Records dating back to 1921 show more bee species are declining than increasing in all parts of Europe except the Alpine region. The richness of bee and hover fly species suffered a persistent drop in the Atlantic and Continental regions, though trends in other regions were mixed or even positive.
Carlos Martínez-Núñez, an ecologist at the Spanish National Research Council and lead author of the study, said the findings showed that biodiversity loss could remain hidden behind apparently stable species numbers, “giving us a crucial opportunity to act before further declines occur”. He added: “The fact that some species are increasing today does not mean they will remain winners as climate change and habitat loss intensify.”
The study found that 91% of the species logged over the last century were also recorded at least once between 2001 and 2020. While this suggests as many as 9% of species could have been wiped out in Europe, many of the species not recently spotted occur only rarely in the historical record, and the researchers said they “do not expect widespread extinctions to have occurred yet”. However, the species’ occupancy – the probability of being found at a given site – had mostly fallen.
Nearly 90% of wild flowering plants and more than three-quarters of major food crop types depend in part on animal pollination. The UN’s Food and Agriculture Organization has warned that the decline of pollinators threatens wildlife and weakens ecosystems’ ability to withstand climate change and environmental stress.
Ainhoa Magrach, an environmental researcher at the Basque Centre for Climate Change (BC3) who was not involved in the study, said the work “confirms what has long been suspected: many pollinator species are losing populations, and the decline is not affecting all of them equally”. She noted that until now most evidence came from a few north-western European countries, but this study shows the pattern extends across the continent, with regional differences.
The Cop17 summit is expected to focus on assessing progress toward this decade’s targets, which include protecting 30% of land and sea, reforming $500bn of environmentally damaging subsidies and restoring 30% of the planet’s degraded ecosystems. Governments have not met a single UN target on nature since the biodiversity convention was created in Rio in 1992.
