London's Judicial Committee of the Privy Council has struck down anti-homosexuality laws in Trinidad and Tobago, ruling that the colonial-era statutes were not in keeping with the fundamental individual right to respect for private and family life. The unanimous decision is the first time the JCPC has decided a case to decriminalise same-sex intimacy, and campaigners hope it will spark similar successful legal challenges elsewhere in the Commonwealth.
The ruling is the culmination of an 11-year legal battle brought by dual-citizen Jason Jones, 62, who had successfully challenged the laws in Trinidad's High Court in 2018 only to see that judgment overturned on appeal by the Trinidadian government.
Prior to the JCPC's decision, Trinidad and Tobago was among some 34 Commonwealth countries that still criminalise homosexuality under laws inherited from the British Empire. Under those statutes, consensual same-sex intimacy carried penalties including imprisonment and, in some cases, the death penalty.
The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago had argued that the law was shielded from legal challenges by "savings law clauses" that preserved pre-independence British legislation. Jones's legal team countered that amendments introduced by the Trinidadian government in 1986, which imposed stricter punishments, meant those savings clauses no longer applied.
The JCPC unanimously found for Jones. Lord Sales said the laws "cannot be regarded as reasonably justifiable in a society that has a proper respect for the rights and freedoms of an individual."
Jones said: "These laws never reflected who we are as a people and a nation - diverse, multiracial, and secular. They told LGBTQ+ people that we were criminals in our own country. That message ends today."
Lawyer Anand Ramlogan SC, representing Jones, called the judgment a "landmark victory for gay rights, equal dignity and respect for private and family life in Trinidad and Tobago."
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The JCPC is the final court of appeal for several Caribbean Commonwealth nations; its ruling sets a binding precedent for those jurisdictions and a persuasive one for others.
- Twenty per cent of the world's anti-LGBTQ+ laws are in Commonwealth countries; this decision could accelerate decriminalisation efforts in the roughly three dozen states that still enforce colonial-era statutes.
- The ruling affirms that savings law clauses, long used to shield inherited British laws from constitutional review, do not automatically protect discriminatory legislation.
Background
Trinidad and Tobago became independent from Britain in 1962 but retained the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council as its highest court of appeal. The "savings law clauses" in its constitution were designed to carry over existing British laws into the independent state, insulating them from constitutional challenge. Jones's case exploited a 1986 amendment that the government itself had made to the anti-homosexuality law, which his lawyers argued broke the savings clause protection.
Key Perspectives
- Jason Jones (appellant): Called the laws a message that "LGBTQ+ people that we were criminals in our own country" and said that message "ends today."
- Lord Sales (JCPC): Ruled the laws "cannot be regarded as reasonably justifiable in a society that has a proper respect for the rights and freedoms of an individual."
- Anand Ramlogan SC (Jones's lawyer): Described the judgment as a "landmark victory for gay rights, equal dignity and respect for private and family life."
- Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago: Argued the savings law clauses protected the law from constitutional challenge.
- Representatives for Jones: Argued the 1986 amendments meant the savings clause protections no longer applied.
What to Watch
- Whether other Commonwealth countries with JCPC jurisdiction, such as Jamaica or Barbados, now face renewed legal challenges.
- The reaction of the Trinidad and Tobago government: it may seek to amend the constitution or introduce new legislation.
- Whether similar savings law clause arguments succeed in other former British colonies that have retained the JCPC as a final court.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 11 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedA UK court overturned Trinidad and Tobago’s anti-homosexuality laws.BBC News: “A UK court has overturned laws criminalising same-sex intimacy in Trinidad and Tobago.”
- SupportedThe Privy Council ruled the colonial-era laws were not in keeping with the right to respect for private and family life.BBC News: “London's Judicial Committee of the Privy Council (JCPC), the Caribbean island's final court of appeal, ruled the laws were not in keeping with the "fundamental individual right to respect for private and family life."”
- SupportedThe JCPC decision was unanimous.BBC News: “The judicial committee unanimously found in favour of Jones.”
- SupportedThis was the first time the JCPC had decided a case to decriminalise same-sex intimacy.BBC News: “It is the first time the JCPC has ever decided on a case to decriminalise same-sex intimacy”
- SupportedLord Sales said the laws “cannot be regarded as reasonably justifiable in a society that has a proper respect for the rights and freedoms of an individual.”BBC News: “Handing down the judgement, Lord Sales told the court the laws "cannot be regarded as reasonably justifiable in a society that has a proper respect for the rights and freedoms of an individual".”
- SupportedJason Jones said: “These laws never reflected who we are as a people and a nation - diverse, multiracial, and secular. They told LGBTQ+ people that we were criminals in our own country. That message ends today.”BBC News: “Jones, human rights campaigner and appellant in the appeal, said: "These laws never reflected who we are as a people and a nation - diverse, multiracial, and secular. "They told LGBTQ+ people that we were criminals in our own country. That message ends today."”
- SupportedAnand Ramlogan SC called the judgment a “landmark victory for gay rights, equal dignity and respect for private and family life in Trinidad and Tobago.”BBC News: “Lawyer Anand Ramlogan SC, representing Jones, said the judgement was a "landmark victory for gay rights, equal dignity and respect for private and family life in Trinidad and Tobago."”
- SupportedThe ruling followed an 11-year legal battle brought by dual-citizen Jason Jones, aged 62.BBC News: “The judgement is the result of an 11-year legal battle brought by dual-citizen Jason Jones, 62”
- SupportedJones won in Trinidad’s High Court in 2018, but the ruling was overturned on appeal by the Trinidadian government.BBC News: “Jones had successfully challenged the laws in 2018 in Trinidad's High Court, however the ruling was overturned on appeal by the Trinidadian government.”
- SupportedBefore the decision, Trinidad and Tobago was among some 34 Commonwealth countries still criminalising homosexuality under laws inherited from the British Empire.BBC News: “Prior to this historic decision, Trinidad and Tobago was one of some 34 Commonwealth countries continuing to criminalise homosexuality based on colonial-era British laws.”
- SupportedThe laws carried penalties including imprisonment and, in some cases, the death penalty for consensual same-sex intimacy.BBC News: “Under these laws, consensual same-sex intimacy is punishable by imprisonment, and in some cases carries the death penalty.”
- Partly supportedJones’s legal team argued that amendments introduced by the Trinidadian government in 1986 imposed stricter punishments, meaning the savings clauses no longer applied.BBC News: “Representatives for Jones argued that the laws violated an individual's right to privacy and argued the government's changes to the laws in 1986 - which saw stricter punishments introduced - meant the savings clause protections no longer applied.”