The execution of convicted murderer Reinaldo Dennes in Texas took more than an hour, during which the 70-year-old inmate complained of severe pain, as lethal injection and the drug pentobarbital faced renewed scrutiny. State officials denied the execution was botched, and TDCJ said staff encountered difficulty finding suitable veins.
Dennes was pronounced dead a minute after the execution was completed, 63 minutes after he was strapped to the gurney. He was sentenced to death for the 1996 murder of diamond dealer Janos Szucs.
Witnesses said Dennes cried out during the procedure, telling the warden to 'go' before shouting, 'The pain! Go! Go!' He repeatedly asked God to 'take this pain' and complained that his right leg was 'killing me'. Reverend Jeff Hood, his spiritual adviser, said he had witnessed 13 executions by lethal injection but had never seen someone able to make complete sentences past 30 seconds. He described Dennes as being in 'tremendous distress'.
Texas Department of Criminal Justice (TDCJ) spokeswoman Amanda Hernandez denied any claims of the execution being botched. She said the two intravenous needles were inserted into 'the most viable veins available, in the left foot and left side of the neck'. Hernandez said Dennes made allegations of pain 'in locations where there were no IVs established and prior to any drugs being administered'. Asked by reporters if Dennes was faking, she replied: 'I think, yeah, there were allegations … There was nothing abnormal on our part.'
The drug pentobarbital has faced increasing criticism. A federal review commissioned during the Biden administration raised concerns the drug could cause 'unnecessary pain and suffering', leading the Biden administration to bar its use in federal executions. The debate intensified in September when Christa Pike survived an attempt to execute her using the same drug.
Dennes was executed on the same day another inmate was put to death in Florida. Gallup polling found support for the death penalty fell to a five-decade low of 52 per cent in 2025. In October, President Donald Trump cancelled Pentagon plans to live stream the execution of former US Army psychiatrist Nidal Hasan by firing squad following intense backlash. There have been 39 executions in the US this year, all carried out by lethal injection.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The specific details of Dennes's execution are likely to fuel legal challenges and public debate over the constitutionality of lethal injection as cruel and unusual punishment.
- It highlights the ongoing tension between federal policy, where the Biden administration banned the use of pentobarbital, and the rights of individual states to set their own execution methods.
- The case comes at a time when public support for the death penalty is at a multi-decade low, potentially shifting the political landscape on capital punishment.
Background
The US is one of few Western nations that still actively uses the death penalty. Lethal injection, introduced as a more humane alternative to older methods, has been subject to increasing scrutiny due to drug shortages and botched executions. The reliance on pentobarbital, a drug not originally intended for executions, stems from the difficulty states face sourcing execution drugs after pharmaceutical companies banned their use in capital punishment.
Key Perspectives
Texas Department of Criminal Justice: maintains the execution was conducted normally, that the IVs were placed in viable veins, and that the inmate's complaints of pain do not indicate a malfunction.
Death penalty opponents and medical experts: argue pentobarbital can cause unnecessary pain and suffering, pointing to Dennes's drawn-out execution and Christa Pike's failed execution as evidence of the drug's unreliability and potential for cruelty.
What to Watch
- Whether Dennes's family or advocacy groups file a lawsuit challenging the state's lethal injection protocol.
- If other states using pentobarbital will pause executions or review their protocols in light of this event and the Christa Pike case.
- A potential shift in the Supreme Court's willingness to hear challenges to specific lethal injection drug cocktails.