Israel's siege of Hebron displaces nearly 5,000, mayor decries 'collective punishment'
Military closes the city at ten entrances after a fatal attack; accounts cite limited accomplishments in the weapons search and legal concerns over prolonged evictions
Israel's military siege on the southern West Bank city of Hebron has entered its second week with nearly 5,000 people displaced, according to an analysis by Al Jazeera. The lockdown began on October 23 after two Palestinians shot dead two Israeli soldiers before being killed. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu ordered the closure, pledging to 'act to destroy this place.'
Al Jazeera's analysis, drawing on municipal data and human rights groups' statistics, places the number of displaced people at 4,969, across 780 families. The displaced population represents about 2% of the city's 250,000 residents. The displaced include 441 elderly people, 336 infants under two years old, 312 patients with chronic diseases, more than 200 pregnant or nursing women, and 44 people with disabilities.
The operation began on Friday, October 23, after two Palestinians shot two Israeli soldiers dead. The attackers were killed by Israeli forces. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu announced on social media that he had ordered security forces to close Hebron and prepare for a full lockdown across what he called Judea and Samaria. 'We will act to destroy this place, to change it completely,' he said.
The Israeli army said the operation aims to 'thwart terrorism' through searches, arrests and weapons confiscation. Defence Minister Israel Katz said Palestinians would not be allowed to return to their homes until Hamas's 'infrastructure' is dismantled. However, the Israeli news site Ynet, cited by Al Jazeera, quoted the army as saying that the search for weapons has had 'limited accomplishments' and that keeping residents away for a prolonged period faces 'legal difficulties.'
Forces closed off 10 entrances to the city, between 2.4km and 7.6km from the centre. In the Farsh al-Hawa area, a three-apartment residential building was demolished, a ceramics company and car parts shops were targeted, and approximately 7,000 square metres of land were bulldozed. Families in the al-Jalda and Ein Deir Bahha neighbourhoods were evicted on the night of October 23, ordered to leave via loudspeakers.
Hebron Mayor Yousef al-Jabari told Al Jazeera that thousands had been forced from their homes. In a statement to Anadolu, he said the city was 'facing a severe, massive siege and collective punishment.' The mayor told Al Jazeera on October 24 that about 2,200 people were displaced; Al Jazeera said the number had more than doubled in two days.
The Palestinian Prisoner's Society (PPS) reported that approximately 110 Palestinians had been arrested across the governorate over the first six days of the operation, including seven children. Hundreds of citizens were subjected to field interrogations accompanied by beatings and abuse, the PPS said. The military searched more than 500 sites.
The Hebron Chamber of Commerce and Industry estimates daily commercial losses at 12 million shekels (about $3.8 million). Factory production capacity has fallen by 40 to 60 percent, according to estimates by Adnan al-Natsheh. Commercial truck movement has completely halted.
The Israeli army claimed to have discovered a 15-metre-deep underground pit containing an electronic device near an attacker's home. The property owner denied the claim, saying it is a sewage cesspit situated more than 100 metres from the residences of the two gunmen.
The front page in your inbox each weekday morning: the lead, the picks, and why each one earned its place.
Displaced population by vulnerable group in Hebron siege
people
Excludes pregnant/nursing women (estimated more than 200, exact number not given in sources). Source: Al Jazeera, citing municipal data and human rights groups
§
Analysis
Why This Matters
The siege has forced nearly 5,000 civilians, including hundreds of vulnerable people (elderly, infants, chronically ill, pregnant women and people with disabilities), from their homes, creating a humanitarian situation.
The scale of the military operation in a major West Bank city, including the mayor's characterisation of it as collective punishment, represents a significant escalation in the occupied territories.
Internal reports cited by Al Jazeera of 'limited accomplishments' in weapons searches and 'legal difficulties' with prolonged displacement suggest potential constraints on the operation's scope and duration.
Background
The lockdown began on Friday, October 23, after two Palestinians shot dead two Israeli soldiers in Hebron before the army killed the attackers. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu ordered the closure of the city and said he would prepare for a full lockdown across the occupied West Bank, which he referred to as Judea and Samaria. The Israeli army said the operation aims to 'thwart terrorism,' while Defence Minister Israel Katz said residents would not be allowed to return until Hamas's infrastructure is dismantled. Al Jazeera notes the operation compounds a heavy toll across the West Bank: in September alone, the Hebron governorate faced 272 attacks, including 122 by settlers, and 19 demolition operations that levelled 91 structures.
Key Perspectives
Benjamin Netanyahu: ordered the immediate closure of Hebron and a full lockdown of the occupied West Bank, stating 'We will act to destroy this place, to change it completely.'
Israeli army: said the operation aims to 'thwart terrorism' but was internally cited as having 'limited accomplishments' and facing 'legal difficulties' with prolonged displacement of residents.
Defence Minister Israel Katz: said Palestinians will not be allowed to return to their homes until Hamas's infrastructure in the area is dismantled.
Hebron Mayor Yousef al-Jabari: said thousands had been forced from their homes and described the siege as 'collective punishment' against the city.
Palestinian Prisoner's Society: reported 110 arrests in the first six days, including children and former prisoners, and said field interrogations were accompanied by severe beatings and abuse.
Property owner: disputed the army's claim about the underground pit, stating it is a sewage cesspit and belongs to neither of the attackers.
What to Watch
Whether the Israeli military continues to expand the displacement zone or allows residents to return, given the cited legal difficulties.
Any legal challenges to the prolonged holding of residents outside their homes, particularly from human rights groups.
Whether Netanyahu enacts the full lockdown of the wider occupied West Bank that he ordered.
SupportedKatz said Palestinians would not be allowed to return until Hamas’s “infrastructure” is dismantled.Al Jazeera – Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera: “Defence Minister Israel Katz said Palestinians will not be allowed to return to their homes until Hamas’s “infrastructure” is dismantled.”
Partly supportedThe summary says “accounts” cite limited accomplishments in the weapons search and legal concerns over prolonged evictions.Al Jazeera – Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera: “the Israeli news site Ynet quoted the army as saying the search for weapons has had “limited accomplishments” and keeping residents away from their homes for a prolonged period faces “legal difficulties”.”
SupportedThe headline says nearly 5,000 people have been displaced by the siege.Al Jazeera – Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera: “Almost 5,000 people have been displaced as a result of Israel’s military siege on the southern West Bank city of Hebron”
SupportedThe lockdown began on Friday, October 23, after two Palestinians shot dead two Israeli soldiers and were killed by the army.Al Jazeera – Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera: “The military siege began on Friday, October 23, after two Palestinians shot two Israeli soldiers dead in Hebron and injured three others, before the army killed the two attackers.”
SupportedAl Jazeera’s analysis put the displaced count at 4,969 across 780 families, about 2 percent of the city’s 250,000 residents.Al Jazeera – Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera: “the number of people forcibly removed from their homes stands at 4,969. ... 780 families are currently displaced, representing about 2 percent of the city’s 250,000 residents.”
SupportedThe story gives the displaced population’s counts of elderly people, infants, people with chronic diseases, pregnant or nursing women, and people with disabilities.Al Jazeera – Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera: “441 elderly people, 336 infants less than two years old and 312 patients with chronic diseases. More than 200 pregnant or nursing women are also included, as well as 44 people with disabilities.”
SupportedThe PPS reported about 110 arrests over the first six days, including seven children.Al Jazeera – Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera: “Over the first six days of the operation, the Israeli military arrested approximately 110 Palestinians across the governorate, according to the Palestinian Prisoner’s Society (PPS). The detainees include seven children”