Transport for Wales (TfW) chief executive James Price now expects every one of the operator's more than £200m tram-trains to be in full passenger service by the end of 2027, five years later than originally promised, and said he "definitely" expects four trains an hour on three south Wales valleys routes by then. The Welsh government said TfW "remains on target to complete the full rollout by the end of next year."
The update comes as BBC data showed less than half of the 36-strong fleet, which TfW calls the "final piece" of its £2bn South Wales Metro project, has passed the statutory testing required by the rail regulator. Sixteen of the three-carriage Class 398 Citylink units have passed testing so far, with 20 yet to complete it. The trains, ordered from Swiss manufacturer Stadler in 2018, were initially promised to be fully up and running by 2022, and the first arrived in Wales in March 2023.
Six tram-trains, worth about £8m each and able to run on urban streets and rail, are currently in passenger testing across the valleys network. They have been temporarily removed from service on occasions for what TfW described as "teething issues" and "early reliability challenges" caused by "software" problems.
“It's definitely frustrating,” said Price. “Everyone would want something to work first time, wouldn't they? It's frustrating but not unexpected.” He said the biggest issue is software, because the whole fleet is controlled by one large software package, and he wants trains that work “100% well, 100% of the time” before putting them into full service. TfW has been achieving 95% on-time reliability across the valleys network, he said, describing it as the high standard TfW wants to achieve before bringing trains into passenger service in large numbers.
Price cited the need to train "quite a few hundred crew" and signalling work at Queen Street station in Cardiff as reasons for the slow pace. "I do fully expect to see four trains an hour by the end of next year definitely. If we can do it earlier, we certainly will do that," he said. Passengers were initially told the doubling of services from two to four trains an hour would happen by 2022.
Stadler said it was “working closely” with TfW to address “minor issues” in what it described as “one of the UK's most advanced battery tram-trains”, with software updates part of the normal fleet introduction process. Rail engineer and broadcaster Gareth Dennis said the vehicles may be too complicated: “It's a pretty ambitious project,” he said, fearing the tram-trains are “being delivered as part of cutting some corners” such as not electrifying the entire route with overhead wires. TfW said the technology already works on the larger class 756 trains now serving the valleys. The project has also won an industry award.
Reform's transport spokesperson Jason O'Connell questioned why most of the tram-trains were "just sitting in a depot gathering dust". "Taxpayers deserve to know what has gone wrong, how delays have turned into years and the costs are spiralling out of control," he said. The Welsh government said TfW had already delivered "transformative improvements on the valleys network" and new trains would eventually "unlock turn-up-and-go" services across the valleys and Cardiff.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- Commuters on the Cardiff-Aberdare, Merthyr Tydfil and Treherbert lines have been waiting since 2022 for a promised doubling of services to four trains an hour; the target is now the end of 2027.
- More than £200m of taxpayer money is tied up in a fleet that is largely not carrying passengers, with 20 of 36 units yet to complete statutory testing.
- TfW says the full rollout is the "final piece" of the £2bn South Wales Metro and would unlock turn-up-and-go services across the valleys.
Background
The South Wales Metro is Wales' single-biggest infrastructure project since devolution in 1999, transforming an old Victorian railway that once carried coal into a turn-up-and-go rapid transit network. The Class 398 tram-trains, ordered from Stadler in 2018, run on batteries over the third of the network that lacks overhead wires, a design TfW says saved about £400m and years of time. The first unit arrived at TfW's depot near Cardiff in March 2023, and the project has repeatedly missed self-imposed targets.
Key Perspectives
- James Price, TfW chief executive: says the delay is frustrating but not unexpected, the biggest issue is a software problem across the fleet, and he "definitely" expects four trains an hour by the end of next year.
- Gareth Dennis, rail engineer and broadcaster: says the tram-trains are an ambitious project trying to do too much in one vehicle, and fears corners are being cut such as not completing overhead wire electrification.
- Jason O'Connell, Reform transport spokesperson: says taxpayers deserve to know what has gone wrong and how costs are spiralling out of control.
- The Welsh government: says TfW has delivered transformative improvements and remains on target to complete the full rollout by the end of next year.
What to Watch
- Whether the 20 remaining tram-trains pass statutory testing; BBC figures from a Freedom of Information request show such tests can take between six weeks and two years.
- The end-of-2027 pledge to run four trains an hour between Cardiff and Aberdare, Merthyr Tydfil and Treherbert.
- Signalling work at Queen Street station in Cardiff and crew training, which Price cites as the reasons for the slow pace.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedTfW expects all its tram-trains to be in full service by the end of 2027.BBC Wales: “Transport for Wales' (TfW) boss has said he expects all of the tram-trains will be in full service by the end of 2027.”
- SupportedJames Price expects four trains an hour by the end of 2027.BBC Wales: “"I do fully expect to see four trains an hour by the end of next year definitely."”
- SupportedThe end-of-2027 target is five years later than the original 2022 promise.BBC Wales: “They were initially promised to be fully up and running by 2022”
- SupportedThe Welsh government said TfW remained on target to complete the full rollout by the end of 2027.BBC Wales: “"Whilst some issues have delayed the introduction of the new tram trains TfW remains on target to complete the full rollout by the end of next year," it added.”
- SupportedThe fleet cost more than £200m.BBC Wales: “A new fleet of publicly funded trains that cost more than £200m”
- SupportedSixteen of the 36 tram-trains have passed statutory testing, with 20 yet to complete it.BBC Wales: “Sixteen of TfW's 36 tram-train fleet have passed testing to ensure the three-carriage units are safe to run on the UK rail network - with 20 yet to complete the scrutiny required by the rail regulator.”
- SupportedSix tram-trains are currently in passenger testing across the valleys network.BBC Wales: “Six tram-trains, worth about £8m each which can run both on urban streets and rail, are currently in passenger testing across the valleys network.”
- SupportedPrice said, “It's definitely frustrating,” and “Everyone would want something to work first time, wouldn't they? It's frustrating but not unexpected.”BBC Wales: “"It's definitely frustrating," said Price. "Everyone would want something to work first time, wouldn't they? It's frustrating but not unexpected."”
- SupportedPrice identified software as the biggest issue and said the fleet is controlled by one large software package.BBC Wales: “"I don't accept there is a problem with the tram-trains but the biggest issue is a software issue. That's because the whole fleet is controlled by one big software package”
- SupportedPrice said TfW had been achieving 95% on-time reliability on the valleys network and called it the standard sought before introducing trains in large numbers.BBC Wales: “"We've been achieving 95% on-time reliability on the valleys network and that's the high standard we want to achieve before bringing something into passenger service in large numbers."”
- SupportedPrice cited training a few hundred crew and signalling work at Cardiff Queen Street as reasons for the relatively slow rollout.BBC Wales: “"The reason for, I guess, the relatively slow pace is that we need to train quite a few hundred crew then do signalling work at Queen Street station in Cardiff," said Price.”
- SupportedGareth Dennis feared the tram-trains were being delivered while cutting corners, including not completing overhead-wire electrification.BBC Wales: “But Dennis fears the tram-trains are "being delivered as part of cutting some corners" like not doing complete overhead wire electrification”