French police accused of war-like injuries to teenagers in school protests

Interior minister confirms 36 investigations into officer violence as student movement enters fourth week

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time2 min
French lawyers and rights groups have accused police of inflicting war-like injuries on teenagers during school protests, as France enters the fourth week of its biggest youth protest movement in decades and police investigate 36 allegations of officer violence against demonstrators.

French lawyers and rights groups say several teenagers have suffered war-like injuries from police weapons used during school protests, and an unprecedented number of children have been held in police custody, some of whom reported being hit or racially insulted.

The interior minister, Laurent Nuñez, told the senate that police had opened internal investigations into 36 allegations of officer violence against demonstrators, including four children allegedly "mutilated" by explosive weapons and six sustaining "significant injuries", as well as complaints over physical blows, insults or alleged sexual assault.

Hundreds of high schools across the country have been blockaded during the movement, with students demanding the replacement of absent teachers and repairs to decrepit buildings.

Among the injured is Evan, a 15-year-old carpentry student, who lost his left hand, several fingers from his right hand and suffered further injuries when a police stun grenade exploded outside a school protest in Lens on 5 October. His lawyer, Bertrand Wattez, said: "His injuries resemble war injuries." Wattez said Evan had gone to school to attend class and discovered a protest under way, had not taken part in violence, and denied the state prosecutor's assertion that the grenade had been picked up from the ground. Evan remained in hospital and his family has filed a criminal complaint.

Eden, 14, suffered extensive facial injuries, including two fractures to his jaw and the loss of his bottom teeth, with all top teeth broken, after being hit by a shot from a grenade launcher near a protest in Saint-Ouen-l'Aumône, north-west of Paris. His lawyer, Elsa Marcel, said the shot was fired from close range, about 1.5 metres. "This is the equivalent of war weaponry," she said. The family has filed a legal complaint for attempted murder.

Video footage appeared to show Eden facing three riot police officers, with one officer hitting out in his direction with a truncheon and Eden kicking toward the police before a grenade shot was fired. An officer has been suspended and placed under official investigation. Eden's parents said he had gone to school but found it blockaded and wanted to go home.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • The injuries have intensified a national debate over police tactics during a protest movement led largely by minors.
  • France's biggest youth protest in decades has drawn attention to the state of its schools, including teacher shortages and dilapidated buildings.
  • The family complaints and internal investigations could become a test of accountability for police conduct involving children at demonstrations.

Background

France has a long tradition of street protest, and the conduct of riot police during demonstrations has repeatedly been a subject of public debate and legal scrutiny. The current movement centres on school conditions: students have blockaded hundreds of high schools to demand the replacement of absent teachers and repairs to decrepit buildings. The protests are now in their fourth week, and allegations of violence against teenage demonstrators have moved the dispute beyond education policy and into questions about policing and the treatment of minors.

Key Perspectives

Lawyers and families: Argue the injuries are disproportionate and that victims such as Evan and Eden were students caught up in protests, not violent demonstrators. They dispute official accounts of what happened, including the prosecutor's assertion that a grenade was picked up from the ground.

Police and prosecutors: The state prosecutor has suggested the grenade that injured Evan was picked up from the ground rather than thrown by police. The interior ministry has opened 36 internal investigations and an officer involved in Eden's case has been suspended, indicating the authorities are treating the allegations seriously.

Critics and rights groups: Point to an unprecedented number of children held in police custody, with some reporting physical blows and racial insults, and question the use of stun grenades and grenade launchers in crowds at close range.

What to Watch

  • The outcome of the 36 internal investigations, particularly the four allegations that children were mutilated by explosive weapons.
  • The progress of the family criminal complaints, including the attempted murder complaint filed over Eden's injuries.
  • Whether the student blockade movement continues and how the government responds to its demands over teacher shortages and school repairs.

Sources

Zotpaper

Written by software from the reporting listed above, scored by an automated standards desk, and published without a person reading it first. If something here is wrong, tell the editor and it will be put right.

How we workSubscribe