Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton on Friday dropped two lawsuits against out-of-state doctors for mailing abortion pills into Texas, part of a wave of withdrawals as he prepares to leave office in January. Attorney General-elect Nathan Johnson has vowed not to sue out-of-state doctors who mail abortion pills to Texas.
The two suits, filed in January and February, targeted Dr. Remy Coeytaux and Dr. Rebecca Gomperts in California and nurse practitioner Debra Lynch in Delaware. The suit against Coeytaux and Gomperts was brought under House Bill 7, a law opponents describe as a “bounty hunter law” that allows private citizens to sue anyone who distributes or mails abortion medication to or from Texas. Paxton’s efforts had been complicated by other states’ “shield laws” that protect physicians who send the medications.
Abortion advocates celebrated the withdrawal. Nancy Northup, president and CEO of the Center for Reproductive Rights, said the incoming attorney general agrees with most Americans that doctors should not be treated like criminals. These cases were baseless from the start and designed to intimidate doctors nationwide, Northup said.
Johnson, speaking less than a day after winning his election, told The Texas Tribune he would “cease using Texas abortion laws as an instrument of persecution and intimidation” and described challenges to other states’ shield laws as “judicially absurd.”
One of the California doctors, Dr. Remy Coeytaux, still faces a separate private lawsuit from a Galveston County man who accused him of providing abortion pills to his girlfriend at the direction of her ex-husband. That suit also relies on the same Texas law.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The withdrawal signals a shift in enforcement under the incoming attorney general, reducing legal threats against out-of-state providers who mail abortion pills to Texas.
- Private lawsuits under HB7 remain possible, leaving some providers at risk even without state action.
- The move highlights the tension between Texas’s restrictive abortion laws and other states’ shield laws, a conflict likely to persist.
Background
Texas law prohibits doctors from mailing abortion medication within the state, but Paxton also sued out-of-state doctors for prescribing pills to Texas residents. The suits were brought under HB7, which allows private citizens to sue those who distribute or mail abortion medication to or from Texas. Other states’ shield laws, which protect physicians who send abortion medications, complicated Paxton’s efforts. Johnson has said he will not pursue such cases.
Key Perspectives
Ken Paxton: withdrew the two lawsuits as part of a wave of withdrawals before leaving office in January.
Nathan Johnson (Attorney General-elect): said he would “cease using Texas abortion laws as an instrument of persecution and intimidation” and called challenges to shield laws “judicially absurd.”
Nancy Northup (Center for Reproductive Rights): called the cases baseless and designed to intimidate doctors, and welcomed Johnson’s position.
Galveston County man: filed his own lawsuit against Dr. Coeytaux under HB7, alleging he provided abortion pills to his girlfriend.
What to Watch
- The private suit against Dr. Coeytaux continues, potentially testing the limits of HB7.
- Nathan Johnson’s tenure begins in January, and his actions will determine whether his pledges translate into policy.
- The withdrawal may be part of a larger pattern as Paxton clears pending cases before leaving office.