The Immigration and Asylum Bill, described by Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood as the most significant migration reforms of modern times, passed its third reading in the House of Commons on Tuesday by 290 votes to 94, a majority of 196, and will now proceed to the House of Lords. Fourteen Labour MPs rebelled against the government, with Apsana Begum accusing the government of an 'utter betrayal'.
The bill aims to accelerate removals of failed asylum seekers by removing the requirement for immigration officers to provide five working days' notice before initiating removal. The draft law also seeks to reduce leave granted to people given refugee status from five years to two and a half years, and an independent immigration appeals authority would be created, which Mahmood said would make asylum decisions swifter.
A blanket proposal to increase the wait time for permanent settlement for people on work visas for low-skilled jobs was dropped earlier this month after a backlash from Labour backbenchers. Those on health and social care visas who meet conditions and earn at least £25,000 a year would continue to be eligible after five years. Home Office minister Anna Turley called the targeted exemption for care workers and other non-degree level public sector roles in health and education 'exceptional', adding: 'It's been done in view of their service during Covid, and since, in our recovery, when we asked them to come to this country and support us in looking after some of our most vulnerable people.'
Neil Duncan-Jordan, Labour MP for Poole, tabled an amendment to broaden the eligibility, arguing the longer wait for settlement 'risks alienating skilled workers that benefit the UK every single day'. Bell Ribeiro-Addy, Labour MP for Clapham and Brixton Hill, who opposed the bill, warned that settlement rights could be 'bought and flogged to the highest bidder' under the proposals. She said: 'For almost everyone earning under £50,000, the wait for indefinite leave to remain will double from five years to 10. But someone earning over £125,000 will just wait for three years. Settlement isn't being earned, it's being bought and flogged to the highest bidder.'
Turley rejected the amendment, saying it would exempt skilled workers from English language and criminality settlement conditions, adding: 'I do not accept that the country has a duty to let domestic abusers, shoplifters, sex offenders settle.' The Commons voted 44 to 368 against new clause 62, a majority of 324.
Apsana Begum, Labour MP for Poplar and Limehouse, also pressed the government to prevent the personal data of victims, witnesses or reporters of abuse offences from being used for immigration investigation or enforcement. She said: 'We know that hundreds of migrants who report domestic abuse have their details shared with immigration enforcement every year. These routine referrals allow perpetrators to weaponise immigration status against victims, providing abusers with a tool of coercive control and a means to evade justice.'
During the debate, SNP MP Pete Wishart accused Reform UK MP Sarah Pochin of 'quasi-racism' after she warned of a 'hostile invasion'. Shadow home secretary Chris Philp said the bill 'makes some small steps in the right direction', but added: 'Until we leave the ECHR and completely dismantle the legal system around illegal migration and foreign criminals, we will never succeed in controlling our country's borders.'
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The bill represents the government's most significant overhaul of immigration and asylum law in modern times, with changes to settlement rules and removal processes that will affect hundreds of thousands of people.
- The Labour rebellion signals deep internal divisions over the direction of migration policy, with backbench concerns that the changes could alienate skilled workers and harm vulnerable individuals.
- The bill now moves to the House of Lords, where further amendments and scrutiny could alter its final shape, making this a key ongoing political story.
Background
The Immigration and Asylum Bill is the Labour government's flagship migration legislation, aiming to tighten the system after years of rising asylum claims and cross-party debate on border control. The government dropped a blanket proposal to increase settlement wait times for low-skilled workers on visas after backlash from its own backbenches. The bill is set to receive further scrutiny in the House of Lords.
Key Perspectives
Shabana Mahmood (Home Secretary): described the bill as the 'most significant migration reforms of modern times', saying it would shut 'loopholes that have been exploited' within the legal framework.
Bell Ribeiro-Addy (Labour MP, opposed): warned settlement rights could be 'bought and flogged to the highest bidder' and argued the changes double the wait for indefinite leave to remain for most earners under £50,000 while those earning over £125,000 wait three years.
Apsana Begum (Labour MP, opposed): accused the government of an 'utter betrayal' and called for protections for abuse victims' data.
Neil Duncan-Jordan (Labour MP, Poole): said the longer wait for settlement 'risks alienating skilled workers that benefit the UK every single day'.
Anna Turley (Home Office minister): said the targeted exemption for care workers was 'exceptional' and argued against broadening eligibility because of English language and criminality conditions.
Chris Philp (Shadow home secretary): said the bill 'makes some small steps in the right direction' but argued that leaving the ECHR is needed to control borders.
Pete Wishart (SNP MP): accused Sarah Pochin of 'quasi-racism' after her remarks about a 'hostile invasion'.
What to Watch
- The House of Lords scrutiny process, where amendments and challenges could reshape key provisions.
- Whether the government faces further backbench pressure over settlement rules for skilled workers after the defeat of Duncan-Jordan's amendment.
- The impact of the bill on removal rates and asylum processing times as implementation begins.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedUK immigration reforms passed the Commons despite a Labour rebellion.The Independent UK: “Reforms to the UK’s immigration system led by Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood have passed the House of Commons, despite a minor Labour backbench rebellion.”
- SupportedThe bill passed its third reading on Tuesday by 290 votes to 94, a majority of 196.The Independent UK: “The Immigration and Asylum Bill cleared its final hurdle in the chamber on Tuesday by 290 votes to 94, a majority of 196”
- SupportedThe bill will proceed to the House of Lords.The Independent UK: “and will now progress to the House of Lords for scrutiny.”
- SupportedShabana Mahmood described the bill as “the most significant migration reforms of modern times”.The Independent UK: “Ms Mahmood described the Bill as the "most significant migration reforms of modern times"”
- SupportedFourteen Labour MPs rebelled against the government at the third reading.The Independent UK: “Fourteen Labour MPs rebelled at the third reading to oppose the legislation”
- SupportedApsana Begum accused the government of an “utter betrayal”.The Independent UK: “Apsana Begum, who joined her in opposing the Bill, accused the Government of an "utter betrayal".”
- SupportedThe bill would accelerate removals of failed asylum seekers by removing the five-working-days’ notice requirement before removal proceedings begin.The Independent UK: “Under the plans, removals of failed asylum seekers would be accelerated, with immigration officers no longer required to provide five working days’ notice before initiating the removal process.”
- SupportedThe draft law would reduce leave for people granted refugee status from five years to two and a half years.The Independent UK: “The draft law also seeks to reduce the leave granted to people given refugee status from five years to two-and-a-half years.”
- SupportedThe bill would create an independent immigration appeals authority, which Mahmood said would make asylum decisions swifter.The Independent UK: “An independent immigration appeals authority would also be created under the legislation, which Ms Mahmood said would make "asylum decisions swifter".”
- SupportedThe proposal to increase the settlement wait for people on low-skilled work visas was dropped earlier this month after a backlash from Labour backbenchers.The Independent UK: “A blanket proposal to increase the wait time for permanent settlement for people on work visas for low-skilled jobs was dropped by the Government earlier this month, following a backlash from its own backbenches.”
- SupportedPeople on health and social care visas who meet their visa conditions and earn at least £25,000 a year would remain eligible for settlement after five years.The Independent UK: “Therefore, those on health and social care visas who meet their visa conditions and earn at least £25,000 a year would continue to be eligible after five years in the UK.”
- SupportedAnna Turley called the exemption for care workers and other non-degree-level public-sector roles in health and education “exceptional”.The Independent UK: “Home Office minister Anna Turley said the “targeted exemption for care workers and other non-degree level public sector roles in health and education” was “exceptional”.”