RBA faces dilemma as oil prices keep inflation high

Reserve Bank torn between controlling inflation and protecting the economy as war in the Middle East pushes up commodity costs

By LineZotpaper
Published
Updated
Read Time3 min
Sources4 outlets
The Reserve Bank of Australia is wrestling with a difficult choice as oil prices show no sign of falling and inflation remains above target. With the war in the Middle East broadening, the bank’s internal forecasts assume oil $20 a barrel lower than current levels, and raising interest rates further, which could push up unemployment, is again on the table.

The Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) is facing what it considers a “worst nightmare”: persistent inflation driven by surging oil prices, with the cash rate already at a 15-year high of 4.6 per cent.

Senior sources within the bank, according to an article by Shane Wright, have expressed growing concern that oil prices—which last week closed at $US106 a barrel—are not falling as the war in the Middle East expands to Saudi Arabia and the Gulf of Aden. The RBA’s own economic forecasts were based on oil prices being as much as $20 lower.

Australian inflation rose 0.4 per cent in August, and would have fallen but for the increase in petrol prices. Diesel prices are particularly troubling for central banks, as they affect transport, manufacturing and food costs. LNG prices have more than doubled since before the war, while food commodities have soared: wheat up 37 per cent, soybeans 24 per cent, sugar 42 per cent and cocoa more than doubled.

The bank is also grappling with a weaker labour market. Unemployment rose to a five-year high of 4.7 per cent in September, lowering the market expectation of a rate rise at the November meeting from one in three to one in five. But the RBA is still concerned that inflation pressures, exacerbated by the war and the global AI data-centre build-out, will not abate.

In a paper released from a conference on monetary policy trade-offs, RBA Governor Michele Bullock and senior researcher Anthony Brassil highlighted the difficulty of a supply shock when the bank has a dual mandate of low inflation and full employment. “If prices are rising faster than nominal incomes, households experience a direct loss of purchasing power. At the same time, weaker activity may mean that unemployment and underemployment are already increasing,” they wrote. “The costs on both sides of the mandate are then visible together, and monetary policy cannot eliminate the real economic loss caused by the shock. It can only influence how that loss is distributed over time.”

Higher rates have put borrowers under pressure, although most have maintained large offset balances. A record $21 billion in interest was paid on home loans in the June quarter. Still, high inflation hits low-income earners hardest, especially those without mortgages who have faced steep rent increases over the past three years.

Globally, central banks have lifted rates over the past three months as inflation climbs. AMP chief economist Shane Oliver said the war against Iran and the Russian-Ukraine conflict were hurting the global economy through oil prices. “Disruptions in the Strait of Hormuz, coupled with recent Ukrainian strikes on Russian refineries, have driven up the cost of refining crude into end products,” he said.

The International Monetary Fund’s chief economist, Silvana Tenreyro, noted that the global economy had shown resilience through re-routing supplies and a shift to renewables, but she warned that the capacity to mitigate the drop in Middle Eastern oil production is nearly exhausted. A squeeze on global supplies through 2027 is increasingly expected.

The RBA will hold two critical meetings before Christmas, where it will have to decide whether to raise rates again or hold steady, weighing the risks of inflation versus unemployment.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • The RBA's decision directly affects Australian mortgage holders, renters and the broader economy.
  • Elevated inflation erodes purchasing power and disproportionately hurts low-income households.
  • A rate hike risks higher unemployment, while inaction could see inflation entrenched.

Background

The RBA has been raising interest rates since 2022, reaching a 15-year high of 4.6 per cent. Inflation has remained above the 2–3 per cent target for three of the past four years. The current inflationary wave is being driven by the war in the Middle East, which has pushed up oil and commodity prices, and is compounded by the global AI-induced data-centre boom.

Key Perspectives

RBA: Must balance its dual mandate of low inflation and full employment. A further rate hike would help bring down inflation but risks weakening the labour market. Households: Borrowers are under strain despite high offset balances. Renters and low-income earners are hardest hit by the cost-of-living crisis. Global economic observers: Central banks worldwide face similar trade-offs. Mitigation measures are reaching their limits, and a global supply squeeze is expected by 2027.

What to Watch

  • The November meeting of the RBA board and any rate decision.
  • Oil price movements in the Middle East, particularly through the Strait of Hormuz.
  • Australian inflation figures and employment data in the next months.

Sources

Checked

12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 9 supported.

Show each claim
  1. SupportedOil prices are keeping the inflation threat elevated for the RBA.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “RBA’s worst nightmare as oil pushes up inflation threat.”
  2. SupportedThe RBA faces a choice between controlling inflation and supporting the economy.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “They said that a supply shock coupled with the bank’s dual mandate – low inflation and full employment – meant it faced a difficult choice between supporting the economy or taking sterner action to control prices.”
  3. SupportedOil finished last week at $US106 a barrel and showed no sign of falling as the war broadened to Saudi Arabia and the Gulf of Aden.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “oil prices – which finished last week at $US106 a barrel – are showing no sign of falling as the war in the Middle East broadens to Saudi Arabia and the Gulf of Aden.”
  4. Partly supportedThe RBA’s forecasts assumed oil prices as much as $20 a barrel below current levels.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “the RBA’s own economic forecasts – due to be updated next month – were based on oil prices being as much as $US20 a barrel lower.”
  5. SupportedFurther interest-rate rises remain possible even if they result in higher unemployment.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “inflation will remain elevated and force it to push up interest rates higher, even if it means more people may end up unemployed as the Australian economy slows.”
  6. Partly supportedThe RBA considers persistent oil-driven inflation its “worst nightmare”.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “RBA’s worst nightmare as oil pushes up inflation threat.”
  7. SupportedBullock and Brassil said households lose purchasing power when prices outpace nominal incomes while weaker activity may already be increasing unemployment and underemployment.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: ““If prices are rising faster than nominal incomes, households experience a direct loss of purchasing power. At the same time, weaker activity may mean that unemployment and underemployment are already increasing,” they said.”
  8. SupportedBullock and Brassil said monetary policy cannot eliminate a supply shock’s economic loss and can only influence its distribution over time.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: ““The costs on both sides of the mandate are then visible together, and monetary policy cannot eliminate the real economic loss caused by the shock. It can only influence how that loss is distributed over time.””
  9. SupportedShane Oliver said disruptions in the Strait of Hormuz and Ukrainian strikes on Russian refineries had raised refining costs.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: ““Disruptions in the Strait of Hormuz, coupled with recent Ukrainian strikes on Russian refineries, have driven up the cost of refining crude into end products,” he said.”
  10. SupportedAustralian inflation rose 0.4 per cent in August and would have fallen without higher petrol prices.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Australian inflation, which rose by 0.4 per cent in August, would have fallen but for the increase in petrol prices that month.”
  11. SupportedUnemployment reached a five-year high of 4.7 per cent in September.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “weaker-than-expected job figures last week , which showed unemployment climbing to a five-year high of 4.7 per cent in September”
  12. Partly supportedIMF chief economist Silvana Tenreyro warned that the ability to offset lost Middle Eastern oil production was nearly exhausted.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “But there are concerns the ability to mitigate the drop in oil production out of the Middle East has almost run its course.”

Zotpaper

Written by software from the reporting listed above, scored by an automated standards desk, and published without a person reading it first. If something here is wrong, tell the editor and it will be put right.

How we workSubscribe