Chief Judge Colm Connolly of the U.S. District Court for the District of Delaware issued the order on Thursday, blocking Operation Bluebird from moving forward with a new app that would take over the Twitter name. In his opinion, Connolly explained that the startup was unlikely to prove that X had abandoned the mark, and that X was likely to prevail on its trademark infringement and dilution claims.
The key evidence favoring X was its current App Store listing, which begins with the sentence: 'Welcome to X (formerly known as Twitter).' This single clause, written in the same font size as the rest of the listing, convinced the court that X continues to use the Twitter name in commerce.
The order does not block Operation Bluebird from using the word 'tweet' or the bird logo, which were not part of the dispute. The case is part of a broader legal battle over the legacy of the Twitter brand after X's rebranding.