The 188-year-old department store David Jones is reportedly on the verge of financial collapse, with its chief executive scrambling to renegotiate landlord deals as the retailer faces another rescue just in time for Christmas; even in the best-case scenario, its store footprint will be cut by more than half, according to people with knowledge of the matter.
David Jones chief executive Erica Berchtold, appointed in June, is conducting a review of the chain’s 38 stores and trading terms with suppliers and brand partners. People with knowledge of the situation say even in the best case the number of stores will be cut to between 12 and 15, with about 70 per cent of revenue generated by a third of existing outlets.
The Australian institution, founded in 1838 as a fabric and drapery store, has survived two world wars and the Great Depression but now faces a financial crisis. It was purchased by South African group Woolworths Holdings for $2.1 billion in 2014 and then sold to Sydney private equity firm Anchorage Capital Partners in December 2022 for less than 7 per cent of that price. Woolworths sold key properties, including the Elizabeth Street flagship in a leaseback deal that created a $25.5 million annual rent bill.
Berchtold, who was CEO of Mosaic Brands for just over a year before it collapsed, is among those scrambling to renegotiate landlord deals. A company spokeswoman said Berchtold’s priority “is to accelerate the execution of the business’s INSPIRE30 strategy and is in advanced discussions with key stakeholders about how David Jones is adapting to the ever-changing retailing landscape.”
At any point, British distressed-business lender Hilco has the right to call in receivers. David Jones has reportedly lost major luxury brands including Christian Dior, Gucci and Chanel and has struggled to pay some suppliers.
Retail trading conditions are dire, with department store sales at Vicinity properties down 6.5 per cent in the past three months. Business strategist Barry Urquhart told 7NEWS that “a boom Christmas trading period will not be a saving grace for David Jones. It will simply delay the inevitable.” He said the issue was “fundamentally capital inadequacy” and liquidity.
RMIT associate professor Carol Tan said the store’s heritage was no longer enough, but she was confident it could be saved “not in the way that they sell right now, but maybe less stores.”
David Jones is believed to employ more than 5000 workers across Australia and New Zealand.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- More than 5000 jobs are at stake if the chain collapses or is drastically downsized
- The potential loss of Australia’s oldest department store would remove a cultural landmark that has hosted Queen Elizabeth II and Christian Dior
- The case highlights the broader struggle of traditional bricks-and-mortar retailers against online giants like Amazon and Temu
Background
David Jones was founded in 1838 by Welsh merchant David Jones and for much of its history was the heart of Australian retail, famous for its fashion shows and Christmas displays. It was owned by the founding family for 142 years before being taken over in 1980. After years of declining foot traffic and heavy debts from its 2014 sale, Anchorage Capital bought it for a fraction of the earlier price in 2022. The chain now faces its most existential test.
Key Perspectives
David Jones spokeswoman: said Berchtold is accelerating the INSPIRE30 strategy and is in advanced discussions with stakeholders about adapting to the changing retail landscape.
Barry Urquhart, business strategist: said Christmas trading will not save David Jones; the problem is capital inadequacy and lack of liquidity.
Carol Tan, RMIT associate professor: said the store can be saved but by downsizing, “not in the way that they sell right now, but maybe less stores.”
Matthew Bailey, Macquarie University associate professor and retail historian: said department stores in people’s memories “hold very strong memories of a business that seemed to care about its customers.”
What to Watch
- Whether Hilco calls in receivers, which could trigger immediate administration
- The outcome of Berchtold’s landlord negotiations and how many stores can be kept open
- Christmas trading figures: sources say even a strong holiday season will only delay, not prevent, the likely outcome
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 2 sources: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedBarry Urquhart said, “A boom Christmas trading period will not be a saving grace for David Jones. It will simply delay the inevitable.”7NEWS: ““A boom Christmas trading period will not be a saving grace for David Jones. It will simply delay the inevitable,” the retail expert told 7NEWS.”
- SupportedThe company spokeswoman said Berchtold’s priority was “to accelerate the execution of the business’s INSPIRE30 strategy” and that it was “in advanced discussions with key stakeholders” about adapting to the retail landscape.7NEWS: ““Erica Berchtold’s priority is to accelerate the execution of the business’s INSPIRE30 strategy and is in advanced discussions with key stakeholders about how David Jones is adapting to the ever-changing retailing landscape,” the spokeswoman said.”
- SupportedUrquhart said the issue was “fundamentally capital inadequacy” and liquidity.7NEWS: ““David Jones cannot trade out of this situation. The issue is fundamentally capital inadequacy. It is about cash flow, or in short, bottom line, liquidity.””
- SupportedCarol Tan said she was confident David Jones could be saved “not in the way that they sell right now, but maybe less stores.”7NEWS: ““I am confident that it can be saved, not in the way that they sell right now, but maybe less stores.””
- SupportedDavid Jones is reportedly on the verge of financial collapse.7NEWS: “After 188 years in business, the chain is reportedly on the verge of collapse and looking for a financial saviour with deep pockets, according to The Australian.”
- SupportedStore closures are being floated to save David Jones.7NEWS: “The future of the nation’s oldest department store, David Jones, is under a cloud with store closures being floated to save the retail empire from extinction.”
- SupportedBerchtold is scrambling to renegotiate landlord deals.WA Today - Latest News: “Chief executive Erica Berchtold and Anchorage Capital partners who sit on the board of David Jones are scrambling to renegotiate deals with multiple landlords if it is to have a viable long-term future.”
- SupportedDavid Jones needs another rescue just in time for Christmas.WA Today - Latest News: “For the second time in four years, David Jones will need another rescue just in time for Christmas.”
- SupportedEven in the best-case scenario, David Jones’ store footprint will be cut by more than half, to about 12 to 15 stores.WA Today - Latest News: “Even in the best-case scenario, David Jones’ footprint of 38 stores will be axed by more than half to about 12 to 15, according to people with knowledge of the matter”
- SupportedAbout 70 per cent of David Jones’ revenue comes from a third of its existing stores.WA Today - Latest News: “with 70 per cent of revenue being made by a third of its existing stores.”
- SupportedBerchtold is reviewing the chain’s 38 stores and its trading terms with suppliers and brand partners.7NEWS: “A company spokeswoman confirmed to 7NEWS.com.au their Chief Executive Officer was conducting “a review of the portfolio of stores across Australia and the trading terms with suppliers and brand partners””
- SupportedDavid Jones is 188 years old.7NEWS: “After 188 years in business, the chain is reportedly on the verge of collapse”