A federal judge in New York has rejected a bid by US subsidiaries of FIFA to block UEFA from gathering evidence tied to FIFA President Gianni Infantino's proposal to sell minority stakes in the World Cup and other tournaments to private investors, a plan that was abandoned in August after fierce backlash.
Judge Jeannette Vargas of the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York ruled on Thursday that the US FIFA parties had no "direct, substantial and legally protectable interest" in the case, which is aimed at Infantino and his dealings. UEFA filed for discovery in August with the intent of removing Infantino from office and has said it will file a criminal complaint in Switzerland if it finds evidence of financial wrongdoing.
The ruling allows UEFA to request the right to obtain documents tied to the FIFA Forward Enterprise (FFE) proposal from JP Morgan and Thrive Capital, the investment firm owned by Joshua Kushner, brother of US President Donald Trump's son-in-law Jared Kushner and son of US Ambassador to France Charles Kushner. Two FIFA subsidiaries had sought to block the discovery, but Vargas wrote: “Nothing in this record indicates that the US FIFA parties, or even FIFA itself, will be parties in the contemplated criminal proceedings.”
Infantino came under intense fire in July when he unveiled the FFE plan to manage FIFA's commercial interests in the World Cup and other competitions by allowing private investors to purchase minority stakes. Three continental soccer confederations rejected the plan, and UEFA threatened to boycott future FIFA tournaments if it was not scrapped. FIFA's 211 member federations were offered $20 million (€18.1 million) payments each to approve the project. Infantino initially pushed back but was forced to abandon the plan in August.
UEFA has continued to push for Infantino's ouster and demanded answers about the details of the scheme, including how Thrive was selected to head the investor group. In what is the biggest challenge Infantino has faced in his 11-year stint as head of FIFA, UEFA has filed requests for discovery in multiple states. Infantino has been accused of seeking retribution against those opposed to his leadership; in September, FIFA told a judge in Florida that UEFA's legal pursuits amount to harassment.
Infantino plans to run for reelection as FIFA president and must pass an eligibility and integrity check conducted by a FIFA-appointed panel. So far, only Japan's Kohzo Tashima has declared his candidacy. The deadline to declare is Wednesday, 18 November. UEFA is expected to propose another challenger and is trying to get FIFA Head of Global Development and former Arsenal coach Arsene Wenger to stand against Infantino.
FIFA lawyers countered the ruling by saying: "The court has not addressed the merits of UEFA's application and no documents are required to be produced."
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The ruling clears a legal path for UEFA to gather evidence about a plan that would have transformed FIFA's ownership structure, potentially exposing financial misconduct by the sport's most powerful figure.
- The challenge to Infantino's leadership, the most serious in his 11-year tenure, could reshape global soccer governance if UEFA succeeds in having him removed or in fielding a credible challenger before next Wednesday's candidacy deadline.
- The involvement of JP Morgan and Thrive Capital, whose owner is tied to the US president's family, adds a political dimension that could draw in wider scrutiny.
Background
Infantino's FIFA Forward Enterprise proposal, which became public in July, would have allowed private investors to buy minority stakes in the World Cup and other tournaments. It was met with immediate opposition from three continental confederations and threats of a boycott from UEFA. Infantino abandoned the plan in August after FIFA's member federations were offered $20 million each to approve it. UEFA has since pursued legal action in multiple US states to gather evidence of potential financial wrongdoing by Infantino, who has led FIFA since 2016.
Key Perspectives
- Judge Jeannette Vargas: Ruled that the US FIFA subsidiaries had no "direct, substantial and legally protectable interest" in the case, which is aimed at Infantino, and that nothing in the record suggests they would be defendants in any contemplated Swiss criminal proceedings.
- FIFA lawyers: Argued that "the court has not addressed the merits of UEFA's application and no documents are required to be produced."
- UEFA: Has said it will file a criminal complaint in Switzerland if it finds evidence of financial wrongdoing and is seeking to remove Infantino from office.
What to Watch
- Whether UEFA moves to obtain documents from JP Morgan and Thrive Capital now that the court has cleared the way.
- The 18 November deadline for candidates to declare against Infantino for the FIFA presidency, and whether UEFA can convince Arsene Wenger or another challenger to stand.
- Any response from Swiss authorities if UEFA files a criminal complaint based on evidence gathered through the US discovery process.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedA US court rejected FIFA subsidiaries’ bid to block UEFA from gathering evidence against Infantino.DW English: “New York Federal Court Judge Jeannette Vargas on Thursday rejected a bid by US subsidiaries of soccer's global governing body FIFA to block Europe's governing body UEFA from gathering evidence tied to FIFA President Gianni Infantino 's attempts to sell shares of the World Cup and other tournaments to private investors.”
- SupportedJudge Vargas said the US FIFA parties had no “direct, substantial and legally protectable interest” in the case.DW English: “Vargas ruled they had no "direct, substantial and legally protectable interest" in the case, which is specifically aimed at Infantino and his dealings.”
- SupportedFIFA subsidiaries have no direct, substantial and legally protectable interest in the case.DW English: “Vargas ruled they had no "direct, substantial and legally protectable interest" in the case”
- SupportedVargas wrote that neither the US FIFA parties nor FIFA itself appeared to be parties to the contemplated criminal proceedings.DW English: “"Nothing in this record indicates that the US FIFA parties, or even FIFA itself, will be parties in the contemplated criminal proceedings," according to Vargas.”
- SupportedFIFA lawyers said the court had not addressed the merits of UEFA’s application and no documents were required to be produced.DW English: “FIFA lawyers countered by saying, "The court has not addressed the merits of UEFA's application and no documents are required to be produced."”
- SupportedUEFA filed for discovery in August with the intent of removing Infantino from office, and said it would file a criminal complaint in Switzerland if it found evidence of financial wrongdoing.DW English: “UEFA filed for discovery in the case in August with the intent of removing Infantino from office and has said it will file a criminal complaint against the embattled soccer boss in Switzerland if it finds evidence of financial wrongdoing.”
- SupportedThe ruling means UEFA can request documents tied to the FFE deal from JP Morgan and Thrive Capital.DW English: “The court's ruling means UEFA can now request the right to obtain documents tied to the deal from the US bank JP Morgan and the investment firm Thrive Capital”
- SupportedThrive Capital is owned by Joshua Kushner, who is Jared Kushner’s brother and Charles Kushner’s son.DW English: “Thrive Capital, which is owned by Joshua Kushner — brother of US President Donald Trump 's son-in-law Jared Kushner and son of US Ambassador to France Charles Kushner”
- SupportedThe FFE plan to let private investors buy minority stakes in FIFA competitions was abandoned in August after fierce backlash.DW English: “Infantino came under intense fire for seeking to set up FFE to manage FIFA's commercial interests in the World Cup and other competitions by allowing private investors to purchase minority stakes”
- SupportedThree continental soccer confederations rejected the plan and UEFA threatened to boycott future FIFA tournaments if it was not scrapped.DW English: “with three continental soccer confederations rejecting the plan and UEFA threatening to boycott future FIFA tournaments if the plan was not scrapped.”
- SupportedFIFA’s 211 member federations were offered $20 million (€18.1 million) each to approve the project.DW English: “The 211 member federations of FIFA, which effectively own the Zurich, Switzerland-based not-for-profit outfit, were offered $20 million (€18.1 million) payments each to approve the project.”
- SupportedThe deadline to declare a challenge to Infantino is Wednesday, 18 November.DW English: “Anyone wishing to challenge Infantino must declare by next Wednesday, November 18.”