Sochański and launched disciplinary proceedings against them.Notes from Poland: “They declared that the chief justice, Bogdan Święczkowski, and his deputy, Bartłomiej Sochański, both of whom were appointed to the TK under the former government, had been suspended for failing to fulfil their duties and launched disciplinary proceedings against them.”
- SupportedŚwięczkowski called the move an illegal “coup d'état”.Notes from Poland: “Święczkowski denounced the move as an illegal “coup d’état”.”
- SupportedŚwięczkowski told the NBP he was the sole person authorised to manage the Tribunal’s accounts; the NBP later said it had received documents indicating other authorised persons.Notes from Poland: “Święczkowski submitted a statement to the NBP identifying himself as the sole person authorised to manage the TK’s accounts. Later that week [...] the NBP said it had also received documents “indicating, in principle, other persons authorised to dispose of the funds held in the Constitutional Tribunal’s bank accounts”.”
- SupportedThe NBP said it had no authority to decide who was legally entitled to control the Tribunal.Notes from Poland: ““The National Bank of Poland has no authority to decide who is legally entitled to control the Constitutional Tribunal.””
- SupportedJustice Minister Waldemar Żurek condemned the NBP’s invocation of a disputed document to block funding for a constitutional body.Notes from Poland: “Justice minister Waldemar Żurek also condemned the NBP’s move, saying its “invocation of a non-existent document [the disputed Supreme Court ruling] to block funding for a constitutional body is…an attempt to protect an entrenched system”.”
- SupportedOnet reported that Święczkowski was pleased the NBP had denied access to the “usurpers” but said he should control the accounts as the legitimate chief justice.Notes from Poland: “Święczkowski expressed satisfaction that the NBP had denied access to the “usurpers” trying to take over the court but argued that he, as the legitimate chief justice, should be given control over the accounts, reports news website Onet.”
- SupportedThe Supreme Court issued a ruling revoking Święczkowski’s suspension, but the ruling’s validity is disputed.Notes from Poland: “the Supreme Court, which on 10 November issued a ruling revoking the order to suspend Święczkowski and Sochański. However, the validity of that ruling is disputed.”