The Rome District Attorney's Office has agreed to reopen the investigation into the murder of Pier Paolo Pasolini, 51 years after the writer and filmmaker was killed. Lawyer Stefano Maccioni has produced previously unknown testimony that Italian media say comes from a retired member of the security forces.
Maccioni, who has investigated the crime for years and published books on it, filed the complaint a year ago. He previously persuaded prosecutors to reopen the case in 2010 and 2023, but it was closed again on both occasions without conclusive findings.
Pasolini was killed in the early hours of November 2, 1975, in a vacant lot in Ostia, on the outskirts of Rome. The official account has been widely doubted: six months after the murder, 17-year-old Pino Pelosi was sentenced to nine years and seven months in prison, although the judge said the case file “overwhelmingly shows evidence that Pelosi was not alone that night.” Pelosi died in 2017 at 59 and took the secret to the grave.
In his new bid, Maccioni is acting for the Lazio Region Journalists' Association, film director David Grieco, and writer Giovanni Giovannetti. He points to new information from recordings made by the public broadcaster RAI at the time and says a thorough review "leads to a single conclusion: it is not certain that Pelosi was alone on the evening of the murder, so it is essential to establish who was with him that evening."
Maccioni has long focused on what Pasolini was doing in the months before his death: the film Salò, released posthumously, and the unfinished book Petróleo, which dealt with political and mafia plots involving the Italian oil giant ENI and the 1962 plane crash that killed its president, Enrico Mattei. One hypothesis is that Pelosi was used as bait to lure Pasolini to the Idroscalo di Ostia, a remote spot he sometimes visited with casual partners, to set up an ambush. Another lead involves the theft of reels at the Cinecittà Studios, with members of the Banda della Magliana, a Roman criminal group linked at the time to the intelligence services’ dirtiest operations, said to have taken part in the theft. Days after the killing, the prominent reporter Oriana Fallaci published an article with testimony pointing to the presence of other people.
The first investigation prompted by Maccioni found DNA from three unidentified individuals on Pasolini's clothes; comparisons with 30 people who had appeared in the inquiries were all negative. "As has been clear for almost 18 years, the judicial truth that attributed sole responsibility to Pelosi has been swept away in recent years by the scientific evidence we requested," Maccioni said. "We trust that the Public Prosecutor's Office in Rome will finally be able to provide the answers we have been seeking for far too many years. At the same time, we urge all those who have chosen to remain silent about what they know until now, to come forward and speak."
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The reopening revives the only formal investigation into one of Italy's most disputed murders, with widespread public doubt about the official account that Pelosi acted alone.
- The case is tied to unresolved questions from Italy's Years of Lead, including political plots, neo-fascist violence, and intelligence-linked criminal groups.
- With Pelosi dead, the appeal for witnesses to come forward may be the last chance to establish who else was present that night.
Background
Pasolini was an Italian writer and filmmaker whose murder in Ostia in 1975 was never fully resolved in the public mind. The 17-year-old Pino Pelosi confessed and was convicted, but the trial judge said the file showed Pelosi was not alone. Over the decades, theories have linked the killing to neo-fascist groups, intelligence services, and the Banda della Magliana, amid the political violence of the 1970s. Maccioni's previous attempts to reopen the case, in 2010 and 2023, ended without conclusive findings.
Key Perspectives
- Stefano Maccioni: says the judicial truth that attributed sole responsibility to Pelosi has been "swept away" by scientific evidence, and that it is not certain Pelosi acted alone.
- Pino Pelosi: gave contradictory accounts after prison, at times saying three or four people carried out the killing and later threatened him into silence.
- Oriana Fallaci: wrote an article days after the crime citing testimony pointing to the presence of other people at the scene.
What to Watch
- Whether the retired security official's previously unknown testimony is examined publicly as part of the reopened inquiry.
- Whether the Rome prosecutor's office reaches conclusive findings this time, unlike the reopenings of 2010 and 2023.
- Whether anyone responds to Maccioni's appeal and comes forward with information about the night of the murder.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedThe case was reopened 51 years after Pasolini’s death.El País English: “the Rome District Attorney’s Office has agreed to reopen the case.”
- SupportedQuestions persist over whether Pelosi acted alone.El País English: “The very verdict that convicted the 17-year-old who confessed to the murder, Pino Pelosi, already cast doubt on whether he acted alone”
- SupportedThe Rome District Attorney’s Office agreed to reopen the case.El País English: “the Rome District Attorney’s Office has agreed to reopen the case.”
- SupportedMaccioni produced previously unknown testimony in his latest effort to reopen the case.El País English: “This time Maccioni has produced previously unknown testimony”
- SupportedItalian media say the testimony comes from a retired member of the security forces.El País English: “which Italian media say comes from a retired member of the security forces”
- SupportedThe judge said the case file “overwhelmingly shows evidence that Pelosi was not alone that night.”El País English: ““The court considers that the case file overwhelmingly shows evidence that Pelosi was not alone that night.””
- SupportedSix months after the murder, 17-year-old Pelosi was sentenced to nine years and seven months in prison.El País English: “six months after the crime Pelosi was sentenced to nine years and seven months in prison”
- SupportedMaccioni said a thorough review leads to the conclusion that it is not certain Pelosi was alone and that it is essential to establish who was with him.El País English: ““leads to a single conclusion: it is not certain that Pelosi was alone on the evening of the murder, so it is essential to establish who was with him that evening.””
- SupportedMaccioni said the judicial truth assigning sole responsibility to Pelosi had been swept away by scientific evidence his side requested.El País English: ““As has been clear for almost 18 years, the judicial truth that attributed sole responsibility to Pelosi has been swept away in recent years by the scientific evidence we requested,” Maccioni explained.”
- SupportedMaccioni said he trusted Rome’s Public Prosecutor’s Office to provide the answers sought for many years.El País English: ““We trust that the Public Prosecutor’s Office in Rome will finally be able to provide the answers we have been seeking for far too many years,” the lawyer said.”
- SupportedMaccioni urged people who had remained silent about what they knew to come forward and speak.El País English: ““At the same time, we urge all those who have chosen to remain silent about what they know until now, to come forward and speak.””
- SupportedThe first investigation prompted by Maccioni found DNA from three unidentified individuals on Pasolini’s clothes.El País English: “The first investigation prompted by Maccioni relied on DNA from three individuals found on Pasolini’s clothes, which could not be identified.”